Philosophy Mafia 2: Electric Boogaloo

[Lime Coke]

I just got home and I'm eating but I have backread.

@MacDougall can you give me your world fartview as a whole with this game?

[leetic]

I'm not sure if a role that would go to a random player is allowed in a non-bastard setup, or if a role that works differently if it is on town or mafia would be included. The OP doesn't mention how tied votes will be resolved, only that a player will still die, which does lend some credence to MM's claim but I'm not sure if he's telling the full truth. On another note, falcon's posts thus far have not been inspiring.

[Lime Coke]

honestly does mac have a role where he has to keep talking about farts for no reason or is he just mafia

This is tough because I have no idea how to read Mac when he's fucking around this much.

[Marmot]

I'm not sure if a role that would go to a random player is allowed in a non-bastard setup, or if a role that works differently if it is on town or mafia would be included. The OP doesn't mention how tied votes will be resolved, only that a player will still die, which does lend some credence to MM's claim but I'm not sure if he's telling the full truth. On another note, falcon's posts thus far have not been inspiring.

I wasn't planning on sharing it, but given we could be heading towards a tie, I opted for full disclosure.

[Marmot]

Oops, I accidentally hit Submit

EBWOP: I also hate ties anyway, because it often leads to an obscure/unknown mechanic or an RNG resolving them, and I'd prefer if players just come to a consensus with their votes rather than deferring.

[cassandra]

god whenever people claim their roles it gives me an intense role to claim mine even though i know i shouldn't

[cassandra]

urge* to
anyway gn

[Marmot]

god whenever people claim their roles it gives me an intense role to claim mine even though i know i shouldn't

Too bad Nanook is postcapped and can't pressure you

[DrWilgy]

Wasing the thinking of Marmot not lying. Wasing of the claim to believing.

[falcon45ca]

I've scammed with Mac, and he never once farted.



I'd think he'd be less full of frivolity if he were scum

[DrWilgy]

I've scammed with Mac, and he never once farted.



I'd think he'd be less full of frivolity if he were scum

Ising the voting of [VOTE: Falcon] aubergine; Of the shit.

[MacDougall]

I just got home and I'm eating but I have backread.

@MacDougall can you give me your world fartview as a whole with this game?

note to self... don't make fart spam when mafia

[MacDougall]

I've scammed with Mac, and he never once farted.



I'd think he'd be less full of frivolity if he were scum

Ising the voting of [VOTE: Falcon] aubergine; Of the shit.

falcon is town

[MacDougall]

honestly does mac have a role where he has to keep talking about farts for no reason or is he just mafia

This is tough because I have no idea how to read Mac when he's fucking around this much.

fine I'll be serious for a minute...

[MacDougall]

Town

falcon
iaafr
Lime coke
Nutella

Prob town but weh

Jay
spf
Marmot
wilgy
Axe

Haven't seen them post

Anne

Kill in

Dyslexicon
Cassandra
leetic

if I've missed anyone they're null too I guess

you can flip me now

*farts*

[MacDougall]

[VOTE: dyslexicon] aubergine

*wet farts*

[MacDougall]

honestly does mac have a role where he has to keep talking about farts for no reason or is he just mafia

This is tough because I have no idea how to read Mac when he's fucking around this much.

firstly I'm town

secondly I have a green on someone

thirdly because of this I would self resolve

because the mafia know this there are mafia voting me

[MacDougall]

the awkward way cassandra has tried to sus me makes it probably her

jay/spf could be but just figure that out later

Nutella probably just derp town

[Lime Coke]

The Dizzy wagon is kinda interesting to me, with MR, Nanook, and Mac.

I'm trying to determine if that's worth jumping on or not.

[Lime Coke]

[VOTE: Dyslexicon] aubergine

Let's try it.

[leetic]

Town

falcon
iaafr
Lime coke
Nutella

Prob town but weh

Jay
spf
Marmot
wilgy
Axe

Haven't seen them post

Anne

Kill in

Dyslexicon
Cassandra
leetic

if I've missed anyone they're null too I guess

you can flip me now

*farts*

Why exactly would you want to vote us?

Anyway, falcon/Mac likely same alignment

[DrWilgy]

I've scammed with Mac, and he never once farted.



I'd think he'd be less full of frivolity if he were scum

Ising the voting of [VOTE: Falcon] aubergine; Of the shit.

falcon is town

Tell the why?

