Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[Hally]

can someone explain to michelle why i’m a villager so that she doesn’t waste her energy suspecting me?

[Alison]

also I believe there is a chance michelle has mech on ted and is prohibited from speaking about it as part of her role card

michelle if there are subjects in this game you'd rather avoid please give this post a smile emoji.

[BoKnows]

masons right.

[Alison]

Also Hally is claimed masons with Mac. Nobody else has counterclaimed therefore they must be the real Peggy.

[Hally]

it’s entirely possible tony is a wolf. i’m just not really convinced by a lot of the reasons i see being thrown around though and it kinda feels like he’s just getting piled on

worth noting that "X is being dogpiled" means less than usual in a multiball game

true. i’m not going to stand in the way of him getting lunched

[Michelle]

Who was in Mac and Jay's Poe?

[Sloonei]

michelle is probably a villager btw. multiball caveat but her posts just feel like v!michelle to me

I was thinking the opposite.

[Alison]

Who was in Mac and Jay's Poe?

ted, tim, al sama, LC.

[Alison]

that was meant to read TSP, not tim. lol

[Michelle]

Also Hally is claimed masons with Mac. Nobody else has counterclaimed therefore they must be the real Peggy.

Was it hard to tell me this Hally?

[BoKnows]

Tim?

[Hally]

michelle is probably a villager btw. multiball caveat but her posts just feel like v!michelle to me

I was thinking the opposite.

why? i haven’t seen her wolf game in a while so i might be wrong

[AL_sama]

alison is lock clear. she can do what she wants

who do you want to kill today?

what makes you lock alison as town?? her play??

ted as I think he is scum and his flip will provide good info

alison’s play + claimed role ~never comes from a wolf imo

not liking this post

from what I've seen so far in this game this kinda thing should be pretty easy for her to do

what makes you say that?

say what??

what makes you say “from what I've seen so far in this game this kinda thing should be pretty easy for her to do”?

given the way how she is playing I think she is pretty up there hence why

[Hally]

Also Hally is claimed masons with Mac. Nobody else has counterclaimed therefore they must be the real Peggy.

Was it hard to tell me this Hally?

[Hally]

what makes you lock alison as town?? her play??

ted as I think he is scum and his flip will provide good info

alison’s play + claimed role ~never comes from a wolf imo

not liking this post

from what I've seen so far in this game this kinda thing should be pretty easy for her to do

what makes you say that?

say what??

what makes you say “from what I've seen so far in this game this kinda thing should be pretty easy for her to do”?

given the way how she is playing I think she is pretty up there hence why

i don’t know what this means

[Michelle]

michelle is probably a villager btw. multiball caveat but her posts just feel like v!michelle to me

I was thinking the opposite.

You make me curious

[Sloonei]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

Apologies if you've gone into it already, but why ted > TSP?

ted looks very aligned with marmot and also could possibly be on the other team

the consensus on tony is that if he’s a wolf he can’t be with marmot and would only be on the other team

so to me it makes more sense to lunch ted first

Would it not be good to try and Lynch someone from the other team first? That way we can start exploring who would be in it.

We should vote for the player who we feel is most likely to flip mafia.

[fingersplints]

Also Hally is claimed masons with Mac. Nobody else has counterclaimed therefore they must be the real Peggy.

Was it hard to tell me this Hally?

iirc from Mac’s role, it didn’t seem like him or his partner (Hally) are allowed to talk about it

[Hally]

has michelle been a wolf on the syndicate recently? i’ll take a look

[BoKnows]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

Apologies if you've gone into it already, but why ted > TSP?

ted looks very aligned with marmot and also could possibly be on the other team

the consensus on tony is that if he’s a wolf he can’t be with marmot and would only be on the other team

so to me it makes more sense to lunch ted first

Would it not be good to try and Lynch someone from the other team first? That way we can start exploring who would be in it.

We should vote for the player who we feel is most likely to flip mafia.

makes sense

[Alison]

Hally isn't allowed to talk about it, Mich.

[Alison]

I want like

4 exes. Or an exe and 3 vig shots.

Like right now there are so many slots I just want to get out of the game.

[Michelle]

Also Hally is claimed masons with Mac. Nobody else has counterclaimed therefore they must be the real Peggy.

Was it hard to tell me this Hally?

iirc from Mac’s role, it didn’t seem like him or his partner (Hally) are allowed to talk about it

Alison said she claimed, so she talked about that already

[BoKnows]

I want like

4 exes. Or an exe and 3 vig shots.

Like right now there are so many slots I just want to get out of the game.

rt.

is it too much to ask to have dom blasted into the sun?

[Hally]

i haven’t claimed anything

[Alison]

Also Hally is claimed masons with Mac. Nobody else has counterclaimed therefore they must be the real Peggy.

Was it hard to tell me this Hally?

iirc from Mac’s role, it didn’t seem like him or his partner (Hally) are allowed to talk about it

Alison said she claimed, so she talked about that already

Hally did not directly claim in an "I am X" way, but rather, hinted at it through indirect means.

