Mafia Misplay Mafia

[Esooa]

that doesn't really explain why wolves are just killing someone with 100% wrong reads which is what actually matters there

[santygrass]

@hollowkatt did you reply in why are you voting me instead of Mac? What makes you lean more to me rather than Mac?

[santygrass]

that doesn't really explain why wolves are just killing someone with 100% wrong reads which is what actually matters there

If HK is town they prob killed there to maintain status quo, IMO

[santygrass]

Like, I stand by the fact that one if these three is true by that kill almost always

V!Hollowkatt
W!Achro
W!Lily.


Other thing it could point out is to another UTR slot without much impact being Scum (Wilgz,Jack,Neon)

[Esooa]

Like, I stand by the fact that one if these three is true by that kill almost always

V!Hollowkatt
W!Achro
W!Lily.


Other thing it could point out is to another UTR slot without much impact being Scum (Wilgz,Jack,Neon)

this literally doesn't make any sense but whatever idc to read this game more rn

[santygrass]

Like, I stand by the fact that one if these three is true by that kill almost always

V!Hollowkatt
W!Achro
W!Lily.


Other thing it could point out is to another UTR slot without much impact being Scum (Wilgz,Jack,Neon)

this literally doesn't make any sense but whatever idc to read this game more rn

... Why not?

[santygrass]

Werent Visor reads like, Hk town, sus on me/achro/Lily???

[santygrass]

Also the townread in ris wowee

[Esooa]

v!hollowkatt as one of the options and that is an exclusive reason for the kill is like never true because wolves have multiple options even if they're wanting to kill someone who is explicity townreading HK and killing someone who doesn't wolf read wolf over.. someone who does is just not how it works. And low posting wolves would explicitly rather kill higher posting and more influential people because the thread influence aspect, which OW had very little of, is already important but even more so then. And then this is all amplified by the fact it's a weird kill as you've said yourself

[Achromatic]

Like, I stand by the fact that one if these three is true by that kill almost always

V!Hollowkatt
W!Achro
W!Lily.


Other thing it could point out is to another UTR slot without much impact being Scum (Wilgz,Jack,Neon)

this literally doesn't make any sense but whatever idc to read this game more rn

I mean it can

a) locks in bad reads
b) one less voice in hk's corner down the line

Not saying it has to be this world but 'doesn't make any sense' lacks imaginaton imo.

[santygrass]

v!hollowkatt as one of the options and that is an exclusive reason for the kill is like never true because wolves have multiple options even if they're wanting to kill someone who is explicity townreading HK and killing someone who doesn't wolf read wolf over.. someone who does is just not how it works. And low posting wolves would explicitly rather kill higher posting and more influential people because the thread influence aspect, which OW had very little of, is already important but even more so then. And then this is all amplified by the fact it's a weird kill as you've said yourself

But cant you apply this fact to like, being more vocal people sussing those slots? Why not kill sabi for example?

[Esooa]

Like, I stand by the fact that one if these three is true by that kill almost always

V!Hollowkatt
W!Achro
W!Lily.


Other thing it could point out is to another UTR slot without much impact being Scum (Wilgz,Jack,Neon)

this literally doesn't make any sense but whatever idc to read this game more rn

I mean it can

a) locks in bad reads
b) one less voice in hk's corner down the line

Not saying it has to be this world but 'doesn't make any sense' lacks imaginaton imo.

lock in bad reads is for wolves with influence not low posting wolves and b being the exclusive reason does not happen so yes I still think what I said is true

[Achromatic]

You can't always look at the world as it is, but as the world as it could be.

What if people started today more paranoid of say, me because visor died? It would have been reasonable and then day goes off track wildly.

[santygrass]

And like, there were a lot of vocal voices that influenced the ~vibes~ not being good in thread I'd say. So I dont think Visor Kill to maintain status is crazy to imagine ?

[Achromatic]

Like, I stand by the fact that one if these three is true by that kill almost always

V!Hollowkatt
W!Achro
W!Lily.


Other thing it could point out is to another UTR slot without much impact being Scum (Wilgz,Jack,Neon)

this literally doesn't make any sense but whatever idc to read this game more rn

I mean it can

a) locks in bad reads
b) one less voice in hk's corner down the line

Not saying it has to be this world but 'doesn't make any sense' lacks imaginaton imo.

lock in bad reads is for wolves with influence not low posting wolves and b being the exclusive reason does not happen so yes I still think what I said is true

Okay hold on.

