MissSparkles wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 1:09 pm
Marmy just throwing a vote for the sake of it makes me feel decent about him, trying to get things going is a good sign, i think he would just hide behind mech talk and/or try manipulating the current strategy we have in place.
Just small town feels. Not enough to join my town inner circle (super exclusive by the by) but definitely enough for a slight town lean.
I love stab in the dark day one
I'm town, so this is a good read
That’s what scum would say, lmao.
But yea i’d feel you wouldn’t follow me here if you were Traitor, the game we played as town you were one of the few to correctly town read (still ended up yeeted but what can u do)) so I know you’d consider my opinion as town. Since you have the hone field advantage here, you’d definitely be able to pain me in a negative light, and you know i’m not easily pocketed so following me here looks good from you.
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 9:37 am
I think with the exile vote isn't it better to not vote the same people twice while it's avoidable to do so?
That way it's betting on making no more than 3 mistakes in the upper half of the player list (which seems fair) compared to betting the entire game on a specific player being town (which I think is easier to fake because of a lack of TMI).
Not sure if this is the better mech play.
I disagre. One of our win conditions is to send three traitors to Exile over the course of the game, and with the limited knowledge that traitors have of each other, yeeting based on interactions will be difficult.
Yeeting based on interactions is impossible this game and I’d look closely at people doing it, it would be a try to look productive/good tactic here.
Marmot wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 12:12 pm
We have a heavy reliance on the cop this game I think (thankfully there's a backup, on the off chance that there's a cc), which means that them claiming might not be in our best interest yet, because it'll give the Anti-Cop more info into who they should frame.
That said, claiming early would prevent cc wars from going down.
So what do you think about our cop being forced to claim?
Fake move too coast? Cause I honestly have a hard time believing it, especially when as I said an outed cop makes it easier for the Traitor Cop to guess the target?
Is Gavial a bastard host? Then again this setup would probably only come from a bastard host mindset lmao
MissSparkles wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 1:04 pm
But anybody with experience with Cat as a player and their meta/strategy can gladly weigh in, i’m all bog cute cartoon eyes over here!
I've only played with cat once, we were teammates in GoC, and he was yeeted Day 1. That said, his entrance into that game had a little more assurance in it then this one, so though I dislike the post, I'm willing to let him say more things here in the event that he just feigns more confidence as mafia.
I mean trying out a different strategy would make sense? Especially when he got yeeted as scum (Was scum right?). And signal attempt abd then dipping ain’t a towny look and fits with someone looking to switch there style up and fly under the radar. I mean it makes a lot of sense if he got yeeted as scum with an assertive assured tone/style.
MissSparkles wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 1:09 pm
Marmy just throwing a vote for the sake of it makes me feel decent about him, trying to get things going is a good sign, i think he would just hide behind mech talk and/or try manipulating the current strategy we have in place.
Just small town feels. Not enough to join my town inner circle (super exclusive by the by) but definitely enough for a slight town lean.
I love stab in the dark day one
I'm town, so this is a good read
That’s what scum would say, lmao.
But yea i’d feel you wouldn’t follow me here if you were Traitor, the game we played as town you were one of the few to correctly town read (still ended up yeeted but what can u do)) so I know you’d consider my opinion as town. Since you have the hone field advantage here, you’d definitely be able to pain me in a negative light, and you know i’m not easily pocketed so following me here looks good from you.
I may have homefield advantage here, but I've only played with half of this player list (we got a huge influx of new players in the last couple months).
I do remember that game, but the problem was that I chose to actually read your ISO like 30 minutes before EOD when you were probably gonna be yeeted anyway and it didn't matter.
MissSparkles wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 1:09 pm
Marmy just throwing a vote for the sake of it makes me feel decent about him, trying to get things going is a good sign, i think he would just hide behind mech talk and/or try manipulating the current strategy we have in place.
Just small town feels. Not enough to join my town inner circle (super exclusive by the by) but definitely enough for a slight town lean.
I love stab in the dark day one
I'm town, so this is a good read
This post is unnecessary as town though, and feels like a slight buddy/pocket attempt. Cause agreeing with any read of mine will make me think i’m doing good and thus could win my favour.
But the other towny points don’t outweigh this scummy post but still no INNER TOWN CIRCLE VIP PASS 4 U
I do have a couple more thoughts on the strategy this game, but I'm going to withhold them until everyone has checked in.
I do have a question for everyone though. I've reconsidered my original stance on the cop claiming, and I've seen a couple players advocating for it. Should we encourage the town cop to claim or not? At this moment, I'm leaning toward yes.
MissSparkles wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 1:09 pm
Marmy just throwing a vote for the sake of it makes me feel decent about him, trying to get things going is a good sign, i think he would just hide behind mech talk and/or try manipulating the current strategy we have in place.
Just small town feels. Not enough to join my town inner circle (super exclusive by the by) but definitely enough for a slight town lean.
I love stab in the dark day one
I'm town, so this is a good read
This post is unnecessary as town though, and feels like a slight buddy/pocket attempt. Cause agreeing with any read of mine will make me think i’m doing good and thus could win my favour.
