Cindy Kate & Percy Date Night Mafia <3 [ENDGAME]

[JaggedJimmyJay]

k

[JaggedJimmyJay]

“k” is not meant to be a top page post.

[Esooa]

I am watching Day 1: A strategic review of civilian Mafia

[JaggedJimmyJay]

lol that thing could probably use an update

[Esooa]

lmao professor jjj using the phrase "going ham on them"

[MacDougall]

I am watching Day 1: A strategic review of civilian Mafia

wait there's a video?

[Esooa]

I am watching Day 1: A strategic review of civilian Mafia

wait there's a video?

in jjj's bio

[Esooa]

I mean his sig

[MacDougall]

I am watching Day 1: A strategic review of civilian Mafia

wait there's a video?

in jjj's bio

ha... who knew

[Esooa]

It occurs to me that my typical first date experience is often a lot like my typical Day 1 experience in Mafia -- I feel like I have to do most of the talking to keep things moving, and it usually ends with me losing.

mine are awfully similar too. Uncomfortably so (thinking that I once tried to convince an irl friend I was town when we were really drunk)

[Esooa]

how many mafia are left>

[Esooa]

"maybe some(plural) 3ps"

flipped:

8 town
1 3p
3 mafia

That the 3p statement is plural, and there is one, makes me believe there is another

16-5-2

something like this?

6 mafia at most?

[Sloonei]

how many mafia are left>

The working theory is 2, but we have no confirmation of this.

[Esooa]

How does one catch Alison as scum anyway? This is not a rhetorical question.

Does Tangy ask things like this as town? I really hate questions like this.

What are people's reads on TSP?

Why is Made being voted atm?

[Esooa]

"maybe some(plural) 3ps"

flipped:

8 town
1 3p
3 mafia

That the 3p statement is plural, and there is one, makes me believe there is another

16-5-2

something like this?

6 mafia at most?

somehow I can't do math. That would be 17-5-2.

other possibilities

17-6-1

16-6-2

16-7-1

not impossible for 6. I don't know what the fuck the 3p is so if it'd balance the game towards more scum/town or not, I'm not gonna look at town power either but with 5/2 scum/3p we have 6 mischops in a 5 person scum team. That's about typical

[Sloonei]

How does one catch Alison as scum anyway? This is not a rhetorical question.

Does Tangy ask things like this as town? I really hate questions like this.

What are people's reads on TSP?

Why is Made being voted atm?

TangyStarkPrime is mechanically confirmed as Not Mafia, but is a 3P candidate.

Made is being voted because of a combination of POE and lack of content on his part.

[Esooa]

How does one catch Alison as scum anyway? This is not a rhetorical question.

Does Tangy ask things like this as town? I really hate questions like this.

What are people's reads on TSP?

Why is Made being voted atm?

TangyStarkPrime is mechanically confirmed as Not Mafia, but is a 3P candidate.

Made is being voted because of a combination of POE and lack of content on his part.

oh lmao. Their SoD1 is so scummy to me

[Sloonei]

@Esooa re: tangy

If I drop dead, Tang is confirmed town. Otherwise, she will drop dead instead and flip as scum, and I will be confirmed town. Stay tuned.

Roses are red
Violets are blue
Blood is also red
Spilling out of you


@Belzy has died!

Spoiler: show

She was a Town 1-Shot Desperado

The day continues. Please do not vote for Belzy. Any vote for Belzy in the poll at the end of the day will be considered an unvote.

"Desperado" is a vigilante role that dies if it targets a civilian, to those who've not seen it before. Belzy told us she was targeting Tangy. Belzy died. Tangy is mechanically confirmed as not mafia.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I’ll reserve judgment on Tony until he answers my question.

[Esooa]

I believe GG to be town atm

Alison scummy

[Garden Gnome]

I believe GG to be town atm

Alison scummy

why?

[Esooa]

Guillo's perspective is wack to me but in a town indicative way

prob

Yep I’m convinced.
Jimmy!Scum TMI’s Nutella!Town
This is an obvious pocket for scum Jimmy.

lol

Guillo's perspective is wack to me but in a town indicative way

prob

Yep I’m convinced.
Jimmy!Scum TMI’s Nutella!Town
This is an obvious pocket for scum Jimmy.

okay gavial

these kinda make me :s

Like... as if they both know he's wrong and think it's funny or whatever

[Esooa]

Act's posts are classically stilted. I have no actual view of what that means; I don't know them well. Not a town read anyway.

Act is an outed wolf if you ask me.

I'm not sure if scum!Alison opens the game calling someone an outed wolf if she's scum. I think this is too strong and negative-credit-bearing (if that makes sense) for most mafia to make. I will maybe look at past Alison games to confirm this if I care later

[Esooa]

my previous problems with Alisons SoD1 were

p#89 is a bit ridiculous to make and it's at a time Nutella is posting. Easy way to justify town reading eachother like this

and p#98 is just a bad read

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I did know he was wrong.

[Esooa]

I did know he was wrong.

No, from your PoV you would know you are town, so the statement is irrelevant. It doesn't mean it's untrue that, if you were scum, it would mean Town!Nutella. The way he is specifically wrong is if you're both w.w

[Esooa]

I continue to town read GG. She has too many posts with a decent amount of sentences talking about nothing (this is not a problem just saying they have nothing to do with the game)

GG I believe tries more to fit into a more stereotypical form of scum play, while her town game is well, talking about gardening

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I did know he was wrong.

No, from your PoV you would know you are town, so the statement is irrelevant. It doesn't mean it's untrue that, if you were scum, it would mean Town!Nutella. The way he is specifically wrong is if you're both w.w

I know I’m just being cheeky.