[MacDougall]

Town

falcon
iaafr
Lime coke
Nutella

Prob town but weh

Jay
spf
Marmot
wilgy
Axe

Haven't seen them post

Anne

Kill in

Dyslexicon
Cassandra
leetic

if I've missed anyone they're null too I guess

you can flip me now

*farts*

Why exactly would you want to vote us?

Anyway, falcon/Mac likely same alignment

been wolfy... haven't been town

[MacDougall]

I've scammed with Mac, and he never once farted.



I'd think he'd be less full of frivolity if he were scum

Ising the voting of [VOTE: Falcon] aubergine; Of the shit.

falcon is town

Tell the why?

ugh why you want me to spell it out

[leetic]

honestly does mac have a role where he has to keep talking about farts for no reason or is he just mafia

This is tough because I have no idea how to read Mac when he's fucking around this much.

firstly I'm town

secondly I have a green on someone

thirdly because of this I would self resolve

because the mafia know this there are mafia voting me

Can you drop your "green"? I have a feeling it's Falcon but I'll ask anyway

[staypositivefriend]

finding it weirdly difficult to get the energy to Make Posts, and i'm not gonna force myself to play if i'm not feeling it, so i'm probably done posting for the night. that said, i'm around if anyone wants any specific opinions/takes from me

[DrWilgy]

honestly does mac have a role where he has to keep talking about farts for no reason or is he just mafia

This is tough because I have no idea how to read Mac when he's fucking around this much.

fine I'll be serious for a minute...

Wasing of Mac the goofing; Ising of heating; Nowing the serious really?

Coward.

[MacDougall]

honestly does mac have a role where he has to keep talking about farts for no reason or is he just mafia

This is tough because I have no idea how to read Mac when he's fucking around this much.

fine I'll be serious for a minute...

Wasing of Mac the goofing; Ising of heating; Nowing the serious really?

Coward.

get rekt dude. I'm not gonna just die d1 to make a point.

[Marmot]

finding it weirdly difficult to get the energy to Make Posts, and i'm not gonna force myself to play if i'm not feeling it, so i'm probably done posting for the night. that said, i'm around if anyone wants any specific opinions/takes from me

Have Mac's Australian farts reached you from across the globe yet?

[Marmot]

Doing a Michelle thing, here's the current poll.

Spoiler: show

) cassandra
1
5%
Voters: Marmot
) DrWilgy
1
5%
Voters: ilario
) Dyslexicon
4
20%
Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, Master Radishes, Lime Coke, MacDougall
) falcon45ca
1
5%
Voters: NotAnAxehole
) JaggedJimmyJay
2
10%
Voters: falcon45ca, Dyslexicon
) MacDougall
5
25%
Voters: JaggedJimmyJay, nutella, staypositivefriend, DrWilgy, cassandra
) NotAnAxehole
3
15%
Voters: leetic, iaafr, anne


Not Voting: Sloonei

[nutella]

Mac looked 100x worse than Jay in that tete a tete and the fact that falcon is macsiding there is quite uninspiring for the bird man as well.

[leetic]

finding it weirdly difficult to get the energy to Make Posts, and i'm not gonna force myself to play if i'm not feeling it, so i'm probably done posting for the night. that said, i'm around if anyone wants any specific opinions/takes from me

What do you think of the respective claims of Marmot and Mac? Thoughts on Dyslexicon and Falcon?

[Marmot]

@MacDougall do you have plans to reveal your green?


@Everyone, we probably shouldn't be chopping someone who claims to resolve and has a green on Day 1.

[ilario]

Part of our role is that we're confirmed town to each other (like masons). If me and ilario are of different alignments, then the game is bastard and the rules explicitly state that this isn't a bastard game.

@ilario - can you confirm that this is true?

i'm p sure it is considering ilario mentioned talking in a chat and they share a vote (their slot is ilario/leetic in the poll) fwiw

also @ilario what was it that leetic said that may make Nook scum?

he explained it somewhere in the thread but it had something to do with thinking nook might have tmi on us

[MacDougall]

Mac looked 100x worse than Jay in that tete a tete and the fact that falcon is macsiding there is quite uninspiring for the bird man as well.

jeez louise

[Lime Coke]

[VOTE: Unvote] aubergine

I thought I posted this already.