But the other towny points don’t outweigh this scummy post but still no INNER TOWN CIRCLE VIP PASS 4 U
MissSparkles wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 1:09 pm
Marmy just throwing a vote for the sake of it makes me feel decent about him, trying to get things going is a good sign, i think he would just hide behind mech talk and/or try manipulating the current strategy we have in place.
Just small town feels. Not enough to join my town inner circle (super exclusive by the by) but definitely enough for a slight town lean.
I love stab in the dark day one
I'm town, so this is a good read
That’s what scum would say, lmao.
But yea i’d feel you wouldn’t follow me here if you were Traitor, the game we played as town you were one of the few to correctly town read (still ended up yeeted but what can u do)) so I know you’d consider my opinion as town. Since you have the hone field advantage here, you’d definitely be able to pain me in a negative light, and you know i’m not easily pocketed so following me here looks good from you.
I may have homefield advantage here, but I've only played with half of this player list (we got a huge influx of new players in the last couple months).
I do remember that game, but the problem was that I chose to actually read your ISO like 30 minutes before EOD when you were probably gonna be yeeted anyway and it didn't matter.
Which is fair considering you were another yeet option!
Have you read any of my other games? How would describe my playstyle? Do you think i’m town here?
Marmot wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:05 pm
I do have a couple more thoughts on the strategy this game, but I'm going to withhold them until everyone has checked in.
I do have a question for everyone though. I've reconsidered my original stance on the cop claiming, and I've seen a couple players advocating for it. Should we encourage the town cop to claim or not? At this moment, I'm leaning toward yes.
The cop has already claimed, how did u miss it?
He confirmed to me it was a valid claim and he was forced too by the mod! It’s all on page 1, go look!!
MissSparkles wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 1:09 pm
Marmy just throwing a vote for the sake of it makes me feel decent about him, trying to get things going is a good sign, i think he would just hide behind mech talk and/or try manipulating the current strategy we have in place.
Just small town feels. Not enough to join my town inner circle (super exclusive by the by) but definitely enough for a slight town lean.
I love stab in the dark day one
I'm town, so this is a good read
This post is unnecessary as town though, and feels like a slight buddy/pocket attempt. Cause agreeing with any read of mine will make me think i’m doing good and thus could win my favour.
But the other towny points don’t outweigh this scummy post but still no INNER TOWN CIRCLE VIP PASS 4 U
I enjoy pocketing as town too tbh.
I mean it’s not considered a pocket if you’re town now is it?
It's been long enough since I've played with you Sparkles, that I honestly don't really remember your playstyle, I've played a lot of games in the last 5 months, and you were only alive for that one day phase in that game. I know we've played video mafia together too, but I can't seem to recall a distinction in your meta.
That said, I'm reading you as town so far for strongly engaging in the game, and with a number of players in the game. Making reads and attempting to engage other people on those reads while we're still sorta in RVS is rand town imo.
I’m trying to move the game away from mech soec, sure everyone canvweigh in but not sure what witholding you’re thoughts on it does for town Marmy, but i’m very much set on Cat being a RED TRAITOR so i’ll let u do u for now since you’re being a pal and helping me pressure my scum lean
Marmot wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:11 pm
It's been long enough since I've played with you Sparkles, that I honestly don't really remember your playstyle, I've played a lot of games in the last 5 months, and you were only alive for that one day phase in that game. I know we've played video mafia together too, but I can't seem to recall a distinction in your meta.
That said, I'm reading you as town so far for strongly engaging in the game, and with a number of players in the game. Making reads and attempting to engage other people on those reads while we're still sorta in RVS is rand town imo.
That’s fair, here’s some insight, believe it or not idc, i’m a very honest mafia player so you should.
My playstyle is always the same, my meta mostly is as well and I’m very good at not only replicating it but using my meta’s perception as a way to manipulate it for town reads.
Marmot wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:05 pm
I do have a couple more thoughts on the strategy this game, but I'm going to withhold them until everyone has checked in.
I do have a question for everyone though. I've reconsidered my original stance on the cop claiming, and I've seen a couple players advocating for it. Should we encourage the town cop to claim or not? At this moment, I'm leaning toward yes.
The cop has already claimed, how did u miss it?
He confirmed to me it was a valid claim and he was forced too by the mod! It’s all on page 1, go look!!
I just assumed it was Mac providing cover for being so open at the start of the game with it. Why is it a confirmed, valid claim?
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
Marmot wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:05 pm
I do have a couple more thoughts on the strategy this game, but I'm going to withhold them until everyone has checked in.
I do have a question for everyone though. I've reconsidered my original stance on the cop claiming, and I've seen a couple players advocating for it. Should we encourage the town cop to claim or not? At this moment, I'm leaning toward yes.
The cop has already claimed, how did u miss it?
He confirmed to me it was a valid claim and he was forced too by the mod! It’s all on page 1, go look!!
I just assumed it was Mac providing cover for being so open at the start of the game with it. Why is it a confirmed, valid claim?
Cause I asked if he was serious and responded with “Yes, the mod forced me to claim” why lie about all that of it’s a cover play? Just tell me it was serious lmao
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
How about supporting my wagon on Cat then fam?
