U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[nutella]

The soulkeeper specifically said the "escape" at night through the door is the one where I could come out "changed". Being rescued was a separate option.

was the soulkeepwr Mac or PC?

This is a top tier pun

[Kylemii]

LC definitely knew it was YOU who outted him though... I wonder how such a thing could be staged. It sounds ballsy but so are the players involved

follow up quandry??: if the mafia knew that juliets was a civ cop then why is she still alive 4 days later

[Kylemii]

The soulkeeper specifically said the "escape" at night through the door is the one where I could come out "changed". Being rescued was a separate option.

was the soulkeepwr Mac or PC?

This is a top tier pun

it was a mid-tier typo

[juliets]

LC definitely knew it was YOU who outted him though... I wonder how such a thing could be staged. It sounds ballsy but so are the players involved

follow up quandry??: if the mafia knew that juliets was a civ cop then why is she still alive 4 days later

Because sig and dunya covered well for me. They drew the suspicion onto them. sig claimed he was JOAT and he had checked LC before he got taken to the chatzy of lost souls and that made sense because the lynching was driven by dunya who was in there with sig.

[colonialbob]

Did mac actually say he'd tell us if a team was eliminated? I thought he had but then I ISO'd him and couldn't find it. Was I making that up?

(Because if that's true we're still looking for at least one of each team right?)

[juliets]

Did mac actually say he'd tell us if a team was eliminated? I thought he had but then I ISO'd him and couldn't find it. Was I making that up?

(Because if that's true we're still looking for at least one of each team right?)

He told us Isis was eliminated.

[juliets]

"At the end of day six insertnamehere (ISIS Cream) and Kites (Civilian) were lynched. ISIS Cream was defeated."

[colonialbob]

Lol guys I've been here the whole time I swear

[colonialbob]

Lol guys I've been here the whole time I swear

Well except for when I was kidnapped for sex stuff

[Dragon D. Luffy]

When does day end

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Yeah pretty sure Im saved juliets but I know nothing about recruitments or w/e

[Turnip Head]

LC definitely knew it was YOU who outted him though... I wonder how such a thing could be staged. It sounds ballsy but so are the players involved

follow up quandry??: if the mafia knew that juliets was a civ cop then why is she still alive 4 days later

Because sig and dunya covered well for me. They drew the suspicion onto them. sig claimed he was JOAT and he had checked LC before he got taken to the chatzy of lost souls and that made sense because the lynching was driven by dunya who was in there with sig.

I thought LC singled you out though. Do you think he was bluffing or what?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

So Kyle and TH formed a team versus Bob and Juliets? Thats what it looks like

[juliets]

LC definitely knew it was YOU who outted him though... I wonder how such a thing could be staged. It sounds ballsy but so are the players involved

follow up quandry??: if the mafia knew that juliets was a civ cop then why is she still alive 4 days later

Because sig and dunya covered well for me. They drew the suspicion onto them. sig claimed he was JOAT and he had checked LC before he got taken to the chatzy of lost souls and that made sense because the lynching was driven by dunya who was in there with sig.

I thought LC singled you out though. Do you think he was bluffing or what?

He did single me out but after that sig and dunya implied they were responsible for the check which was believable because of where the nail came from.

[juliets]

So Kyle and TH formed a team versus Bob and Juliets? Thats what it looks like

Well not really. We have just been discussing why each person could be mafia or civ.

[juliets]

Also, I acknowledge its possible I got a bad result on one of my checks but assuming I got valid results Kyle is bad. And I have to go with that assumption right now.

[juliets]

I will probably not be on after about 8 o'clock eat, and I'll have dinner before that so if anyone wants me to answer anything please put it out there.

[juliets]

EBWOP: eastern daylight time not "eat"

[Kylemii]

working a closing shift til about 10 PST so by the time I'm back around everyone's probably going to be asleep

[Kylemii]

whatever you do, please keep this phase from ending in a tie, that's the actual worst case scenario for today.

[colonialbob]

Also, I acknowledge its possible I got a bad result on one of my checks but assuming I got valid results Kyle is bad. And I have to go with that assumption right now.

