[END] Harry Potter Mafia

[Jack Shephard]

That, coupled with my opinion that resurrected persons are working for Tom Riddle, had been giving me pause about Sarah Good being bad.

Wait, so you hinted that you brought me back to life, and yet you think it was the doing of Tom Riddle?

I never once implied that the method of resurrection had anything to do with the quality of life after resurrection.

[Operator]

That, coupled with my opinion that resurrected persons are working for Tom Riddle, had been giving me pause about Sarah Good being bad.

Wait, so you hinted that you brought me back to life, and yet you think it was the doing of Tom Riddle?

I never once implied that the method of resurrection had anything to do with the quality of life after resurrection.

Malin, what is your opinion about the resurrected ones?

I am very suspicious of people who show up out of nowhere, vote without discussion, and get annoyed when people question them. Do not trust.

[Jack Shephard]

Also, Barbara Kollerin, a very squirrelly individual before and after death, has not been back since Day 9.

[Jack Shephard]

That, coupled with my opinion that resurrected persons are working for Tom Riddle, had been giving me pause about Sarah Good being bad.

Wait, so you hinted that you brought me back to life, and yet you think it was the doing of Tom Riddle?

I never once implied that the method of resurrection had anything to do with the quality of life after resurrection.

Malin, what is your opinion about the resurrected ones?

I am very suspicious of people who show up out of nowhere, vote without discussion, and get annoyed when people question them. Do not trust.

I'm sorry. I meant about my theory outlined above.

[Operator]

[
I'm sorry. I meant about my theory outlined above.

What I think is worth remembering is that Agnes came back as a zombie, whereas these two are not zombies. That may be a telling difference. I really think Sarah Good is bad and I don't know how else to interpret Agnes' comment. The part about a returned Hermione, converted to the side of evil, makes sense though.

[Jack Shephard]

What is your opinion of Anne Redferne?

[Chuck]

That, coupled with my opinion that resurrected persons are working for Tom Riddle, had been giving me pause about Sarah Good being bad.

Wait, so you hinted that you brought me back to life, and yet you think it was the doing of Tom Riddle?

I never once implied that the method of resurrection had anything to do with the quality of life after resurrection.

Malin, what is your opinion about the resurrected ones?

I am very suspicious of Sarah Good. Or at least I will pretend to be because I want to discredit her suspicion of me.

Fixed.

[Jack Shephard]

In all 44 of your posts, you've done absolutely nothing helpful. Don't try to start now.

[Chuck]

In all 44 of your posts, you've done absolutely nothing helpful. Don't try to start now.

Well, this buddy-buddy thing is pretty cute.

[Chuck]

In all 44 of your posts, you've done absolutely nothing helpful. Don't try to start now.

I disagree, I smoked out 2 baddies. My effort/result ratio is tight as fuck.

[Operator]

What is your opinion of Anne Redferne?

I'm on the fence about her. Sometimes she seems helpful, other times she seems to be faking helpful while coasting on the ideas of others. I could go either way.

[Jack Shephard]

In all 44 of your posts, you've done absolutely nothing helpful. Don't try to start now.

Well, this buddy-buddy thing is pretty cute.

I'm giving you an opportunity to speak and be helpful. So is everyone else who has not voted for you. You're around. Even though you've already voted, you don't have other things to say?

linki @ Sarah~ Proof or GTFO

[Chuck]

In all 44 of your posts, you've done absolutely nothing helpful. Don't try to start now.

Well, this buddy-buddy thing is pretty cute.

I'm giving you an opportunity to speak and be helpful. So is everyone else who has not voted for you. You're around. Even though you've already voted, you don't have other things to say?

linki @ Sarah~ Proof or GTFO

Proof like the fact that Mary was Lucius Malfoy or some other form of proof?

Malin is so transparently baddie I struggle to see how you could not see it. Or you're ignoring it because you're an indie and you don't care as long as Voldemort is your BFF

[Jack Shephard]

In all 44 of your posts, you've done absolutely nothing helpful. Don't try to start now.

Well, this buddy-buddy thing is pretty cute.

