The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[Made]

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

[DkKoba]

i stopped reading btw i got overwhelmed lol i wanna eventually get to a point where i have good info on every slot but like - yeah i think made is a good lim today if not 112.

[Made]

Also hi Bo! CDC crew needed a 4th.

Hey MR. You got any reads I can steal? Don't feel like sifting through 80 pages.

When did you show up?



Also, hi Bo

literally this

like literally, literally. Hi Bo!

[Scotty]

Looking through 112’s iso…

There’s a few red flags

There’s no discernible progression of how 112 starts our scum reading Mac:

Hmmmmm.

Fuck.

mac + this guy scum

MR possibly scum but i'm not sure yet. he's forcing all his posts but consciously/knowingly so i dunno

[VOTE: 112] aubergine

that womp womp stuff was probably the wolfiest thing anyone's posted this game and you know it.

To this:

I'll probably roll with Mac for a bit don't really care if I'm wrong I can always reevaluate or die

i'm pretty confident he's town fwiw

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

you and him are the players i normally read well and am pretty sure are town

[112]

hi sorry, long couple of days. renovations in my suite are ongoing and it's stressful on top of general business

[VOTE: enderwiggin] aubergine

^because i'm 50 pages behind and will be going by gut until i catch up on enough details

[Urist]

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

dw man the wagon will be switched to someone with 0 votes at dl

[112]

Looking through 112’s iso…

There’s a few red flags

There’s no discernible progression of how 112 starts our scum reading Mac:

Hmmmmm.

Fuck.

mac + this guy scum

MR possibly scum but i'm not sure yet. he's forcing all his posts but consciously/knowingly so i dunno

[VOTE: 112] aubergine

that womp womp stuff was probably the wolfiest thing anyone's posted this game and you know it.

To this:

I'll probably roll with Mac for a bit don't really care if I'm wrong I can always reevaluate or die

i'm pretty confident he's town fwiw

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

you and him are the players i normally read well and am pretty sure are town

'that womp womp stuff was probably the wolfiest thing anyone's posted this game and you know it' was sarcasm. i don't even remember making the initial read and whether it was serious.

i am always on top of maintaining consistency when i'm wolfing. i'll only break the general rules and backflip like that from this player is x alignment to this player is y alignment without any progression when i'm town. i know i'm giving you a meta read on myself but it's the truth, so take it with w/e you want.

also i feel i'm a better wolf than you're assuming so i feel somewhat challenged here lmao.

[112]

Also hi Bo! CDC crew needed a 4th.

Hey MR. You got any reads I can steal? Don't feel like sifting through 80 pages.

When did you show up?



Also, hi Bo

literally this

like literally, literally. Hi Bo!

summy entrance from bo imo

[Urist]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

[112]

[BoKnows]

I see his face everywhere I go

[Urist]

Alternatively, made is w, koba is t, and two of koba's voters are w: sig, rondo, falcon

[112]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

i'm not sure why you think that but i will agree 2 and 3 exist within the realm of statistical/mathematical possibility.

[Urist]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

i'm not sure why you think that but i will agree 2 and 3 exist within the realm of statistical/mathematical possibility.

No counterwagon to a w elim means he's probably being bussed yeah?
This is assuming made is w which is probably not the case.
My actual guess is that he's t and there is only 1 w on the wagon... the rest are hanging back and letting him die

[Scotty]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

[112]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

Why would it be Mac?

[Scotty]

Looking through 112’s iso…

There’s a few red flags

There’s no discernible progression of how 112 starts our scum reading Mac:

Hmmmmm.

Fuck.

mac + this guy scum

MR possibly scum but i'm not sure yet. he's forcing all his posts but consciously/knowingly so i dunno

[VOTE: 112] aubergine

that womp womp stuff was probably the wolfiest thing anyone's posted this game and you know it.

To this:

I'll probably roll with Mac for a bit don't really care if I'm wrong I can always reevaluate or die

i'm pretty confident he's town fwiw

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

you and him are the players i normally read well and am pretty sure are town

'that womp womp stuff was probably the wolfiest thing anyone's posted this game and you know it' was sarcasm. i don't even remember making the initial read and whether it was serious.

i am always on top of maintaining consistency when i'm wolfing. i'll only break the general rules and backflip like that from this player is x alignment to this player is y alignment without any progression when i'm town. i know i'm giving you a meta read on myself but it's the truth, so take it with w/e you want.

also i feel i'm a better wolf than you're assuming so i feel somewhat challenged here lmao.

ok that you can identify what you do or not do as town is too much WIFOM.

It tells me you can replicate it as mafia, and it means nothing to me

[MacDougall]

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

by finding and pushing mafia while you're alive

[Scotty]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

Why would it be Mac?

Wait, I’m asking urist

[Urist]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

100%

[112]

Looking through 112’s iso…

There’s a few red flags

There’s no discernible progression of how 112 starts our scum reading Mac:

Hmmmmm.

