RPG Mafia MAFIA WIN

#4151

Dolby wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:45 am
Urist wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:43 am tsp is outed and shouldn't be saved. if he's saved i'm going to assume it's by mafia
why is tsp mafia?

he isn't slanking

#4152

tsp is literally the easiest person on earth to read

#4153

Ironically that isn’t untrue. He was extremely active in GoV as Mafia.

#4154

actually i'm going to vote wilgy, pretty sure dunya's reads were correct or close to correct

#4155

Though I think if we assume Mafia TSP is healed. That mafia can’t act tonight as it’s the same cycle. Unless I misread how P1 works.

#4156

tsp holds the TS record for highest post count in a scum game (fallout 2)
i should know

#4157

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:51 am Though I think if we assume Mafia TSP is healed. That mafia can’t act tonight as it’s the same cycle. Unless I misread how P1 works.

yes correct

#4158

the team is wilgy / marmot / tsp +1 (sig?)

#4159

I'm still in the Twilight Zone

#4160

Mmm. I kind of doubt that honestly.
There is still actually a kind of large PoE.
I think I may be wrong about Sig though. I’m thinking the more I reread some people the more I like Petit as pretty good town lean too.

#4161

Syn not Sig. Sorry. I’m leaning on Syn might be town actually
Sig I’ll hopefully know to ihht

#4162

@NotAnAxehole do you have any reason to townread wilgy?

#4163

Dolby wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:53 am I'm still in the Twilight Zone

What is your scum list anyways? Is it just me?

#4164

syn has been obviously town but going after him for not dying n1 is crazy.
especially when the reason for why he'd be dying is... for being obvious town. he doesn't stop being obvious town just because he didn't die.

#4165

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:56 am
Dolby wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:53 am I'm still in the Twilight Zone
What is your scum list anyways? Is it just me?

I believe that the wolf team is

LP/LP/LP/LP

#4166

more seriously

LP/Wilgy w

Rask/Scotty/Syn v

Dya/Jack/Marmot less v

#4167

Dolby wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:57 am
LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:56 am
Dolby wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:53 am I'm still in the Twilight Zone
What is your scum list anyways? Is it just me?
I believe that the wolf team is

LP/LP/LP/LP

Ok yeah you are just scum. I don’t believe you are town reading the whole game. A lot of people this game have been very hard to read. That’s some mafia TMI pov if I’ve ever seen one.

#4168

Wait who is rask?

#4169

Dolby wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:59 am more seriously

LP/Wilgy w

Rask/Scotty/Syn v

Dya/Jack/Marmot less v

Wow I was making a joke that you town Read the whole games
But you actually do.
That is unironically just scum TMI.

#4170

Like I had to put in a ton of work to even reach the conclusion Duyna was town. Petit Scotty and Syn have also been hard reads. Wilvg is still an implausible read. Jack has been off and on scum and town posts. Urist is also someone you said was just fluffing

#4171

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 4:00 am Wait who is rask?

petit/LPP

#4172

Ok. I do really want to know your reasonings for those reads though. I want you to convince me that you actually reached those reads legit and don’t just throw names togetherz

#4173

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 4:04 am Like I had to put in a ton of work to even reach the conclusion Duyna was town. Petit Scotty and Syn have also been hard reads. Wilvg is still an implausible read. Jack has been off and on scum and town posts. Urist is also someone you said was just fluffing

rask and syn are from my home forum i think I can read them well

Wilgy's entire ISO has been harping on a illogical Urist/Dunya w/v read. I don't think that man is town

Urist and TSP imo are pretty equivalent in the tone that I get from them but also not w/w. Also similar contribution levels. I frankly can't say that I don't TR TSP more as a consequence of the existence of his wagon and your presence on it but I really don't like that type of read while you're still alive. They're tone and the way they express themselves leaves them as black holes

#4174

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 4:06 am Ok. I do really want to know your reasonings for those reads though. I want you to convince me that you actually reached those reads legit and don’t just throw names togetherz

like idk what to tell ya it's 1 am I am not doing full justice to this

rask and syn are doing typical rask and syn town things moreso Rask

Scotty's emotionally charged moments throughout the game have felt legitimate and towny, and I have had times that I've vibed hard with a read of his on D2 that I've come to the conclusion that the man is just pure. At the start of the game I felt that his posts did not hold under scrutiny, but the way he's expressed himself later outweighs that.