Sorry, I missed the very last sentence by Santy like four times sorry lmao.

Withdrawn.

[Achromatic]

I was dead ass just responding to everything but the last line.

[santygrass]

The last point/sentence is refering on why they could've picked Visor as a kill to maintain status , idk if that is not explained well or what. Like adds up to the equity lf them being Wolf?
Cuz for example Wilgz would be a better kill to maintain status in my mind, them not doing that also speak for the UTR slots

[Esooa]

And like, there were a lot of vocal voices that influenced the ~vibes~ not being good in thread I'd say. So I dont think Visor Kill to maintain status is crazy to imagine ?

Porscha was more town read and seems to fit the description of what you're saying wolves want in killing

Risiinq

Sabi

Wilgy

etc

There's a reason OW was chosen over all of them and I don't think you can just say "some of them made the thread have bad vibes"

[hollowkatt]

@hollowkatt did you reply in why are you voting me instead of Mac? What makes you lean more to me rather than Mac?

I didn't reply. I am voting you because I think you are a wolf. I am not voting mac because I do not think he is a wolf. I have played a metric fuckton of games with mac as all possible alignment combinations (including 3p) and in all of them this is mac indicative behavior, not alignment indicative. I judge mac on the results of his pushes only. It generally takes me a couple of days to get to a read on Mac but when I do it's fairly accurate.

like when achro says "mac is lying about being tilted by sabi" I don't look at that and go "chop all liars" I look at that and go "mac being mac, he'll have a poop and feel better in the morning/afternoon/whatever"

[Esooa]

The last point/sentence is refering on why they could've picked Visor as a kill to maintain status , idk if that is not explained well or what. Like adds up to the equity lf them being Wolf?
Cuz for example Wilgz would be a better kill to maintain status in my mind, them not doing that also speak for the UTR slots

you mean Wilgy not dying over OW when they're similar ones is why Wilgy is more likely a wolf?

I mean sure that on it's own is possible but I don't see why Wilgy specifically is wanting to kill someone like OW either is the problem there

[santygrass]

With that list I agree with Wilg, not so sure about Porscha, cuz in maintaining status i think mostly in killing a player with low impact tbh?
And yeh, it had something that benefitted them (aka why V!hk is a reason there, cuz Visor had a townread there)

[hollowkatt]

v!hollowkatt as one of the options and that is an exclusive reason for the kill is like never true because wolves have multiple options even if they're wanting to kill someone who is explicity townreading HK and killing someone who doesn't wolf read wolf over.. someone who does is just not how it works. And low posting wolves would explicitly rather kill higher posting and more influential people because the thread influence aspect, which OW had very little of, is already important but even more so then. And then this is all amplified by the fact it's a weird kill as you've said yourself

the visor kill points to one of two worlds:
a world where one of the wolf team members is familiar with visor and how, even with low engagement and low presence can just wreck a wolf team
or
a world where the wolf team wanted to solidify visors reads before he could re-evaluate

yeah they look similar but they're really not. One of them is more akin to a fear kill and the other is an advantage kill

[santygrass]

The last point/sentence is refering on why they could've picked Visor as a kill to maintain status , idk if that is not explained well or what. Like adds up to the equity lf them being Wolf?
Cuz for example Wilgz would be a better kill to maintain status in my mind, them not doing that also speak for the UTR slots

you mean Wilgy not dying over OW when they're similar ones is why Wilgy is more likely a wolf?

I mean sure that on it's own is possible but I don't see why Wilgy specifically is wanting to kill someone like OW either is the problem there

In the scenario where hk is a wolf, and me/lily/achro are town, dont you think that Visor being a kill points more of other of the UTR slots being rand > W ?
I dont say that Wilg wanted to kill outed wolf, just saying that the wolf mindset of killing to maintain status and stuff there it would fit better with other slots then, and them bot being the kill then should be taken into account

[hollowkatt]

v!hollowkatt as one of the options and that is an exclusive reason for the kill is like never true because wolves have multiple options even if they're wanting to kill someone who is explicity townreading HK and killing someone who doesn't wolf read wolf over.. someone who does is just not how it works. And low posting wolves would explicitly rather kill higher posting and more influential people because the thread influence aspect, which OW had very little of, is already important but even more so then. And then this is all amplified by the fact it's a weird kill as you've said yourself

But cant you apply this fact to like, being more vocal people sussing those slots? Why not kill sabi for example?

sabi, bless their soul, does not have thread impact or pull even with the massive number of posts that they have. If the wolf team was concerned about sabis pull sabi would be dead.

