Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Dec 08, 2020 3:48 am
it's kind of incredible seeing nutella town lead so successfully, juxtaposed with the reputation she had 4 years ago for being "wishy washy"
I don't think that was ever actually true though, I think it was just a meme.
This comment had me reading back at some of nutella's games from years ago.
One thing I can say is, I'm sure glad we did away with survival is a requirement for the win con.
Honestly the second most compelling reason to think I’m town is because Mac was incredibly obviously the jailor and the mafia fucked up obliterating him anyway
I may be relatively checked out of this game but I’m not THAT checked out
nutella wrote: ↑Tue Dec 08, 2020 2:38 am
oh fuck did she do it again
No, I only softed in Mysterious Universe because I had no idea that town knew there was a lost wolf. Softing in this context is much more risky because people do know that a lost wolf exists. Also like nanook says, Martin brought it up not me.
There's nothing that says a fake can't surpass the real thing.
Also my strategy this game has literally been "set up the GD thing, assemble a towncore, then slank and sheep nutella". That's just not a winning strategy if I am scum. If I am scum here I need to power wolf and redirect the exe to some townies to swing the game back into my favor. It's what I did after a poor scum opening in Mysterious Universe. Instead I farm out my vote to nutella which is just townsiding like crazy if I am scum.
There's nothing that says a fake can't surpass the real thing.
If the traitor is someone who didn't know they were mafia I'd think a likely player would be tuutuu, she's kind off dropped off and having just finished a game as mafia I could see the burn out
Also what is the logic of just shooting people right now? Whoever came up with thst has to be mafia like no way around it
Literally what just happened could so easily happen and we're down 2 civs that isn't sustainable especially without knowledge of what other KP mafia/3rd party has
sig wrote: ↑Tue Dec 08, 2020 10:16 am
Also what is the logic of just shooting people right now? Whoever came up with thst has to be mafia like no way around it
Mac came up with it himself iirc, he outed that he had a gun and said he was going to shoot someone
There's nothing that says a fake can't surpass the real thing.
sig wrote: ↑Tue Dec 08, 2020 9:54 am
If the traitor is someone who didn't know they were mafia I'd think a likely player would be tuutuu, she's kind off dropped off and having just finished a game as mafia I could see the burn out
"someone who didn't know they were mafia" -> what?
Like first of all that seems bastard because it's the host lying to you, and second of all even if it were true why would any behavior be AI given that the player genuinely believes they're town?
There's nothing that says a fake can't surpass the real thing.
sig wrote: ↑Tue Dec 08, 2020 9:54 am
If the traitor is someone who didn't know they were mafia I'd think a likely player would be tuutuu, she's kind off dropped off and having just finished a game as mafia I could see the burn out
"someone who didn't know they were mafia" -> what?
Like first of all that seems bastard because it's the host lying to you, and second of all even if it were true why would any behavior be AI given that the player genuinely believes they're town?
I'm half skimming isn't that what someone said the traitor was? Like classic traitor doesn't know they're mafia, but is if targeted by mafia type deal. Also that isn't within the realm of basted I'd think it's a classic role.
Maybe the mafia aren't just in the low posters and it's not that easy. Myo might still be one but I should read more into motivation rather than post volume. Also there's no way the traitor doesn't know they're mafia if they don't even count towards parity.
Agreed that he's sus. His vote on MrRadish feels overexplained.
I owe my friends explanations when I vote for them.
But I feel like you're reaching really hard for a reason to shade me. "Because he explained his vote" is a desperate reach.
Gives Kylemi town points, because your rationale is so flimsy it looks designed to cozy up to Kyle who's sussing me for an equally poor reason.
You seem to call out votes throughout the rest of the game without much explanation. I think a difference in where you're choosing do to that and where you're not is interesting.
Myo only suspects Flanders in response to Kyle's vote on Flanders, I could easily see that as scum thinking Flanders might become viable.
tutuu wrote: ↑Tue Dec 08, 2020 11:35 am
Why did we shoot chuck didnt he repeatedly claim the armorsmith thing before flanders and falcon (janitored town) died
Nobody reviews syndicate games afaik hosts have full autonomy
I dont know enough about the secret roles but if the obliterator is hard capped at 1 kp per night (or even less) the setup was definitely breakable with d1 massclaim imo
Thundercat wrote: ↑Sun Nov 29, 2020 2:47 am
I exaggerate a little, but NIK's reads all look something like:
Player A: Reason they're town but reason they're scum.
Player B: Reason they're scum but reason they're town.
Addendum, no confidence.
Thundercat, what happened between these two posts? Why did you drop your confidence level in NIK being scum, or am i misinterpreting your second post?
NIK is still in the would shoot category.
However he's also been the counterwagon to each of the last 3 chops, which includes two scum and a 3p. Also, sabie voted for him Days 1-3. Poly and Jack voted for him Day 1. These other occurences make him look more town.
Also btw obliterator role phrasing suggests multiple people can be obliterated a night. As does precedent for similar roles. So I would not assume a limit of one per night.
Thundercat wrote: ↑Sun Nov 29, 2020 2:47 am
I exaggerate a little, but NIK's reads all look something like:
Player A: Reason they're town but reason they're scum.
Player B: Reason they're scum but reason they're town.
Addendum, no confidence.
Thundercat, what happened between these two posts? Why did you drop your confidence level in NIK being scum, or am i misinterpreting your second post?
NIK is still in the would shoot category.
However he's also been the counterwagon to each of the last 3 chops, which includes two scum and a 3p. Also, sabie voted for him Days 1-3. Poly and Jack voted for him Day 1. These other occurences make him look more town.
We're not doing a massclaim until we know exactly how the Obliterator works. We also have no idea what the unknown 3P does - in Radiohead there was a scum role that punished mass claiming and a 3P role that also tried to collect town roles.
There's nothing that says a fake can't surpass the real thing.