Marmot, Dya, and Jack, most so Marmot, have just vibed well to me in a towny way when I read through their posts. Jack hard defending TSP isn't the best but I can't help but think "towny" when looking at his posts. Whenever Dya has popped into the thread I've ended up liking what she's had to say, and the fact that she is trying to gain a complete view of the thread and the positioning of it's players whenever she enters.

TSP and Urist are just a mental black hole. It's hard to even evaluate them indirectly. Same with NAA but the difference between NAA and them is that with them I feel like I SHOULD have a read on them, yet don't

Good night

#4175

also LP I would love the chance to thunderdome with you today, go for it

#4176

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:45 am Honestly I’m thinking we should just all out what we are. It’ll make it harder for someone to slip an anti-town action through like a the warrior kills or healing a mafia of poison or role locking a town.

I was druid level 1 and either got blocked or failed my action N1.

I re-specced to paladin level 2 N2 and was not blocked, but also did not gain any CP because of that.

in hindsight I should have probably done warrior level 2 in order to shoot sig tonight, but oh well

#4177

Dolby wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 4:17 am
LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 4:06 am Ok. I do really want to know your reasonings for those reads though. I want you to convince me that you actually reached those reads legit and don’t just throw names togetherz
like idk what to tell ya it's 1 am I am not doing full justice to this

rask and syn are doing typical rask and syn town things moreso Rask

I am not sure this is true

#4178

i have hyper-posted in exactly one other game

i was town in that game, but it's a tremendously tiny sample size

#4179

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:55 am Syn not Sig. Sorry. I’m leaning on Syn might be town actually
Sig I’ll hopefully know to ihht

why the flip

#4180

Urist wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:57 am syn has been obviously town but going after him for not dying n1 is crazy.
especially when the reason for why he'd be dying is... for being obvious town. he doesn't stop being obvious town just because he didn't die.

no

#4181

urist gives me angina

#4182

maybe I should recommit to scum-reading tsp even though it doesn't matter today in any way

#4183

dolby and naa do be wolfing tho

#4184

also jack

#4185

i love marmot and want him to father my children

#4186

do you guys want to hear a cool song

#4187

scotty where are you, i think you're town now, let's be friends and win the game

#4188

Urist wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 3:56 am @NotAnAxehole do you have any reason to townread wilgy?

I think he's town.

#4189

Urist is outed wolf

#4190

ok i believe it's plausible that urist believes that in any game where I have more than X posts I'm a wolf

#4191

this is obviously very stupid and does not connect to reality but if you've only seen me play fallout and [ins x town game where I slanked] it works

#4192

like in 2 of the last 3 jobs where I was town I was a top poster. hell, in fargo i managed to get 500 posts and get chopped on day 2

#4193

I actually have a higher average posts per phase in town games in the last year than in wolf ones by a quick count (naa responsible for math)

#4194

ok that's all for this pop in I'm now going to slank because I'm town (and driving back to Ohio)

#4195

I wonder if Jack can actually read me or if he’s pretending for the camera

#4196

Seems to me that Dolby is the scummiest player alive but idk

#4197

Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 1:18 am
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 1:16 am the problem is it feels like honoring dunya means killing wilgy and like cmon there's no way killing wilgy is the thing to do on day 3 after two town flips
Mood.

At least I can honor Dunya by towncoring Scotty.

[VOTE: Jack] aubergine

#4198

I had so much to say last night at 7p, and now that day was pushed back and I just woke up I’m too tired and lost it all

#4199

I remember ISOing Wilgy last night and coming to the conclusion that he’s just a wolf. Look at his reads on D1. Someone else (marmot?) called them out as surface level and that’s the best word to describe them. I would even go so far as to say he gets confused in who he trusts and suspects. I’ll go into more detail later once I’ve had my coffee and did my morning routine.

Jack can also just be a wolf. That uberconfidence in his casing of dunya is easily motivated by a wolf agenda to try and take out a player that can be very beneficial as town.
I’ll do more looking into this later too.

NAA can also die.

The 4th can be aaaaaanyone

#4200

TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Sat Mar 19, 2022 7:33 am Seems to me that Dolby is the scummiest player alive but idk

I’m behind by like 9 pages but his behavior the last hour yesterday was bizarre in retro as I was reading it. For someone to be so adamant that LP was the lynch, he was the one that rolled his eyes and put the final blow in dunya’s casket. I’m gonna dig more into that, but it’s a bad look imo

Akshually it's an immersive table top social gaming experience, not an "rpg"