The Syndicate

Elo, your interaction with MP is not wholly relevant to my suspicion of you. Did you read my accusations?

If you're asking would I be willing to vote to confirm Epi was mafia then yes I would. i was just looking for your response so i could gauge whether you really didn't realize Epi is dead or milked the noob card. :p at the moment my top suspect is probably Elohcin. i'll re-evaluate everyone later in...

I don't think Epi's style is inherently suspicious. It think the points he's made have consistently been unfair and misleading. And his vote was really bad. He's a lot like old Mac for you RYMers. Also, I can't emphasize this enough. I'm certain that Epi is mafia. We haven't seen an Elo and Epi maf...

I think adam smith can be real helpful role to help catch baddies. I mean if you want to just catch one indy and lose the most helpful info role the civs have then poor old george will be on his own. i don't necessarily disagree with you. it wouldn't be too huge a gamble for that player to try to g...

Any RYMers able to provide insight regarding aether? I have no read on her. I remember her being quiet in early parts of the game when I played, but since she got NKed N1, I haven't really seen her in action as the game progresses. she has played at a slow pace consistently in recent games. it's a ...

I would propose that if Adam Smith is still alive (hopefully he's not Metalmarsh), then he should try to build a case against Malthus, who he probably targetted last night. This game doesn't allow role reveals, but I suppose he can come up with some reason to call him bad and then tunnel on him, no...

Honestly I don't see much point in analysing why mafia killed someone. That's WIFOM trap. And if we apply Occam's Razor, the fact is that Metalmarsh was a player who wasn't really attracting suspicions from anyone, and was being fairly active, voicing suspicions on others and showing interest in th...

i reviewed all of MM's posts to see what insights i could dig up. and i came up with very little. he cast some degree of suspicion upon all of these people: DDL Golden (town) Bass JJJ MP Elohcin but didn't go hard after any of them. he made that one big post against MP for the word "transparenc...

sanmateo wrote:i already said this a few times tho, are yall skipping over my posts? people do that in rym and i hate it

i think we noobs are going to have to scream a little louder to ensure our contributions are noticed. i don't think my stuff is getting read by most others either.

actually i hadn't realized the kills are specified by the targeting role too, so that helps. we know MM was killed by the mafia team, so that's something i can work with.

So many strange new rules! Nothing wrong with that. This one (not revealing night kill roles) affects me immensely though. I'm going to have to think about how to approach Day 2, because my style has been largely nullified.

Again, no complaint. It'll be an interesting challenge.

Elohcin, i wasn't vague at all. I explained in detail why i didn't like your vote. I can't reference the post on my phone, but it shouldn't be hard for you to find. Your name is underlined in it.

I don't think Epi's style is inherently suspicious. It think the points he's made have consistently been unfair and misleading. And his vote was really bad. He's a lot like old Mac for you RYMers.

Oh, cool. Hi Vompatti.

What's standard procedure around here for prolonged absence?

Because Dom

Pretty sure it was #79/Inception, sanmateo.

Jimmy jj- I quoted what I did bc I found you suspicious for posting that we should appreciate you more bc of your new role. ofc you would say that - everyone would but for me it is the fact you have to qualify yourself with that statement. i didn't mean you should appreciate me more. i meant you sh...

Jimmy jj- I quoted what I did bc I found you suspicious for posting that we should appreciate you more bc of your new role. ofc you would say that - everyone would but for me it is the fact you have to qualify yourself with that statement. i didn't mean you should appreciate me more. i meant you sh...

And 3J? I'm going to call his fluffy ass out too. and you're going to do so without addressing the points i made against you directly. you'll deflect attention back upon me and take the offensive because it's your preferred method for manipulation. i can see it down there in those words already. ;)...

i don't have the time or energy to redevelop every read of mine this night phase. so based on what work i have done to this point, here's a rainbow. MovingPictures07 Dragon D. Luffy Sloonei sanmateo Black Rock G-Man birdswithteeth11 Roxy Turnip Head Dom >> TinyBubbles << fingersplints acrosstheaeth...

just remembered to address this: That said, I still have a neutral opinion on MP, maybe somewhat leaning to the scum side. I thought the way he defended me at the start felt somewhat forced, specially when he made his first rainbow list and put me on the top and the guy who was accusing me the most ...

i don't have the time or energy to redevelop every read of mine this night phase. so based on what work i have done to this point, here's a rainbow. MovingPictures07 Dragon D. Luffy Sloonei sanmateo Black Rock G-Man birdswithteeth11 Roxy Turnip Head Dom fingersplints acrosstheaether Metalmarsh89 Bas...

Sloonei. you're asking your questions of people and that's groovy. keep doing it. but i haven't seen a read from you lately (unless i overlooked something).

who are your suspects? your town reads?

might as well look at Turnip Head 's vote for Golden too and ensuing explanations. so let's see what TH had to say about Golden before the vote. er-- I think it's pretty dangerous that people are taking the notion that one of the 5 players to kickstart the game MUST be scum as a foregone conclusion....