Fuck.

mac + this guy scum

MR possibly scum but i'm not sure yet. he's forcing all his posts but consciously/knowingly so i dunno

[VOTE: 112] aubergine

that womp womp stuff was probably the wolfiest thing anyone's posted this game and you know it.

To this:

I'll probably roll with Mac for a bit don't really care if I'm wrong I can always reevaluate or die

i'm pretty confident he's town fwiw

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

you and him are the players i normally read well and am pretty sure are town

'that womp womp stuff was probably the wolfiest thing anyone's posted this game and you know it' was sarcasm. i don't even remember making the initial read and whether it was serious.

i am always on top of maintaining consistency when i'm wolfing. i'll only break the general rules and backflip like that from this player is x alignment to this player is y alignment without any progression when i'm town. i know i'm giving you a meta read on myself but it's the truth, so take it with w/e you want.

also i feel i'm a better wolf than you're assuming so i feel somewhat challenged here lmao.

ok that you can identify what you do or not do as town is too much WIFOM.

It tells me you can replicate it as mafia, and it means nothing to me

[112]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

Why would it be Mac?

Wait, I’m asking urist

I am urist.

[MacDougall]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

[Scotty]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

Why would it be Mac?

Wait, I’m asking urist

I am urist.

[Epignosis]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Don't know if you saw my request. Do you have a thing on Made I can read? I searched your posts for Made and Made is too common.

Sorry Made, you're a commoner.

[112]

[Scotty]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

[Urist]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

Why would it be Mac?

Wait, I’m asking urist

I am urist.

i don't think this is true

[falcon45ca]

how do I make my town flip more juicy for retrieving scum reads? flipping me is sub optimal, but I wanna make it more fun.

Whats the case against you?

[Scotty]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Don't know if you saw my request. Do you have a thing on Made I can read? I searched your posts for Made and Made is too common.

Sorry Made, you're a commoner.

I don’t know about Mac, but this is a little bit I found in his iso :

Spoiler: show

Made is a self professed towny slanker in this game. He is fine with sitting back and waiting for the “game state to change”. A lazy position for any alignment. He votes Syn, and then makes one pertinent post today analyzing the dya voters, narrowing it down to 3. Also slightly lazy

I don't really have much to say right now. Eod was a bad look for the people that put Dya over(ish....i'll explain)

If we're looking for our wolf, and syn is scum (or sig is scum for that matter) we're looking for the player(s) that hesitated voting with mac initially, then changed their mind maybe an hour or two before end of day. Depending the brass on the players who changed their votes at EOD will tell you how late EOD scum would of hoped off of Syn/Sig. late hop offs are >randscum on bolder players, while early hops are scum on more thread state sensitive players.

That's my hypothesis, gonna read end of day and see who shows up based on that

hello i am fresh from an EOD read

the wagon switch-offs happened in the last half hour and everyone seemed pretty gung-ho about following Mac

ted expressed hesitance, as did sig and TSP (TSP did sheep first)

Mac votes
then TSP
then Michelle
then Ender (? he says vote sheeped but didn't use vote tags, he voted according to the tally though)
then KZA
then Rondo

NANOOK, Epi, and MR voted without posting? or were they on dya before Mac?

imma do something radical here:
Michelle will prob flip at end of day, if you assume she's town, then even if you're wrong, we get a wolf at the end of day, so it doesn't matter like that
KZA is dead town
Mac is innocent child.

Nanook and Epi both voted before mac. Nanook voted before mac even put his read, so i'd argue he's not the pusher of the "let's chop dya" wagon. Epi voted once it looked like steam could pick up there, so wanna pivot back there eventually, but i'm not gonna for the purpose of this thought.

that leaves TSP, Ender, and Rondo. If the vote for Dya was a save, scum is one of the 3

Great! you might say. He suspects one of those 3. Doesn’t he?

Well, his vote has been just chilling on Syn all day, and Made has Made no strides in attempting to push any of those names nor defend himself.

I think he frozen af and ready to walk the plank

[falcon45ca]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

Why would it be Mac?

Wait, I’m asking urist

I am urist.

You guys ever seen Spartacus?


Me neither. It's always rented out at my local Blockbuster

[falcon45ca]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

112s a better wolf than that. What are you pushing him for is NAI from her

[112]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

Why would it be Mac?

Wait, I’m asking urist

I am urist.

You guys ever seen Spartacus?


Me neither. It's always rented out at my local Blockbuster

i'm fond of sportacus if that counts

[falcon45ca]

@BoKnows I said hi you asshole. Don't worry, we still tight homie

[falcon45ca]

If Made is w then I'd imagine 2 or 3 of his voters are w as well. Otherwise I don't understand how there's no cw atm

Voters: Michelle, tutuu, Master Radishes, MacDougall, BoKnows, Scotty, TonyStarkPrime

How likely do you think it’s me and Mac?