[MacDougall]

@MacDougall do you have plans to reveal your green?


@Everyone, we probably shouldn't be chopping someone who claims to resolve and has a green on Day 1.

obviously it's falcon dude

[MacDougall]

I'm genuinely whelmed

[MacDougall]

[leetic]

I'm genuinely whelmed

You might as well tell us how you know he's town. Are your roles linked? Do you have BTSC? Does your role give you information before D1?

Also Nanook was voting Falcon for forever and I find it a little weird that both of you have a connection to him

[Marmot]

Spoiler: show

I'm not caught up. At all.



Who's got reads for me to sheep, or would it be better if J just swung wildly in the dark?

Wasin the working; Happening the here?

Ha, yeeting Mac; What of Mac is the case?

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine



Intuition

[VOTE: Jay] aubergine



He's bound to be Maf one of these times

[VOTE: Jay] aubergine



He's bound to be Maf one of these times

Why is this the time, captain falcon

A combination of probability & your less than towny posting

[VOTE: Jay] aubergine



He's bound to be Maf one of these times

Why is this the time, captain falcon

A combination of probability & your less than towny posting

Please expand on the latter thing

Sure thing.


You are not trying to form a towncore. I don't know that I've ever seen you have so few posted townreads before. You don't usually scum hunt, you town hunt. I'm not seeing that here.


Your tone is...off. I imagine it's tough to hunt for town when you already know who town is

I've scammed with Mac, and he never once farted.



I'd think he'd be less full of frivolity if he were scum

falcon has 6 posts today

Post 1: Nothing in particular

Post 2: Votes Wilgy who is asking what the case on Mac is.

Post 3: Votes Jay because he's bound to be mafia (I've disproved this logic, and also Jay happened to be voting Mac at the time)

Post 4: Followup on above

Post 5: Levels a better acusation against Jay

Post 6: Defends Mac's farting status



All of these posts are in some capacity defending Mac. Mac claims a green falcon at the same time. Yeah, I think nutella's right and this looks awful for both of them.

[MacDougall]

oh yes falcon and I as mafia just decided to do this d1 and then I faked a green on him. good read.

[MacDougall]

falcon and I have a chat... I have a green on falcon because we have a role that means one of us can get a green on the other. first in best dressed. falcon didn't join the chat for the first 36 hrs of the game so I used it and got a green on him.

[leetic]

I'd still like Mac to answer my question but you have to consider that if Mac and Falcon are both scum Mac just outed Falcon for no reason. I don't think he'd be likely to do that.

[MacDougall]

I'd still like Mac to answer my question but you have to consider that if Mac and Falcon are both scum Mac just outed Falcon for no reason. I don't think he'd be likely to do that.

see above

[leetic]

falcon and I have a chat... I have a green on falcon because we have a role that means one of us can get a green on the other. first in best dressed. falcon didn't join the chat for the first 36 hrs of the game so I used it and got a green on him.

What do you mean by "can get a green on the other"? What would have happened if Falcon was scum?

[MacDougall]

falcon and I have a chat... I have a green on falcon because we have a role that means one of us can get a green on the other. first in best dressed. falcon didn't join the chat for the first 36 hrs of the game so I used it and got a green on him.

What do you mean by "can get a green on the other"? What would have happened if Falcon was scum?

sorry I've just been saying green a lot

there is a shared alignment check and I used it on him and it returned green. if he was mafia it'd have been red.

[MacDougall]

I also waited ages to use it which falcon can attest to and only used it cuz he didn't arrive in the chat. I gave him ample time to use the check on me first.

[MacDougall]

essentially we are now neighbours and I have falcon as confirmed town but not vice versa

[leetic]

falcon and I have a chat... I have a green on falcon because we have a role that means one of us can get a green on the other. first in best dressed. falcon didn't join the chat for the first 36 hrs of the game so I used it and got a green on him.

What do you mean by "can get a green on the other"? What would have happened if Falcon was scum?

sorry I've just been saying green a lot

there is a shared alignment check and I used it on him and it returned green. if he was mafia it'd have been red.

That does seem a bit unbalanced in a game where roles aren't tied to alignment and millers explicitly don't exist, seems like it would be unfair for Mafia to rand into such a role. Regardless, I would definitely feel more comfortable voting for Wilgy or Axehole.