You're not even voting for cat.
(Reminder that your vote in the poll is the one that counts)
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
There's way too much confidence in these reads for this stage of the game
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
How about supporting my wagon on Cat then fam?
You're not even voting for cat.
(Reminder that your vote in the poll is the one that counts)
What? I thought it was some random thing we didn’t know about, guess i’ll change it then lmao
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
There's way too much confidence in these reads for this stage of the game
Well sure, but you’re probably not the greatest in the early game and generally better with them as the game goes on, but for me personally my best reads come on day 1.
Probably why i’m so often misyeeted on day one, the paranoia from players who’ve seen me as scum skews there judgement when I’m a pretty easy read on day one
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
There's way too much confidence in these reads for this stage of the game
Well sure, but you’re probably not the greatest in the early game and generally better with them as the game goes on, but for me personally my best reads come on day 1.
I'm not the greatest analyst stage of the game. Wiml has a lack of suspicion I find suspicious
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
There's way too much confidence in these reads for this stage of the game
Well sure, but you’re probably not the greatest in the early game and generally better with them as the game goes on, but for me personally my best reads come on day 1.
I'm not the greatest at any stage of the game. Wiml has a lack of suspicion I find suspicious
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
There's way too much confidence in these reads for this stage of the game
Well sure, but you’re probably not the greatest in the early game and generally better with them as the game goes on, but for me personally my best reads come on day 1.
I'm not the greatest analyst stage of the game. Wiml has a lack of suspicion I find suspicious
Okay sure, but what he’s doing is good, finding town in a any setup is easier then finding scum. So this early having more town reads is smart, I just like to attack when I have a scum read, i’d be doing the same if I didn’t.
I like how real you are here, portraying yourself as not great at the game would give a perception if an easy yeet, which town wouldn’t want but neither and especially not a self preserving scum, so it reads to me as unconfident town.
Creature wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 10:14 am
I wonder how we'll find the traitors
Do you think the traitors will try to contact eachother? Should we look for softs?
Would bringing up the idea be consistent as a soft cause I feel ot is, bringing up strategies for traitors like this ain’t a good look.
Vote Cat
This is kind of towny even if I don't fully agree with the conclusion but keep going
Why not? It’s well disguised as a potential towny thought and the statement just gives traitors a way to find us aka not a very towny mindset
I think it's a decent insight
I would've like it more if it was an assertion rather than phrased as questions but that might be a personality thing
I don't know Cat so I'll let it play out
Cooperation is better then assertion this early in the game, i’m asking questions to try and get input from others so I can get a read from there, day 1 tunnels are bad play.
Creature wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 10:14 am
I wonder how we'll find the traitors
Do you think the traitors will try to contact eachother? Should we look for softs?
Would bringing up the idea be consistent as a soft cause I feel ot is, bringing up strategies for traitors like this ain’t a good look.
Vote Cat
This is kind of towny even if I don't fully agree with the conclusion but keep going
Why not? It’s well disguised as a potential towny thought and the statement just gives traitors a way to find us aka not a very towny mindset
I think it's a decent insight
I would've like it more if it was an assertion rather than phrased as questions but that might be a personality thing
I don't know Cat so I'll let it play out
Cooperation is better then assertion this early in the game, i’m asking questions to try and get input from others so I can get a read from there, day 1 tunnels are bad play.
Oh I meant Cats post not yours
KZA
Hally wrote: ↑Sun Apr 11, 2021 1:51 am
eating an entire sandwich is not that hard
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
How about supporting my wagon on Cat then fam?
Maybe! I wanted to work out how to vote / ISO first lol.
Do you think the traitors will try to contact eachother? Should we look for softs?
Would bringing up the idea be consistent as a soft cause I feel ot is, bringing up strategies for traitors like this ain’t a good look.
Vote Cat
This is kind of towny even if I don't fully agree with the conclusion but keep going
Why not? It’s well disguised as a potential towny thought and the statement just gives traitors a way to find us aka not a very towny mindset
I think it's a decent insight
I would've like it more if it was an assertion rather than phrased as questions but that might be a personality thing
I don't know Cat so I'll let it play out
Cooperation is better then assertion this early in the game, i’m asking questions to try and get input from others so I can get a read from there, day 1 tunnels are bad play.
Wiml wrote: ↑Mon May 31, 2021 2:29 pm
Quickly dropping in, I think Sparkles is a pretty clear cut town now (mostly for reasons wrt her case on Cat that I can get into a little later but I think her approach to this game is towny too). Broadly agree with that one post from Cat being wolfy but not as strongly.
Leaning town on Marmot but I don't really have anything I can add on this (also not sure if you remember me from the hydra game we played together relatively recently?).
I'm a bit of a hypocrite but I agree that I think it'll be better to cool off focusing the mech / exile stuff until Night (since we have 24 hours to discuss it then anyway).
Would somebody please be able to tell me how to ISO here? And is there any specific way to vote or is it just announcing your vote + using the poll? Thanks!
I do remember that now!!! Sort of.
Which hydra were you again?
Slow & Steady in the CFC game (the person doing the vast majority of the posting).