[Michelle]

has michelle been a wolf on the syndicate recently? i’ll take a look

My last wolf game is on MC if you want to check it

[Hally]

has michelle been a wolf on the syndicate recently? i’ll take a look

My last wolf game is on MC if you want to check it

which game?

[Michelle]

Also Hally is claimed masons with Mac. Nobody else has counterclaimed therefore they must be the real Peggy.

Was it hard to tell me this Hally?

iirc from Mac’s role, it didn’t seem like him or his partner (Hally) are allowed to talk about it

Alison said she claimed, so she talked about that already

Hally did not directly claim in an "I am X" way, but rather, hinted at it through indirect means.

Got it, thanks

[AL_sama]

vote lynch ted

[falcon45ca]

[VOTE: VOTE TSP] aubergine

it was more than two paragraphs so I kinda glossed over it and then I played tetris instead

Quality posting from a town mindset right here

There are 2 scum teams. I'm happy with a Ted or TSP lynch.

I see, it's understandable

Can you give me one sentence for each one as a mini case?

Sure.


Ted's ISO is full of soft posts, that are hedgey & have little to no game solve attitude. One in particular that stood out "I'm not gonna work hard til later, maybe not then. Usually sometimes I can be towny if I want to"...that's a paraphrase, but it's what he said.


TSP has numerous contradictions and examples of him just clouding the POE & muddying the town waters in general. Seems to be both not taking the game seriously at all in a solve sense, but trying to stay alive. That's wolfy AF IMO

[Hally]

nook silent voted tony in case anyone cares

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME why?

[Sloonei]

Hally I will not read that, i have a life

okay. well then it’s hard to care about your defense of ted unless you have mechanical information suggesting he’s a villager

I note this as role fishing and put you in my Poe

once again, i’m lock clear

Proove it

Read mac’s role card.

[Hally]

sloonei, talk about mich? what are you seeing?

[Michelle]

has michelle been a wolf on the syndicate recently? i’ll take a look

My last wolf game is on MC if you want to check it

which game?

https://www.mafiacolosseum.com/threads/ ... -over.451/
I am WakeMeUp in that game

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

nook silent voted tony in case anyone cares

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME why?

I still think he's mafia

[Hally]

has michelle been a wolf on the syndicate recently? i’ll take a look

My last wolf game is on MC if you want to check it

which game?

https://www.mafiacolosseum.com/threads/ ... -over.451/
I am WakeMeUp in that game

thanks, i’ll take a look

[Hally]

nook silent voted tony in case anyone cares

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME why?

I still think he's mafia

i gathered that from the vote can you remind me why you think so?

[Sloonei]

tier 3: ehhhh
spf
jpic
nanook
bk
lc
Michelle

tier 4:
finger
kza
al
ted

unr: dom (but I think more likely wolf for reasons)

Let's talk about these tiers. Why are spf and bo stuck in ehhhh? A few minutes ago you said bo was probably town. SPF is a popular town read.

Why is nanook in tier 3 rather than tier 4? Why is fingersplints in tier 4 rather than tier 3? Why is Dom "more likely wolf"?
And lastly, have you given any consideration to how any of these folks would fit on either of the hypothetical teams?

the difference between tier 3 and tier 4 is not particuarly well thought out. I think Nanook is playing slightly in his town profile more here, especially in a multiball game. I generally expect mafia nanook to try to keep a hand on the wheel a bit more, and in a multiball game I think I'd expect that even more. As I don't see that, that's enough to raise him above a fair amount of the crowd. I just read Mac's iso and he said that he thought Bo was polarising or something. IDK. He's probably town. I would have had him in tier 4 before. SPF is at the top of tier 3 but I consider tier 1 and 2 to be what would colloquially be towncore (frankly I don't get all the reads there but okay) and SPF hasn't done enough to justify this assertion. I have done next to zero work on finger and honestly can't keep them and straw straight but my general impression is they fit on either team decently (I'm leaning towards not marmot though). Could be tier 3 but probably not higher than LC at least. I've thought about teams a bit but seeing as we have no information on one it's not a top priority. But people who I think are cleared from being teamed with marmot get boosts.

Prior to this TSP had his "BK scummy, BK maybe not scummy? Piecharts are wolfy, link me his scum games, BK prolly town" progression....



Which moved BK to "ehhhhhhh" status, not particularly well thought out difference between Tier 3 or 4, and some stuff about Mac's ISO saying Bo was polarizing, woulda been Tier 4.


How can BK be towny, but also be "ehhhhhhh, he's almost Tier 4"? It doesn't make sense from a towny perspective.

our good friend @Sloonei would tell us that hypocrisy is a staple of the civilian playbook

[Michelle]

Also I think i had another wolf game on MtGS but I subbed out because I didn't have time to play and a wolf team with me inactive would be weakened more than with me active

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

nook silent voted tony in case anyone cares

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME why?

I still think he's mafia

i gathered that from the vote can you remind me why you think so?

I've never been able to satisfactorily quantify a direct tsp read tbh. He just seems like he's doing mafia tsp things. Joseph stated it better, but I'm not digging through that many posts to find it.