I'm giving you an opportunity to speak and be helpful. So is everyone else who has not voted for you. You're around. Even though you've already voted, you don't have other things to say?

linki @ Sarah~ Proof or GTFO

Proof like the fact that Mary was Lucius Malfoy or some other form of proof?

Malin is so transparently baddie I struggle to see how you could not see it. Or you're ignoring it because you're an indie and you don't care as long as Voldemort is your BFF

That will do. Thanks.

[Chuck]

You sure? Because I can keep going.

[Operator]

Yeah, transparent like a fox.

[Jack Shephard]

I will leave it up to the other witches to decide if Malin is naughty or not. I hope the lesson we've learned is to not take someone's hasty ass word for it. Which smells like a hasty ass.

Jane is impaired. I hope to reach out to her, because she has good insight.

In the meantime, Sarah, you would do well to consider your words.

[Operator]

Alizon, what do you make of the fact that Jennet said she would return to the underworld like Agnes, but has not done so?

[Chuck]

I will leave it up to the other witches to decide if Malin is naughty or not. I hope the lesson we've learned is to not take someone's hasty ass word for it. Which smells like a hasty ass.

Jane is impaired. I hope to reach out to her, because she has good insight.

In the meantime, Sarah, you would do well to consider your words.

I'm the only one considering my words. :/

[Jack Shephard]

Alizon, what do you make of the fact that Jennet said she would return to the underworld like Agnes, but has not done so?

That is yet a mystery to me. Agnes' exact words were this~

"But alas, I am likely not long for this world so I will have to hurry in any case."

That implies the possibility of staying. So I don't know. What do you think?

[Jack Shephard]

I will leave it up to the other witches to decide if Malin is naughty or not. I hope the lesson we've learned is to not take someone's hasty ass word for it. Which smells like a hasty ass.

Jane is impaired. I hope to reach out to her, because she has good insight.

In the meantime, Sarah, you would do well to consider your words.

I'm the only one considering my words. :/

You have offered no words to consider.

[Operator]

Alizon, what do you make of the fact that Jennet said she would return to the underworld like Agnes, but has not done so?

That is yet a mystery to me. Agnes' exact words were this~

"But alas, I am likely not long for this world so I will have to hurry in any case."

That implies the possibility of staying. So I don't know. What do you think?

Jennet said this:

I know exactly why I have returned. I'm sure you could figure it out if you look at what's happened in recent parts of the game. Let's just say that I don't have long here (very much like Agnes), and I'm pressing as a result of that.

To me, this reads like a clever way to avoid getting lynched. Who would waste a lynch on someone who is going to die anyway? I think it is a big fat lie.

Although that doesn't necessarily make her bad. Civvies lie too sometimes.

[Chuck]

I will leave it up to the other witches to decide if Malin is naughty or not. I hope the lesson we've learned is to not take someone's hasty ass word for it. Which smells like a hasty ass.

Jane is impaired. I hope to reach out to her, because she has good insight.

In the meantime, Sarah, you would do well to consider your words.

I'm the only one considering my words. :/

You have offered no words to consider.

Then why would you tell me to consider them?

[Jack Shephard]

I will leave it up to the other witches to decide if Malin is naughty or not. I hope the lesson we've learned is to not take someone's hasty ass word for it. Which smells like a hasty ass.

Jane is impaired. I hope to reach out to her, because she has good insight.

In the meantime, Sarah, you would do well to consider your words.

I'm the only one considering my words. :/

You have offered no words to consider.

Then why would you tell me to consider them?

That was word play.

In my first sentence, I was advising you to think before you post.

In my second sentence, I was giving you a Shakespearean smackdown.

[Chuck]

I will leave it up to the other witches to decide if Malin is naughty or not. I hope the lesson we've learned is to not take someone's hasty ass word for it. Which smells like a hasty ass.

Jane is impaired. I hope to reach out to her, because she has good insight.

In the meantime, Sarah, you would do well to consider your words.

I'm the only one considering my words. :/

You have offered no words to consider.

Then why would you tell me to consider them?

That was word play.

In my first sentence, I was advising you to think before you post.