Sloonei wrote:Epignosis, do you have anything for real to say to Golden's and others' suspicion of you? And do you have any suspects yet?

as if he gives a damn

as requested by sanmateo. Metalmarsh89 and his vote for Golden prior to placing the vote, there is not a single moment anywhere in which MM expresses suspicion of Golden (unless he did so without actually addressing him by name). the first thing i see which could be interpreted as remotely accusator...

sanmateo wrote:what's your analysis of mm's vote, jay?

i had the mind to skip TH and MM because their votes weren't a part of the late-Day avalanche. but that's probably ill-advised, so i'll check it out and report back on both dudes.

i got the time zone blues. i miss so much of the fun. nobody is going to remember my posts when the sun rises.

given that i leaned town on Golden (and that read would have been expressed more strongly if i'd been here to talk about his behavior as the day was ending), i view all of the votes for him to be bad votes. it's not just that he flipped town, it's that i find that flip wholly unsurprising. ranking t...

Bass_the_Clever's vote for Golden:

"no don't kill me, kill that guy"

obligatory maneuver and probably meaningless regarding his alignment. i feel no better and no worse.

G-Man also voted for Golden. it's impossible to analyze his content, which is the most important benefit he'd enjoy if he's faking it. but for now i am not inclined to feel that way. i agree with sanmateo that it looks more likely to be town than not. through pictures he said he was deliberating bet...

Elohcin and her interactions with Golden prior to her vote for him: In fact, I'd suggest that what Jay has experienced is a culture in which mostly the baddies try to look good. In contrast, I think the practice that has developed more strongly here (and at the contributing sites that make up 'here...

Epignosis and his interaction with Golden prior to placing a vote for him: for much of Day 1, there was no interaction. the only moments in former half-plus of his post history in which Epignosis acknowledges the existence of Golden are these meaningless little posts: Epignosis is going to hate me ...

Golden: Most of his posts were about forum culture, and the activity on me and the other newbies. Voiced a suspicion on sanmateo, but hasn't really pursued it after that. Feels like someone who is tring to help, but hasn't really contributed that much in scumhunt. I'm pretty neutal on him. in DDL's...

G-Man, whether you're screwing around or not, i love the effort in your rebus posts. always a delight.

anyway, i'm home. time to see just how much sense these Golden votes made.

There were a few terrible Golden votes and i am looking forward to shredding them when i get home.

I don't think Epignosis has made a single good point in this game and his Golden vote is nonsense. So I'm definitely on board with making him dead.

Might be my only chance to vote at work before the deadline. Voting for Bass_the_Clever why them over elohcin or epi? I have less conviction for my suspicion of Eloh than the other two. With Epi i can at least ask myself "is it necessary for mafia Epi to carry on this much to get a townie lync...

Might be my only chance to vote at work before the deadline.

Voting for Bass_the_Clever

I think MP would be a terrible lynch and i think the case against him is mostly crap.

Let's lynch Epi or Bass. Unite under my banner.

I kept forgetting my password so had to keep retrieving it lol but I got Chrome to remember it this time :) Hello, have you been able to follow any of this stuff so far? What are your thoughts? What's your password? No substantial thoughts yet... I kinda agree with JJJ on Epi but I disagree with hi...

I placed MP highest because i thought he looked pretty organic in his responses to the interrogation perpetrated by numerous players at once. Nobody else faced that kind of pressure this Day 1, not even DDL or Golden. I also thought Epignosis's series of accusations was rife with complete B/S, which...

bed time.

everybody read everybody.

it's highly likely my vote will be on one of those three reds. i will not participate in a lynch of any greens.

tomorrow i am going to be extremely busy all the way through the deadline. so my contribution might have to be limited to dropping a vote when i must and bailing.

Turnip Head wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:CLIFF NOTES on all my ISOs:
Elohcin
Epignosis
I wonder if you realize how interesting it is that you have these two so close together on your baddie radar

unfortunately i don't. gimme the juicy deets.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:CLIFF NOTES on all my ISOs:

MovingPictures07

Dragon D. Luffy
Sloonei

sanmateo
Golden
Black Rock

G-Man
birdswithteeth11
Roxy
fingersplints
Dom
Turnip Head
> Metalmarsh89 <

acrosstheaether
TinyBubbles

Elohcin
Epignosis
Bass_the_Clever

forgot a dude.

CLIFF NOTES on all my ISOs:

MovingPictures07

Dragon D. Luffy
Sloonei

sanmateo
Golden
Black Rock

G-Man
birdswithteeth11
Roxy
fingersplints
Dom
Turnip Head

acrosstheaether
TinyBubbles

Elohcin
Epignosis
Bass_the_Clever

Day 1 ISO - TinyBubbles Especially TinyBubbles, since I asked if he was bad, and he never responded! He is a she. Dammit! Sorry, TinyBubbles, I even almost put he/she but thought someone said he somewhere. I must have been mistaken. I apologize! I hate messing up someone's gender. Lol. Golden, how a...

Day 1 ISO - Sloonei i recently rated Sloonei as the best townie on RYM. so there are a few things i look for with him. Sloonei , could you describe the strategy you hoped to develop with the approach you just explained to DDLuffy? when you say "get things rolling", what shape did you envis...

i don't think anyone has asked... are no lynches a thing here?

because if they are they're the devil.

Search found 36823 matches