[Esooa]

The last point/sentence is refering on why they could've picked Visor as a kill to maintain status , idk if that is not explained well or what. Like adds up to the equity lf them being Wolf?
Cuz for example Wilgz would be a better kill to maintain status in my mind, them not doing that also speak for the UTR slots

you mean Wilgy not dying over OW when they're similar ones is why Wilgy is more likely a wolf?

I mean sure that on it's own is possible but I don't see why Wilgy specifically is wanting to kill someone like OW either is the problem there

In the scenario where hk is a wolf, and me/lily/achro are town, dont you think that Visor being a kill points more of other of the UTR slots being rand > W ?
I dont say that Wilg wanted to kill outed wolf, just saying that the wolf mindset of killing to maintain status and stuff there it would fit better with other slots then, and them bot being the kill then should be taken into account

I mean, maintaining status by killing a lower impact slot can be done if the wolves are primarily in people everyone thinks is going to be NK'd. Because an off kill throws them off tracks rather than backing the wolves into a corner in later kills. But, maintaining status as a general kill is done by killing louder and solving voices because once you get rid of everyone that has the WIM to reevaluate constantly and post about alignments a bunch you end up in way more of a stagnant game. So I think Wilgy being the latter matters more than the fact that Wilgy didn't die for this specifically

[Esooa]

And this is part of why I scum read you, as Visor did, and Mac, as he is a frequent night kill as town

[santygrass]

v!hollowkatt as one of the options and that is an exclusive reason for the kill is like never true because wolves have multiple options even if they're wanting to kill someone who is explicity townreading HK and killing someone who doesn't wolf read wolf over.. someone who does is just not how it works. And low posting wolves would explicitly rather kill higher posting and more influential people because the thread influence aspect, which OW had very little of, is already important but even more so then. And then this is all amplified by the fact it's a weird kill as you've said yourself

But cant you apply this fact to like, being more vocal people sussing those slots? Why not kill sabi for example?

sabi, bless their soul, does not have thread impact or pull even with the massive number of posts that they have. If the wolf team was concerned about sabis pull sabi would be dead.

And like, isnt sabi PoE A LOT similar to Visor?

As in Me/Achro/Lily with a lot of sus? Think maybe Mac/Jack too but the three that Visor sussed I remember sabi sussing too, tbh

[hollowkatt]

v!hollowkatt as one of the options and that is an exclusive reason for the kill is like never true because wolves have multiple options even if they're wanting to kill someone who is explicity townreading HK and killing someone who doesn't wolf read wolf over.. someone who does is just not how it works. And low posting wolves would explicitly rather kill higher posting and more influential people because the thread influence aspect, which OW had very little of, is already important but even more so then. And then this is all amplified by the fact it's a weird kill as you've said yourself

But cant you apply this fact to like, being more vocal people sussing those slots? Why not kill sabi for example?

sabi, bless their soul, does not have thread impact or pull even with the massive number of posts that they have. If the wolf team was concerned about sabis pull sabi would be dead.

And like, isnt sabi PoE A LOT similar to Visor?

As in Me/Achro/Lily with a lot of sus? Think maybe Mac/Jack too but the three that Visor sussed I remember sabi sussing too, tbh

if true would point more towards a "wolf team that understands what visor is capable of" I would think, which points squarely at myself, mac, achro, esooa, possibly jackofhearts, and potentially you but I'm unsure of your MU experience or if you've played on sites like The Org or CFC.

[santygrass]

The last point/sentence is refering on why they could've picked Visor as a kill to maintain status , idk if that is not explained well or what. Like adds up to the equity lf them being Wolf?
Cuz for example Wilgz would be a better kill to maintain status in my mind, them not doing that also speak for the UTR slots

you mean Wilgy not dying over OW when they're similar ones is why Wilgy is more likely a wolf?