In my second sentence, I was giving you a Shakespearean smackdown.

I'm not sure you understand how word play works.

[Jack Shephard]

See, that's irony! Well done.

[Ben Linus]

Alizon, what do you make of the fact that Jennet said she would return to the underworld like Agnes, but has not done so?

That is yet a mystery to me. Agnes' exact words were this~

"But alas, I am likely not long for this world so I will have to hurry in any case."

That implies the possibility of staying. So I don't know. What do you think?

Jennet said this:

I know exactly why I have returned. I'm sure you could figure it out if you look at what's happened in recent parts of the game. Let's just say that I don't have long here (very much like Agnes), and I'm pressing as a result of that.

To me, this reads like a clever way to avoid getting lynched. Who would waste a lynch on someone who is going to die anyway? I think it is a big fat lie.

Although that doesn't necessarily make her bad. Civvies lie too sometimes.

Except that I offered my own lynch as a viable alternative to lynching Anne Whittle.

[Ben Linus]

Anyway, I really don't believe you all should be following what Alizon has to say today. She's seemingly taken the reigns and is leading us astray. She could be a misguided townie, but she very well could be a Death Eater (my belief).

[Phoebe Buffay]

I don't know who Marilyn Allison. . I'm going to start making the sauce, it was the end of my Allison once again last month, before a couple of days ago, facing God.


There are many tag team has wanted to invest more in the elevator. Sarah Ellis. Abbot good crazy show, Catherine. Listen to voice messages. Citizens for the civilian population. Also the need to select a country.

Except that I offered my own lynch as a viable alternative to lynching Anne Whittle.

Jeremiah. Lynch. It is a pity, because it is not a problem for the rest of the day now. You can also continue in 2010?

[Phoebe Buffay]

Anyway, I really don't believe you all should be following what Alizon has to say today. She's seemingly taken the reigns and is leading us astray. She could be a misguided townie, but she very well could be a Death Eater (my belief).

What is Merlin, Sarah?

[Celeste]

alright i'm going with sarah good, was a close decision between her and karin though.

voting now since i'll be busy all day tomorrow with doing stuff

[Young Lady]

You all sure do get talkative after I have gone to bed.

In all 44 of your posts, you've done absolutely nothing helpful. Don't try to start now.

I disagree, I smoked out 2 baddies. My effort/result ratio is tight as fuck.

Sarah Good did seem to be exaggerating her involvement in the whole Mary thing

Is it really an exaggeration though. Is it really.

Yes, it is Sarah. It really is. *Votes Sarah Good*

[Jack Shephard]

Jane, pull out your crayons.

Color the ones you think should be lynched with red the ones you're nervous about with yellow and those who are good with green. Not sure? Leave it alone.

Jennet Bierley
Alizon Device
Sarah Good
Katharina Henot
Barbara Kollerin
Malin Matsdotter
Alice Nutter
Anne Redferne
Jane Southworth
Karin Svensdotter

[Chuck]

Anne, Karin, if I am lynched how do you plan on explaining yourselves?

[Phoebe Buffay]

Jane, pull out your crayons.

Color the ones you think should be lynched with red the ones you're nervous about with yellow and those who are good with green. Not sure? Leave it alone.

Jennet Bierley
Alizon Device
Sarah Good
Katharina Henot
Barbara Kollerin
Malin Matsdotter
Alice Nutter
Anne Redferne
Jane Southworth
Karin Svensdotter

Karin died, Catherine, Carlin. Neural network with a great tone for the murder of a powerful neural network, neural network, something that is not good.

Day 9
Who is a nasty Death Eater?

Alizon Device
1
Alice Nutter (9)
7%

Malin Matsdotter
1
Sarah Good (13)
7%

Karin Svensdotter
5
Jennet Bierley (2), Barbara Kollerin (3), Anne Whittle (5), Anne Redferne (7), Märet Jonsdotter (8)
33%

Anne Whittle
5
Katharina Henot (10), Malin Matsdotter (11), Alizon Device (12), Karin Svensdotter (14), Jane Southworth (15)
33%

[Jack Shephard]

Jane, would you like to take a survey?