[Esooa]

@Garden Gnome I am shielding you until day 3.

@MacDougall why did you make this post

[Garden Gnome]

I continue to town read GG. She has too many posts with a decent amount of sentences talking about nothing (this is not a problem just saying they have nothing to do with the game)

GG I believe tries more to fit into a more stereotypical form of scum play, while her town game is well, talking about gardening

I'm poisoned and will die so I may as well talk about gardening.
Watch out for lesser celendine in your garden. It is highly invasive and will take over and crowd out all of the native plantings. It will have a terrible effect on the local ecosystem. To prevent that from happening, you're going to need to eradicate this invasive weed.

[Garden Gnome]

I continue to town read GG. She has too many posts with a decent amount of sentences talking about nothing (this is not a problem just saying they have nothing to do with the game)

GG I believe tries more to fit into a more stereotypical form of scum play, while her town game is well, talking about gardening

I'm poisoned and will die so I may as well talk about gardening.
Watch out for lesser celendine in your garden. It is highly invasive and will take over and crowd out all of the native plantings. It will have a terrible effect on the local ecosystem. To prevent that from happening, you're going to need to eradicate this invasive weed.

The best way to eradicate lesser celendine is to dig it up by the roots! Don't try to eradicate it with chemicals, especially Round up. That is highly toxic and will get into the groundwater. Also, it is carcinogenic, which can be a problem for dogs.

[Esooa]

[VOTE: Dana] aubergine

Do you think your read on Garden Gnome doesn't feature equivocation?

Not the way in which Dana is with their posts this game. Starting from Dana’s first post through most subsequent posts, Dana is equivocating. At some point, I think it’s safe to say there is some level of back and forth from players. It isn’t about a single post. Dana started off right away careful about appearing a certain way. Dana cared more about appearances and had a focus on how they came across to others.

I’m very firm when I say I can’t read Gnome. I am not offering a read on gnome so much as explaining to you why I will likely refrain from reading her. I don’t see it the same way.

Okee dokee.

You've received a healthy dose of criticism already. How do you feel about your haters?

Nutella is the person most strongly pushing actvscenei at this point. I think this would be an interesting post to come from partners here

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I’m going to personally forge Esooa a gold medal if she reads this whole game.

[Esooa]

I’m going to personally forge Esooa a gold medal if she reads this whole game.

oh worm?

[Esooa]

there are differences in how mac "does" chaos as town vs mafia but it's not necessarily a regular pattern ime

Mac called Nutella frozen then walked it back with a more curious tone in a different post referring to Nutella. He then said he chooses to believe Guillo found nutella/Alison scum already.

I believe if Mac were mafia his goal here is to create something that can be pointed to for anti-associatives later. In this situation I don't believe he has the idea to use a lighter tone implying she could be town

I'm just explaining this so people can learn how to read him. He's an easy read (and I believe town because of the above)

[Esooa]

Mac is going to say that I can't read him now cause I called him scum in 1984 which is not a game that any meaningful conclusions can be drawn from

That's okay though

[Esooa]

Nanook can you believe we're already both confirmed town and I'm still making us confirmed town even harder rn

[Esooa]

Mac absolutely hates being called easy to read

heheheheheh

[Esooa]

[VOTE: Alison] aubergine trying this out

[Esooa]

do I need to read Martin's posts? I feel like if he's town everyone should know it rn.

I'm going to take a shower

[Garden Gnome]

Well, I've just gotten onto Zoom, and I am waiting for my playreading group to start. We are reading Danton's Death by Georg Buchner. Probably not from poison or scum shot, but dead anyway.

Is there anyone who doesn't think that Made is scum? If so, who? And why?

[Esooa]

well looks to me like he's town so (martin, not made)

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I'll look at Made/Mac to see if there's a good reason to question that as a pair.

[Esooa]

Guillo's perspective is wack to me but in a town indicative way

prob

Yep I’m convinced.
Jimmy!Scum TMI’s Nutella!Town
This is an obvious pocket for scum Jimmy.

Sorry, I can’t make our date tonight, Percy. I read this post and started throwing up.

Why?

I understand most individual words that yall are writing, but the context seems like it's a foreign language.

“Player A has a more confident read on Player B than I do, it must be TMI” is not an inspiring read.

hmm

JJJ, I get the feeling Sloonei would want to upholster a partners look in-thread when they first enter it. This is the opposite. So I think it's towny from Sloonei

Do you think so?

[Esooa]

I genuinely think only nutella has a >rand read on Long Con and there's some chance even that is luck.

[Esooa]

I'm getting bored of this on page 14. I will ISO made now

[JaggedJimmyJay]

whatever this is all dumb lets chop made

[VOTE: made] aubergine

Do you actually scum read Jay?

And why Made?

Kinda feels like deflection here.

no I don't scum read Jay

do you intend to accuse everyone who introduces a new suspect as deflecting from somewhere arbitrary?

Just posting this juicy bit while I work. No thoughts on it yet, but discussion is open.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

hmm

JJJ, I get the feeling Sloonei would want to upholster a partners look in-thread when they first enter it. This is the opposite. So I think it's towny from Sloonei

Do you think so?

Yes. In general I think puking is a Sloonei towntell.

[Esooa]

hmm

JJJ, I get the feeling Sloonei would want to upholster a partners look in-thread when they first enter it. This is the opposite. So I think it's towny from Sloonei

Do you think so?

Yes. In general I think puking is a Sloonei towntell.

[Esooa]

there is no reason for Made to be a lone wagon. Lettuce vote Alison together