If this is Alison speaking, you legit didn't do any of those things in GoC when you were 3P. In fact, in that game, you resorted to tactics that you open admitted to never using before -- thus, I don't trust any argument you make where you say you would or wouldn't do something as scum.Akemi Hazelnut wrote: ↑Fri May 07, 2021 11:09 pm Ok so this discussion is going nowhere but
1) if I'm worried someone is going to catch me as scum I have a few options, including pocketing, nightkilling or just plain ignoring them. Asking my partner to loverize them and then bussing my partner is a pretty absurd theory. It makes more sense to just nightkill you in that scenario. At any rate, I had enough clout in the game that desperation plays like that don't make sense regardless. You aren't exeing me on D2.
Poop had them as a townread, too, early on in D2, before sudden pairing me and H&V up as a possible V/W pair. I'll ask you the same thing that I asked Poop -- why did you suddenly have a townread on them coming into D2? What did you find that was towny? The reason I ask this is that they were practically ignored D1. Nobody really talked about them or talked to them.Akemi Hazelnut wrote: ↑Fri May 07, 2021 11:09 pm 2) If I came into the day planning to bus H&V I wouldn't out a readslist having them as a townread early on in D2.
So, you'd jump on it, even if it results in OUR death, too? This is why I'm skeptical of you doing it specifically in H&V's case. Chopping or killing H&V is just a roundabout way to kill me without having to call me scummy.Akemi Hazelnut wrote: ↑Fri May 07, 2021 11:09 pm 3) I think a lot of the characteristics you're identifying as opportunistic are like, just the way nutella and I play. We see scummy shit, we jump on it. If someone claims a night action that is absolutely anti-town, I'm going to vote that person until I get a good explanation for why they did it. I don't know if it's a playstyle clash or what that's causing you to view that as scummy, but I personally believe town should not hold back from making forceful pushes when new info crops up, or when someone makes a really wolfy post.
In general I think you're (as Mac loves to say) jumping the shark. The stuff you're saying is scummy for us is literally just the way we play.
- Hyena