Please quote all that apply~


I think it may be worth lynching Jennet for information.

I think Jennet has a student role but is working for the Death Eaters.

I think Jennet is a misguided student who really wants to help.

I think something else about Jennet.


I think Alice Nutter and Sarah Good voted outside of the Karin/Whittle lynch for evil reasons.

I think Alice Nutter and Sarah Good are probably teammates.


I would support a Jennt lynch.

I would support a Sarah lynch.

I would support a Barbara lynch.

I would support a Malin lynch.

I would support an Alice lynch.

I would support an Anne lynch.


I think there is 1 bad guy left.

I think there are 2 bad guys left.

I think there are 3 bad guys left.

I think there are 4 bad guys left.

I don't know how many bad guys are left.


I saw someone with the devil.

[Ben Linus]

I voted myself. I do believe Sarah is good, or at least not bad, and we'll benefit more from my own lynch.

[Jack Shephard]

I voted myself. I do believe Sarah is good, or at least not bad, and we'll benefit more from my own lynch.

What leads you to that belief about Sarah?

[Chuck]

I voted myself. I do believe Sarah is good, or at least not bad, and we'll benefit more from my own lynch.

What leads you to that belief about Sarah?

Well, facts for one thing.

[Phoebe Buffay]

I think Jennet has a student role but is working for the Death Eaters.

I think Alice Nutter and Sarah Good voted outside of the Karin/Whittle lynch for evil reasons.

I think Alice Nutter and Sarah Good are probably teammates.

If you're thinking of others.

I would support a Jennt lynch.

I would support a Malin lynch.

I would support an Alice lynch.

...

I would support a Sarah lynch.

I would support a Malin lynch.

Is one of them.

I think there are 2 bad guys left.

[Operator]

Well, I am still convinced Sarah is bad and nothing she has said today causes me to think otherwise. I've never seen anyone so reluctant to provide positive, useful participation even in the face of a potential lynch, so I am casting my vote for her.

BIH Sarah (Not)Good.

[Chuck]

Well, I am still convinced Sarah is bad and nothing she has said today causes me to think otherwise. I've never seen anyone so reluctant to provide positive, useful participation even in the face of a potential lynch, so I am casting my vote for her.

BIH Sarah (Not)Good.

I've provided that though

[Chuck]

Based on Malin's voting record, her surviving multiple deaths (probably due to horcruxes), her going after a seemingly quiet/easy target when she got heat, her buddy-buddy with Alizon, and all the other evidence I've presented, I'm borderline incredulous that nobody has connected the dots.

[Jack Shephard]

I did a full reading of Anne Redferne.

First a history of votes.
1. Anne Whittle (6th, jokey reason)
2. Krystyna (14th, first vote when Bridget Bishop got lynched)
3. Entjen Gillis (5th, first vote on the day Krystyna got lynched despite having fewer votes)
4. Missed the vote.
5. Mary Eastey (7th, second vote)
6. Alizon Device (8th, third vote)
7. Malin (3rd, first vote)
8. Malin (11th, first vote)
9. Karin (7th, fourth vote)
10. Sarah Good (5th, first vote)

So this is a history of voting early in terms of sequence (likely because of real life, as evinced by things Anne has said). This is also indicative of not needing to save a teammate.

Anne went after Malin fairly consistently until the resurrection event, and now no longer considers Malin a threat (something I find strange since Malin had no positive opinion about Redferne). Not sure what to make of that.

Anne Redferne has never received a vote.

Anne's thread presence strikes me as student, though less so than Jane's did.

A few things bother me about Anne.

She jumped on the Karin case eagerly, but then retracted her support of the case after realizing it was based on faulty and misleading claims. However, she voted Karin anyway, also voicing support of a (supposedly) telling Jennet lynch.

Despite what Redferne said to Whittle, lynching Jennet would (I believe) be a wasted lynch. If I'm right about the resurrected ones being in the service of evil, and Anne is bad, then lynching Jennet would be the perfect crime. Waste a lynch that sets up someone else.

[Julinook]

Voted for who I think will make the civs have any hope of winning. No time for more.