Yyyyyyyyep.

[Quin]

i'll be here guys dont worry

[colonialbob]

Theory crafting a bit:

If I'm mafia, my power is basically useless tonight. The only way it comes into play is if there's a tie between me and somebody else and I picked the right person who is voting with me not against me.

If TH is mafia, Kyle was probably telling the truth about him and his power is basically useless tonight.

If Kyle is mafia, he could have an extra kill or vote steal or make himself a double voter or something else that messes with the math.

If DDL is mafia, his power is useless tonight.

If juliets is mafia, her power is useless tonight unless she's lying about it, which is entirely possible but IMO the way her/Sig played out yesterday she's basically confirmed.

So Kyle is the smart lynch, because even if we're wrong we're still likely to be in mylo tomorrow (relying on DDL's vote, granted). But if he's mafia he could potentially lock up a win with a mislynch today.

[Turnip Head]

[mention]juliets[/mention] what's the name of your role?

[Kylemii]

If I'm mafia, my power is basically useless tonight. The only way it comes into play is if there's a tie between me and somebody else and I picked the right person who is voting with me not against me.

this assumes you can't self target, we also don't know for sure the exact function of your role, just that it results in a +/- 1 vote

If Kyle is mafia, he could have an extra kill or vote steal or make himself a double voter or something else that messes with the math.

all I have left is a jail-keep

So Kyle is the smart lynch, because even if we're wrong we're still likely to be in mylo tomorrow (relying on DDL's vote, granted). But if he's mafia he could potentially lock up a win with a mislynch today.

that seems pretty convenient for you

[Kylemii]

did mac ever say if he'd tell us when we were in lylo?

[colonialbob]

If I'm mafia, my power is basically useless tonight. The only way it comes into play is if there's a tie between me and somebody else and I picked the right person who is voting with me not against me.

this assumes you can't self target, we also don't know for sure the exact function of your role, just that it results in a +/- 1 vote

If I could self-target and was mafia again INH wouldn't have been lynched

If Kyle is mafia, he could have an extra kill or vote steal or make himself a double voter or something else that messes with the math.

all I have left is a jail-keep[/quote]
If you're town, sure. If you're mafia, who knows.

So Kyle is the smart lynch, because even if we're wrong we're still likely to be in mylo tomorrow (relying on DDL's vote, granted). But if he's mafia he could potentially lock up a win with a mislynch today.

that seems pretty convenient for you

Care to dispute any of the logic or just cast aspersions on my character?

[colonialbob]

If I'm mafia, my power is basically useless tonight. The only way it comes into play is if there's a tie between me and somebody else and I picked the right person who is voting with me not against me.

this assumes you can't self target, we also don't know for sure the exact function of your role, just that it results in a +/- 1 vote

If I could self-target and was mafia again INH wouldn't have been lynched

If Kyle is mafia, he could have an extra kill or vote steal or make himself a double voter or something else that messes with the math.

all I have left is a jail-keep

If you're town, sure. If you're mafia, who knows.

So Kyle is the smart lynch, because even if we're wrong we're still likely to be in mylo tomorrow (relying on DDL's vote, granted). But if he's mafia he could potentially lock up a win with a mislynch today.

that seems pretty convenient for you

Care to dispute any of the logic or just cast aspersions on my character?

Fixed

[colonialbob]

If juliets got recruited and we were teammates why wouldn't I have just made her the double voter?

[Kylemii]

i disputed your logic in that very post, right up there.

if we were voting purely based on potential to fuck up lylo your role is way worse than mine :0 if I'm mafia then the worst case scenario is that my role might do the thing that your role has already been proven to do.

[Kylemii]

If juliets got recruited and we were teammates why wouldn't I have just made her the double voter?

you would. who's questioning that?

[Kylemii]

that's why im concerned about ties

[colonialbob]

If juliets got recruited and we were teammates why wouldn't I have just made her the double voter?

you would. who's questioning that?

There was a whole discussion on her being recruited and me also being mafia, no?

[colonialbob]

i disputed your logic in that very post, right up there.

if we were voting purely based on potential to fuck up lylo your role is way worse than mine :0 if I'm mafia then the worst case scenario is that my role might do the thing that your role has already been proven to do.