Why would it be Mac?

Wait, I’m asking urist

I am urist.

You guys ever seen Spartacus?


Me neither. It's always rented out at my local Blockbuster

i'm fond of sportacus if that counts

Me too, I lied about the Blockbuster. It was just a topical joke

[Epignosis]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

112s a better wolf than that. What are you pushing him for is NAI from her

Just to be clear to everyone from now until ever, this kind of argument means nothing to me.

If you give me a list of things I have to believe in order for a person to be mafia, fine. "So and so is better than this" won't cut it.

[Scotty]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

112s a better wolf than that. What are you pushing him for is NAI from her

I guess I don’t know what a “better wolf” looks like. The progression isn’t showcased, and so I’m supposed to just shrug and townread them for that?

lol I guess that was what Ted was tunneling me for all the way in the beginning of the game, so whatever

[MacDougall]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

why would he fake his meta in a way that makes him look more scummy?

[MacDougall]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

112s a better wolf than that. What are you pushing him for is NAI from her

I guess I don’t know what a “better wolf” looks like. The progression isn’t showcased, and so I’m supposed to just shrug and townread them for that?

lol I guess that was what Ted was tunneling me for all the way in the beginning of the game, so whatever

No it's fine and good for you to call things like that out. But 112 as mafia is very conscious of their progressions.

[MacDougall]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

why would he fake his meta in a way that makes him look more scummy?

she/her my bad

[Scotty]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

why would he fake his meta in a way that makes him look more scummy?

He’s a she {I think??}

And to make the exact argument she’s making.

[MacDougall]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

112s a better wolf than that. What are you pushing him for is NAI from her

Just to be clear to everyone from now until ever, this kind of argument means nothing to me.

If you give me a list of things I have to believe in order for a person to be mafia, fine. "So and so is better than this" won't cut it.

Thats fine but 112 is the type of mafia that townsides hard and is mindful of looking towny and being careful to do so.

[MacDougall]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

why would he fake his meta in a way that makes him look more scummy?

He’s a she {I think??}

And to make the exact argument she’s making.

As opposed to just not doing the scummy thing to begin with?

The thing is that 112 making a progression from scumreading me to townreading me without showing it or being overly performative about it is not just townie for 112. It's kinda towny for anyone tbh.

[RondoDimBuckle]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

why would he fake his meta in a way that makes him look more scummy?

[MacDougall]

To the point where the very thing you're suspicious of them for is actually what made me townread them to begin with.

[Epignosis]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

112s a better wolf than that. What are you pushing him for is NAI from her

Just to be clear to everyone from now until ever, this kind of argument means nothing to me.

If you give me a list of things I have to believe in order for a person to be mafia, fine. "So and so is better than this" won't cut it.

Thats fine but 112 is the type of mafia that townsides hard and is mindful of looking towny and being careful to do so.

112 is my parking space. I'm speaking in general.

[Scotty]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

112s a better wolf than that. What are you pushing him for is NAI from her

Just to be clear to everyone from now until ever, this kind of argument means nothing to me.

If you give me a list of things I have to believe in order for a person to be mafia, fine. "So and so is better than this" won't cut it.

Thats fine but 112 is the type of mafia that townsides hard and is mindful of looking towny and being careful to do so.

I’m not even sure what we’re arguing about here. Because if town 112 usually acts with a bit less logical progression than her wolf self, she knows that looks towny, so why not play to that towny side?

I hate it.

Anyway- this point aside- I have no big reason to town read her from her entire iso anyway

[MacDougall]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Don't know if you saw my request. Do you have a thing on Made I can read? I searched your posts for Made and Made is too common.

Sorry Made, you're a commoner.

I just found made scummy off entrances and he's never gotten out of POE. I only voted there because it was the only crossover point between tutuu's POE and mine. I have no idea why he has 7 votes aside from that ppl in this game be sheeping hard.

[112]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

112s a better wolf than that. What are you pushing him for is NAI from her

Just to be clear to everyone from now until ever, this kind of argument means nothing to me.

If you give me a list of things I have to believe in order for a person to be mafia, fine. "So and so is better than this" won't cut it.

Thats fine but 112 is the type of mafia that townsides hard and is mindful of looking towny and being careful to do so.

112 is my parking space. I'm speaking in general.

[Scotty]

I believe 112 is town tbh. What you are pushing him for is town indicative for 112.

Do you not think that metas can be faked if you know your meta?

why would he fake his meta in a way that makes him look more scummy?

He’s a she {I think??}

And to make the exact argument she’s making.

As opposed to just not doing the scummy thing to begin with?

The thing is that 112 making a progression from scumreading me to townreading me without showing it or being overly performative about it is not just townie for 112. It's kinda towny for anyone tbh.

Great, so the common knowledge is that that would look towny, so someone like you would think it’s towny,,

Thus completing the circle of life