I mean sure that on it's own is possible but I don't see why Wilgy specifically is wanting to kill someone like OW either is the problem there

In the scenario where hk is a wolf, and me/lily/achro are town, dont you think that Visor being a kill points more of other of the UTR slots being rand > W ?
I dont say that Wilg wanted to kill outed wolf, just saying that the wolf mindset of killing to maintain status and stuff there it would fit better with other slots then, and them bot being the kill then should be taken into account

I mean, maintaining status by killing a lower impact slot can be done if the wolves are primarily in people everyone thinks is going to be NK'd. Because an off kill throws them off tracks rather than backing the wolves into a corner in later kills. But, maintaining status as a general kill is done by killing louder and solving voices because once you get rid of everyone that has the WIM to reevaluate constantly and post about alignments a bunch you end up in way more of a stagnant game. So I think Wilgy being the latter matters more than the fact that Wilgy didn't die for this specifically

Ehh idk if I particularly agree? In sf2 a big part of why we decided to nk a slot, was because he was townreading 2 slots that were yeet material. And it would make just life easier for us. Even deciding to leave other slot (Fext) which had a lot of threadpull and was wary/sussing me. Idk if I fully agree or understand your view of how kills to maintain status are carried

[santygrass]

And this is part of why I scum read you, as Visor did, and Mac, as he is a frequent night kill as town

Also didnt understand thi

[santygrass]

If I played with Visor before, they were alting I'd say. Only played in MU, and recently in a game from supershorty community that just ended yesterday (Didnt want to talk about it because it was going while this started, but also a partial reason on why my D1 was just like super busy and I prefer to slank it mostly and focus on the other game wowee)

[santygrass]

Going to search for a Sabi readlist near EoD, wish me luck

[Esooa]

The last point/sentence is refering on why they could've picked Visor as a kill to maintain status , idk if that is not explained well or what. Like adds up to the equity lf them being Wolf?
Cuz for example Wilgz would be a better kill to maintain status in my mind, them not doing that also speak for the UTR slots

you mean Wilgy not dying over OW when they're similar ones is why Wilgy is more likely a wolf?

I mean sure that on it's own is possible but I don't see why Wilgy specifically is wanting to kill someone like OW either is the problem there

In the scenario where hk is a wolf, and me/lily/achro are town, dont you think that Visor being a kill points more of other of the UTR slots being rand > W ?
I dont say that Wilg wanted to kill outed wolf, just saying that the wolf mindset of killing to maintain status and stuff there it would fit better with other slots then, and them bot being the kill then should be taken into account

I mean, maintaining status by killing a lower impact slot can be done if the wolves are primarily in people everyone thinks is going to be NK'd. Because an off kill throws them off tracks rather than backing the wolves into a corner in later kills. But, maintaining status as a general kill is done by killing louder and solving voices because once you get rid of everyone that has the WIM to reevaluate constantly and post about alignments a bunch you end up in way more of a stagnant game. So I think Wilgy being the latter matters more than the fact that Wilgy didn't die for this specifically

Ehh idk if I particularly agree? In sf2 a big part of why we decided to nk a slot, was because he was townreading 2 slots that were yeet material. And it would make just life easier for us. Even deciding to leave other slot (Fext) which had a lot of threadpull and was wary/sussing me. Idk if I fully agree or understand your view of how kills to maintain status are carried

I'm not talking particularly about the reads people who die have, but their post tendencies, whether it's low-impact with less posts like OW or higher impact with more posts like Achro. Wolves p often kill their opposites I guess you could say there and that's been true in some way in I think every game I've played since I started again, at least what I remember. For the reasons I explained and other things. So OW dying isn't scum indicative for people like Wilgy but Mac instead

[Esooa]

Like, a wolf playing as Wilgy or Nanook are just won't stand up to Achro or Mac come later in the game. They just won't. So Achro and Mac need to die.

Achro or Mac as wolves will be sus'd out by the fact they are alive because they are supposed to be dying with how they are posting/usually do. So they can't make kills that are normal, onto for example the other in the pair. It'll just lead people to them. Leaving the other alive gives more options for people to be paranoid of, and confuses the NKA.

[Esooa]

The above is why Mac kills OW

[Lilypetal]

im gonna probs check out of this game till maybe eod kill mac thx

[santygrass]

Forget it. I hate ISOing here I cant find shit and It really annoys me

[santygrass]

The last point/sentence is refering on why they could've picked Visor as a kill to maintain status , idk if that is not explained well or what. Like adds up to the equity lf them being Wolf?
Cuz for example Wilgz would be a better kill to maintain status in my mind, them not doing that also speak for the UTR slots

you mean Wilgy not dying over OW when they're similar ones is why Wilgy is more likely a wolf?