[Sloonei]

michelle is probably a villager btw. multiball caveat but her posts just feel like v!michelle to me

I was thinking the opposite.

You make me curious

I feel like town Michelle is more open and responsive than you have been. I felt this way before reading the previous page where you suspected everyone who talked to you and recused to elaborate on things.

[Hally]

nook silent voted tony in case anyone cares

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME why?

I still think he's mafia

i gathered that from the vote can you remind me why you think so?

I've never been able to satisfactorily quantify a direct tsp read tbh. He just seems like he's doing mafia tsp things. Joseph stated it better, but I'm not digging through that many posts to find it.

okay

[Hally]

michelle is probably a villager btw. multiball caveat but her posts just feel like v!michelle to me

I was thinking the opposite.

You make me curious

I feel like town Michelle is more open and responsive than you have been. I felt this way before reading the previous page where you suspected everyone who talked to you and recused to elaborate on things.

i think the opposite actually. i think her attitude/obstinacy is villagery for her

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

Who posted? - This is a list of all members who posted in this topic
UsernamePosts
JaggedJimmyJay573
Sloonei460
Alison454
BoKnows440
TonyStarkPrime414
MacDougall399
Hally384
tutuu330
Esooa296
Long Con251
Justplayingitcool226
KZA213
tedxtr212
falcon45ca203
staypositivefriend192
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME156
Marmot152
Oddmerta122
Michelle114
Strawhenge98
fingersplints82
AL_sama53
novaselinenever7
Dom6
Master Radishes2

Who is lower than me in posts number except Al, who I know is low poster by meta, is suspicious for me.
No one talks about Straw and Fingers, can I know why?
Nanook is in the same tier because he is easy posting one liners as villager, flooding the thread with a specific kind of joy.

[Sloonei]

michelle is probably a villager btw. multiball caveat but her posts just feel like v!michelle to me

I was thinking the opposite.

You make me curious

I feel like town Michelle is more open and responsive than you have been. I felt this way before reading the previous page where you suspected everyone who talked to you and recused to elaborate on things.

i think the opposite actually. i think her attitude/obstinacy is villagery for her

I don’t think I have ever seen it to this degree from Michelle. The nearest parallel I can think of is when she OMGUS’d everyone who suspected her in Champs.

[falcon45ca]

Spoiler: show

Who posted? - This is a list of all members who posted in this topic
UsernamePosts
JaggedJimmyJay573
Sloonei460
Alison454
BoKnows440
TonyStarkPrime414
MacDougall399
Hally384
tutuu330
Esooa296
Long Con251
Justplayingitcool226
KZA213
tedxtr212
falcon45ca203
staypositivefriend192
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME156
Marmot152
Oddmerta122
Michelle114
Strawhenge98
fingersplints82
AL_sama53
novaselinenever7
Dom6
Master Radishes2

Who is lower than me in posts number except Al, who I know is low poster by meta, is suspicious for me.
No one talks about Straw and Fingers, can I know why?
Nanook is in the same tier because he is easy posting one liners as villager, flooding the thread with a specific kind of joy.

Finger is in my POE. Straw no, based off post tone & quality.

[Justplayingitcool]

michelle is probably a villager btw. multiball caveat but her posts just feel like v!michelle to me

I was thinking the opposite.

You make me curious

I feel like town Michelle is more open and responsive than you have been. I felt this way before reading the previous page where you suspected everyone who talked to you and recused to elaborate on things.

Disagree. That makes me think she is town even more.

[Michelle]

michelle is probably a villager btw. multiball caveat but her posts just feel like v!michelle to me

I was thinking the opposite.

You make me curious

I feel like town Michelle is more open and responsive than you have been. I felt this way before reading the previous page where you suspected everyone who talked to you and recused to elaborate on things.

I can't read the thread so I forced reactions, whether you saw me previously doing this or not, it's not good to explain in detail what I'm doing because this nullifies my intention.
Anyway, I am ready with stirring the thread for now

[fingersplints]

Spoiler: show

Who posted? - This is a list of all members who posted in this topic
UsernamePosts
JaggedJimmyJay573
Sloonei460
Alison454
BoKnows440
TonyStarkPrime414
MacDougall399
Hally384
tutuu330
Esooa296
Long Con251
Justplayingitcool226
KZA213
tedxtr212
falcon45ca203
staypositivefriend192
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME156
Marmot152
Oddmerta122
Michelle114
Strawhenge98
fingersplints82
AL_sama53
novaselinenever7
Dom6
Master Radishes2

Who is lower than me in posts number except Al, who I know is low poster by meta, is suspicious for me.
No one talks about Straw and Fingers, can I know why?
Nanook is in the same tier because he is easy posting one liners as villager, flooding the thread with a specific kind of joy.

Im probably not the one you were looking to to answer this, but we are both returning from a long break, so the quantity of our posting isn’t much of a surprise to many in a game of this size. I feel I’ve been talked about quite a bit lately. There is just stronger suspects right now.