The Syndicate

A place for spectators to spectaculate.

first

frist

Hey DF, whenever you get here!!!

That was an appropriate end. I guess you were a sacrifice the island demanded!

Who do you think the baddies are?

I think the baddies are...

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I think the baddies are...

Spoiler: show

Not sharing.

Metalmarsh89

Well, that was very much according to script.

At least the Cop lynch black smoke curse has not returned for a fourth time.

Ricochet wrote:Well, that was very much according to script.

At least the Cop lynch black smoke curse has not returned for a fourth time.

One of them was a day one nightkill...

Golden wrote:

Ricochet wrote:Well, that was very much according to script.

At least the Cop lynch black smoke curse has not returned for a fourth time.

One of them was a day one nightkill...

Semantics!

Golden wrote:Hey DF, whenever you get here!!!

That was an appropriate end. I guess you were a sacrifice the island demanded!

Who do you think the baddies are?

Right now I'm leaning towards Zebra and Matt, but a couple of those more bandwagony votes could be hiding a baddie.

SVS

Do we get a cookie if we're right?

Black Rock wrote:SVS

Do we get a cookie if we're right?

They probably wouldn't be in great shape by the time they got to Canada.

The poll in this thread has changeable votes and I'll keep eliminating people as they die.

Turnip Head wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I think the baddies are...

Spoiler: show

Not sharing.

Metalmarsh89

Lol. Ture.

I hope Nutella does draw that Venn diagram.

Mmmm, Venn Diagrams.

Hey Floyd. That was unlucky! I don't know how that turned around on you so fast. Curse of the heist cop, lol.

Welcome Long Con

Golden wrote:Welcome Long Con

<Long Con
<not revealed to be Sawyer

fail

I figured claiming Locke would get me killed. Ha ha, joke's on them, I was vanilla. Matt and Zebra are the baddies then?

Long Con wrote:I figured claiming Locke would get me killed. Ha ha, joke's on them, I was vanilla. Matt and Zebra are the baddies then?

I was kind of surprised, given the theory in the thread that Locke could be smoky. I will admit, though, that before Floyd flipped cop there was some discussion of you being the likely cop.

That's exactly why I didn't design Locke to be the cop. Those who think the game design could be deduced from role claims must think I was born yesterday I completely expected some people to make decisions based on role claims in this game, and designed the game with that in mind. It's fun seeing that get borne out.

Did you do the thing I thought of, fake claims for the baddies?

So the baddies caught my role hint then?

Long Con wrote:Did you do the thing I thought of, fake claims for the baddies?

So the baddies caught my role hint then?

Yeah, the baddies all have fake role claims. You can't really do a setup like this without them, like someone pointed out if you all just say what characters you are the baddies would be immediately outed.

And yes, the baddies caught your role hint right away, from when you first did it. I think most people I got their role hints, but even though I knew what character she was I didn't get SVS one lol. It is quite fun watching SVS in this set-up, knowing how foreign the concept of info-dumping is to her mafia sensibilities. I wonder how she will feel about it at the end. I hope she enjoys it.

I never went back and looked at SVS' hints... I assume she's Kate?

Long Con wrote:I never went back and looked at SVS' hints... I assume she's Kate?

Sayid.

Oh.... is there a Kate?

Golden wrote:

Long Con wrote:I never went back and looked at SVS' hints... I assume she's Kate?

Sayid.

Could have spoilered that, you know.

Ricochet wrote:

Golden wrote:

Long Con wrote:I never went back and looked at SVS' hints... I assume she's Kate?

Sayid.

Could have spoilered that, you know.

She has stated it in the game thread...

Hey Golden, I'm sorry I said what I said. I probably should've been more careful with my words.

TheFloyd73 wrote:Hey Golden, I'm sorry I said what I said. I probably should've been more careful with my words.

No problems Floyd.

The funny thing is, that people genuinely think you checked Matt, when we can freely say here in Spectator Chat that you, in fact, did not.