[Gunther]

Anyway, I really don't believe you all should be following what Alizon has to say today. She's seemingly taken the reigns and is leading us astray. She could be a misguided townie, but she very well could be a Death Eater (my belief).

I disagree with you. I think at *worst* she is a misguided civ, but I do not think at all that Alizon is a Death Eater.

I'm also curious as to why you and Barbara are so sure that lynching you is a) the best way to go and b) will give us lots of information.

[Gunther]

I want to link to Jane's post and add to it now.

I am operating under the opinion that the resurrected persons are in service to Tom Riddle.

Jennet said she gunned hard for Mary and knew she would be killed for it. So if Jennet was Hermoine and checked Mary, that explains the sudden fervor. If this is true, then looking at when Jennet voted might be helpful~

1. Enjen (21st, no info)
2. Krystyna (22nd, no info)
3. Enjen (19th, likely no info)
4. Mary (4th, info)
5. Mary (3rd, info)

Now then, if Jennet were Hermoine, and she came back to life insisting on a Karin lynch, she'd be implying that she checked Karin. Asking to be lynched, then, would be an effective strategy in getting others to believe Karin should be lynched. However, looking at the above sequence, it can be assumed that Jennet did not check Karin unless she did so on the night she was killed.

Rewind to Agnes Sampson.

Agnes never said we should lynch Sarah Good. I threw out an interpretation of her vague comment and Anna Koldings expressed agreement with my thinking~

Cool it with the snark everyone. Zombie don't play that. Anyway, we have more important things to discuss. The underworld was most illuminating. I can't be very specific, but let me just say that names can be deceiving.

So Sarah Good is not good.

I'd buy that. It doesn't work with anyone else's name (if that Agnes was driving at).

But right after this, Mary went nuts and Agnes never responded to me. Weirdly enough, Agnes spent her time back going after Entjen, then said this~

I really do have thoughts on players other than Entjen I swear, I will get to them soon, Im glad we have 24 hours and not a only a few like Margarethe almost had me believing! :P But alas, I am likely not long for this world so I will have to hurry in any case.

Then

Okay Entjen then who do you think is bad? The only person being discussed that I see right now is Mary, who I will get to in a bit. We need to be talking about more than one person in order to see which way the discussions head toward. As you have said before yourself there is more than one baddie out there.

I have thoughts on other players that I'm trying to get organized, but I'd like to hear your thoughts on other players as well.

Isn't it funny that Agnes came back and tried to have people discuss someone other than Lucius Malfoy?

Then

I think the case on Mary is pretty compelling. I'm placing my vote there.

Agnes never got back to us about any of these other players she supposedly had thoughts on, nor did she respond to my interpretation of what she said.

That, coupled with my opinion that resurrected persons are working for Tom Riddle, had been giving me pause about Sarah Good being bad.

But if Sarah Good WERE bad, and Agnes was working for the baddies, then her cryptic remark backfired. Agnes would have had no reason to address it and could move on to getting Entjen lynched. That didn't happen, and Agnes voted second to last for Mary, right before Sarah Good.

This makes a lot of sense.

[Gunther]

Alizon great job on helping Jane get her thoughts out!

Jane - well done as well!

[Ben Linus]

Anyway, I really don't believe you all should be following what Alizon has to say today. She's seemingly taken the reigns and is leading us astray. She could be a misguided townie, but she very well could be a Death Eater (my belief).

I disagree with you. I think at *worst* she is a misguided civ, but I do not think at all that Alizon is a Death Eater.

I'm also curious as to why you and Barbara are so sure that lynching you is a) the best way to go and b) will give us lots of information.

Because lynching me will presumably reveal my role (something that a NK will not do). Don't you also find it interesting that Alizon believes I am "working" for Lord Voldemort, but has no interest in lynching me? She knows what will happen, and does not want it to happen, the same reason she has been keeping me alive. This is also why she does not want to lynch Karin, who I do know is bad. I'm sorry I can't tell anything more than this vague statement, but I would be breaking rules if I did.

[Chuck]

You know what else would serve the civvies, lynching a baddie like Malin.