Thunal33 wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 5:29 pm
I'm not actually sold on PSV anymore and I'm currently ISOing pyxxy to see if I want to go there. One thing that I thought of about the ping that PSV stuck me in her PoE was that if she were a wolf, she might have been *more* consistent to try to telegraph her change on me from townlean to PoE instead of just sticking me there.
I'm working under the idea that genny was being defended by their teammates via the lowposter argument, cause in general I find lowposters maf get protected more by partners than highposters
I'm gonna run through the last few hours of yesterday and see what I find
Don't think a wolf puts the lowposter packmate on the board in that thread context
On first glance that's the biggest thing that stands out to me from d1, one other item of note is that when genny was most in danger d1 (3 votes: Scotty, Kate, creature) her closest counter was Quin (3 votes: thunal, PSV, Creature). So, maybe he was the village counter to her after all.
I'm gonna work through the d2 votes and look at some interactions with PSV but it'll have to be tomorrow.
I don't actually think it's Dubz. If it were Dubz, I feel like the whole mafia gameplan would just be to lose. Kate scumread both PSV and Genny and had influence, so even if I didn't shoot Genny I think she would have been eliminated fairly soon and I think Dubz would know this. Then Dubz looks bad and has no plan to go deep, and even if there's a fourth mafia it would be really hard for them to come back.
Btw we started with 17 so a fourth mafia is plausible. I think it's either 3 maf and a 3p or 4 maf.
Dennis wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 10:12 pm
I'm working under the idea that genny was being defended by their teammates via the lowposter argument, cause in general I find lowposters maf get protected more by partners than highposters
I'm gonna run through the last few hours of yesterday and see what I find
Well that went nowhere but I am caught up now I guess
A) 2 mafia down, in a 15 player game that probably means there’s only 1 more, right? assuming there’s no 3p’s as nook ‘doesn’t like to party’
B) why did Kate die? Ability from psv to kill one of her voters or was Kate poisoned or something?
If the latter, makes me wonder if someone like falcon didn’t green check her and actually did something nefarious.
C) I wasn’t actually feeling the psv yeet and only tried to switch to get art. Didn’t make it in time
The poison thing is a tinfoil I have. Day actions are possible, but it's also possible one of Zenon or Falcon actually poisoned Kate night 1 instead of doing what they claimed.
Thunal33 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 11:06 pm
I don't actually think it's Dubz. If it were Dubz, I feel like the whole mafia gameplan would just be to lose. Kate scumread both PSV and Genny and had influence, so even if I didn't shoot Genny I think she would have been eliminated fairly soon and I think Dubz would know this. Then Dubz looks bad and has no plan to go deep, and even if there's a fourth mafia it would be really hard for them to come back.
Btw we started with 17 so a fourth mafia is plausible. I think it's either 3 maf and a 3p or 4 maf.
But dubz wasn't defending genny (I think). She could have turned on her today and been in an okay spot. Also sorry for planting my vote on you and promptly ghosting thread
Dubz wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 4:37 pm
...nah this ain't wolf!PSV
@Kate @Thunal33 y'all should reconsider
Would you prefer you
No pls, I've never been misyoten in an off-SDN game and I'm not about to end that streak!
I'm serious though. I've seen wolf!PSV under pressure and I've seen village!PSV under pressure and this is not the former.
The way you seemed so confident gives me the feel you were determined to stop psv's elim but you couldn't really back it up
I just really thought she was village, she was acting exactly how I've seen her act before when she's village and doesn't feel defending is going to get her anywhere.
I haven't seen her in that kind of...defeated headspace as a wolf.
Kate wrote: ↑Mon Jun 05, 2023 11:54 am
I'm not sure, I could move you up a couple notches I suppose. I'm lumping you in with psv and genny in my mind. I will try not to do that.
Lol the SDN conglomerate. I am indeed my own person.
What's your take on Quin and on Scotty's defense there?
RIP the SDN squad, pillars of scumminess. The only thing wolfier than our patients is us.
lol if this is just prophetically outing
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
Thunal33 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 11:06 pm
I don't actually think it's Dubz. If it were Dubz, I feel like the whole mafia gameplan would just be to lose. Kate scumread both PSV and Genny and had influence, so even if I didn't shoot Genny I think she would have been eliminated fairly soon and I think Dubz would know this. Then Dubz looks bad and has no plan to go deep, and even if there's a fourth mafia it would be really hard for them to come back.
Btw we started with 17 so a fourth mafia is plausible. I think it's either 3 maf and a 3p or 4 maf.
Dammit there’s no Playerlist or ISOs so I have no idea who has played this game
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
Thunal33 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 11:06 pm
I don't actually think it's Dubz. If it were Dubz, I feel like the whole mafia gameplan would just be to lose. Kate scumread both PSV and Genny and had influence, so even if I didn't shoot Genny I think she would have been eliminated fairly soon and I think Dubz would know this. Then Dubz looks bad and has no plan to go deep, and even if there's a fourth mafia it would be really hard for them to come back.
Btw we started with 17 so a fourth mafia is plausible. I think it's either 3 maf and a 3p or 4 maf.
But dubz wasn't defending genny (I think). She could have turned on her today and been in an okay spot. Also sorry for planting my vote on you and promptly ghosting thread
Np, it's all part of the game. Dubz pretty much said genny was NAI and made a light "gennnnnyyyyyyyy Are you howling?" post when she returned. It's possible w!Dubz would turn on genny yes, but if PSV defended genny and Dubz defended PSV and genny continued lowposting I don't think bussing a low poster really matters for cred especially since Dubz called genny's activity NAI before.
Ok yeah there does seem to be 17 players so that would mean 4 mafia which is only slightly wolf sided but because of willy nilly roles that can be active, I would say this whole setup has the potential to be townsided
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
Scotty wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 11:38 pm
Ok yeah there does seem to be 17 players so that would mean 4 mafia which is only slightly wolf sided but because of willy nilly roles that can be active, I would say this whole setup has the potential to be townsided
Just an FYI, I know I am not a mod or anything but anything editable/outside of the thread is a no go. Youll need to take screen shots or something like that
Scotty wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2023 11:38 pm
Ok yeah there does seem to be 17 players so that would mean 4 mafia which is only slightly wolf sided but because of willy nilly roles that can be active, I would say this whole setup has the potential to be townsided
Wait, I just counted 16 lol.
Wait really, 17 signed up in the sign up thread
@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME how many players are playing this game
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