I should have probably been smarter and deleted your dead post right away, but I didn't actually think through the way it would be taken, because I knew you hadn't checked Matt. I just saw it as a genuine reaction to being lynched, given the circumstances.

I've been in a very similar position to you. The lynch seemed done, I went to bed, and when I woke up I was lynched because the person who was going to be lynched before that went and role-claimed near day end, and everyone flipped to me while I wasn't around to defend it. It sucks, but what are you going to do!

You played this one well, Floyd. I thought you were going to be about for a while and probably win the game for the civs, given you already had two civilians nailed and the baddies weren't even thinking of targetting either you or the people you knew were civ.

Golden wrote:

Ricochet wrote:

Golden wrote:

Long Con wrote:I never went back and looked at SVS' hints... I assume she's Kate?

Sayid.

Could have spoilered that, you know.

She has stated it in the game thread...

Oh. I understood it as her hinting at Kate in the game, but actually being Sayid.

I also understood this as LC asking for post-death clarifications. I'm just not a fan of learning stuff in the Spectators Chat, as a spectator.

Golden wrote:

Long Con wrote:Did you do the thing I thought of, fake claims for the baddies?

So the baddies caught my role hint then?

Yeah, the baddies all have fake role claims. You can't really do a setup like this without them, like someone pointed out if you all just say what characters you are the baddies would be immediately outed.

And yes, the baddies caught your role hint right away, from when you first did it. I think most people I got their role hints, but even though I knew what character she was I didn't get SVS one lol. It is quite fun watching SVS in this set-up, knowing how foreign the concept of info-dumping is to her mafia sensibilities. I wonder how she will feel about it at the end. I hope she enjoys it.

Correct!

I gave similar fake-claiming civ roles to the baddies in Tree Mafia, but nobody bothered to character-claim.

A little birdy on the street told me that there might be some RYM folks playing the next Heist to show us "how roleplaying is done".

On that note, Epi has cracked me up as Sawyer this game. Too great.

I think Matt might be bad.

Turnip Head wrote:I think Matt might be bad.

SVS and zebra as the last two baddies?

I think that it was quite prescient of me to figure out that there would be fake role cards given to the baddies, all on my own.

Long Con wrote:I think that it was quite prescient of me to figure out that there would be fake role cards given to the baddies, all on my own.

I'm not sure how a game like this would work without them.

Welcome Sorsha!

Welcome Typh.

Epi is the last baddie.

Why the hell did they lynch zebra? What a gigantic fail

I trust SVS 100% because of the failed kill.
Bullz has been against both Matt and Scotty, I trust him.
Nutella just reads civ to me, she made some posts early game where she did not read like her baddie self at all.
Wilgy has been batshit insane this game, but his thread interaction with Scotty leaves me to believe that he is not the baddie.

Leaves Epi. Who is the last baddie.

But I'm guessing they will lynch nutella, and I hope they are right about her. Next lynch is lylo right?

I think it's nutella.

All 5 posted during the night.
All 3 power roles are dead.

How is there no kill? Is there some strategic value that I have a very hard time seeing?

Typhoony wrote:All 5 posted during the night.
All 3 power roles are dead.

How is there no kill? Is there some strategic value that I have a very hard time seeing?

L O S T

The killer probably spelled the victim's name wrong and Golden didn't allow it.

So it can't be Epi.

Ricochet wrote:

Typhoony wrote:All 5 posted during the night.
All 3 power roles are dead.

How is there no kill? Is there some strategic value that I have a very hard time seeing?

L O S T

The killer probably spelled the victim's name wrong and Golden didn't allow it.

So it can't be Epi.

Yeah, they forgot the ~

I just want to say that, in case neither of them are bad, if I were a lone baddie left, near-lylo, with SVS and Epig in the game, I'd shit all my pairs in the drawer.

Whoever out of those two is civ, they've been off their game. Their instincts this game when it comes to baddies suck

Typhoony wrote:Why the hell did they lynch zebra? What a gigantic fail

Good fucking question.

I'm joining the "Epi is bad" group.