My role isn't helpful tomorrow unless I can self-target, and like I said if I could self-target INH wouldn't have gotten lynched.

[colonialbob]

i disputed your logic in that very post, right up there.

if we were voting purely based on potential to fuck up lylo your role is way worse than mine :0 if I'm mafia then the worst case scenario is that my role might do the thing that your role has already been proven to do.

My role isn't helpful tomorrow unless I can self-target, and like I said if I could self-target INH wouldn't have gotten lynched.

If I could self-target and was mafia*

(I just make sure I vote Kites, we look like we tie, kites is lynched, we kill somebody, etc)

[Kylemii]

i disputed your logic in that very post, right up there.

if we were voting purely based on potential to fuck up lylo your role is way worse than mine :0 if I'm mafia then the worst case scenario is that my role might do the thing that your role has already been proven to do.

My role isn't helpful tomorrow unless I can self-target, and like I said if I could self-target INH wouldn't have gotten lynched.

double targeting rule means you'd only be able to do yourself every other night, right? plus even without that you'd be able to target ddl

[colonialbob]

Welp inh was ISIS rip that defense

But anyway why wouldn't I have made Sloonei a double voter instead of you

[Kylemii]

If juliets got recruited and we were teammates why wouldn't I have just made her the double voter?

you would. who's questioning that?

There was a whole discussion on her being recruited and me also being mafia, no?

yes, i don't understand the question. if you and juliets are teammates you'd obviously target juliets at endgame

[colonialbob]

i disputed your logic in that very post, right up there.

if we were voting purely based on potential to fuck up lylo your role is way worse than mine :0 if I'm mafia then the worst case scenario is that my role might do the thing that your role has already been proven to do.

My role isn't helpful tomorrow unless I can self-target, and like I said if I could self-target INH wouldn't have gotten lynched.

double targeting rule means you'd only be able to do yourself every other night, right? plus even without that you'd be able to target ddl

Tomorrow that doesn't matter. If we mislynch it's presumably 1 v 1 v 1. It's basically "who does DDL want to win". Giving him a double vote doesn't change that. Heck giving myself a double vote doesn't really change that, all that happens is either town or DDL doesn't win because they're lynched alongside me.

[colonialbob]

If juliets got recruited and we were teammates why wouldn't I have just made her the double voter?

you would. who's questioning that?

There was a whole discussion on her being recruited and me also being mafia, no?

yes, i don't understand the question. if you and juliets are teammates you'd obviously target juliets at endgame

Why does al-Pieda cbob, with teammates Sloonei and motel and potentially a recruited juliets, make you a double voter?

[Kylemii]

Welp inh was ISIS rip that defense

But anyway why wouldn't I have made Sloonei a double voter instead of you

the only reason we think you targeted me is cus you said you did, you could have targeted any of the inh voters, right?

[colonialbob]

Welp inh was ISIS rip that defense

But anyway why wouldn't I have made Sloonei a double voter instead of you

the only reason we think you targeted me is cus you said you did, you could have targeted any of the inh voters, right?

If you think I faked that reaction, sure.

[colonialbob]

And also this is all depending on the fact that I also have a godfather role, let's not forget

[juliets]

@juliets what's the name of your role?

Dr. Laszlo Kreisler, from the Alienist.

[juliets]

Welp inh was ISIS rip that defense

But anyway why wouldn't I have made Sloonei a double voter instead of you

the only reason we think you targeted me is cus you said you did, you could have targeted any of the inh voters, right?

which rules me out because I voted Kites.

[juliets]

I'll check back in every so often until I go to bed.

[Turnip Head]

Should we just let DDL decide the coin toss?

[colonialbob]

Should we just let DDL decide the coin toss?

[Turnip Head]

[mention]Kylemii[/mention] and [mention]Dragon D. Luffy[/mention] if you had to choose between juliets and CBob which way would you lean iykwim

[juliets]

@Kylemii and @Dragon D. Luffy if you had to choose between juliets and CBob which way would you lean iykwim

You seriously want to lynch the cop?