I mean sure that on it's own is possible but I don't see why Wilgy specifically is wanting to kill someone like OW either is the problem there

In the scenario where hk is a wolf, and me/lily/achro are town, dont you think that Visor being a kill points more of other of the UTR slots being rand > W ?
I dont say that Wilg wanted to kill outed wolf, just saying that the wolf mindset of killing to maintain status and stuff there it would fit better with other slots then, and them bot being the kill then should be taken into account

I mean, maintaining status by killing a lower impact slot can be done if the wolves are primarily in people everyone thinks is going to be NK'd. Because an off kill throws them off tracks rather than backing the wolves into a corner in later kills. But, maintaining status as a general kill is done by killing louder and solving voices because once you get rid of everyone that has the WIM to reevaluate constantly and post about alignments a bunch you end up in way more of a stagnant game. So I think Wilgy being the latter matters more than the fact that Wilgy didn't die for this specifically

Ehh idk if I particularly agree? In sf2 a big part of why we decided to nk a slot, was because he was townreading 2 slots that were yeet material. And it would make just life easier for us. Even deciding to leave other slot (Fext) which had a lot of threadpull and was wary/sussing me. Idk if I fully agree or understand your view of how kills to maintain status are carried

I'm not talking particularly about the reads people who die have, but their post tendencies, whether it's low-impact with less posts like OW or higher impact with more posts like Achro. Wolves p often kill their opposites I guess you could say there and that's been true in some way in I think every game I've played since I started again, at least what I remember. For the reasons I explained and other things. So OW dying isn't scum indicative for people like Wilgy but Mac instead

Ah yeah, I can see that. My point to look at Wilgy there is mostly that 'if that scum mindset why didnt you die' kind of deal

[DrWilgy]

Imt still just sheeping Sabi... But now that Mac's in the lead I wonder if I'm to move to Santi.

Concern.

[santygrass]

Is there a correct way to ISO? Cuz when I did the post search on Sabi it bringed me up even results from post in other topics wowee. And I hate that quotes just dont let me read the content sabi put in a post wowee

[santygrass]

Imt still just sheeping Sabi... But now that Mac's in the lead I wonder if I'm to move to Santi.

Concern.

How are you sheeping sabi? Sabi has been voting and insisting to vote for me since D1

[DrWilgy]

Is there a correct way to ISO? Cuz when I did the post search on Sabi it bringed me up even results from post in other topics wowee. And I hate that quotes just dont let me read the content sabi put in a post wowee

Not sure if this helps, but I go back into the the topics list, select "replies" then click on the number next to whomever I like to eyeball.

[DrWilgy]

Imt still just sheeping Sabi... But now that Mac's in the lead I wonder if I'm to move to Santi.

Concern.

How are you sheeping sabi? Sabi has been voting and insisting to vote for me since D1

Sabi said they wanted a Mac wagon and to stay on Mac.

I don't disagree with the Mac wagon, and I trust Sabi, but idk what the nearest confirmed town player who has read more than me wants rn lol.

[hollowkatt]

Is there a correct way to ISO? Cuz when I did the post search on Sabi it bringed me up even results from post in other topics wowee. And I hate that quotes just dont let me read the content sabi put in a post wowee

ok.
at the top of your screen, below the syndicate banner you'll see "board index > active mafia games > the hustle"
Click "the Hustle"
You'll see our game listed.
Click the number in the Replies column. This brings up the post count by player screen. Click the number in the posts column to see only the posts from that player in this game.

Alternately find the player you want to ISO in the game thread. Click the "Posts in topic" number.

[Esooa]

Is there a correct way to ISO? Cuz when I did the post search on Sabi it bringed me up even results from post in other topics wowee. And I hate that quotes just dont let me read the content sabi put in a post wowee

go to the hustle, click replies, then click on the number of posts a person has and it'll show you only their posts

Or if not on mobile click the post number under their pfp

[santygrass]

Omg tysm Im crying

[santygrass]

My WIM just went up a notch

[Lilypetal]

My WIM just went up a notch

wim these

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

@Neon I think I already asked you this and probably forgot the answer already. Could you elaborate on Mac? What are some posts that pinged you as towny? What do you think about his pushes and solving?

I believe him and I'd he's playing me well gg. I believe his WiM is shot and I believe he was barely trying d1. I believe he tried to muster the WiM and went into trying to generate content and solve. I don't know how much stock I would put into how attacked he feels but the explosion happened so maybe I should buy into that too.

Or this has all been a game and because AtE is allowed the wolfies are AtEing it up for funnies. If the wolf team is Mac and HK I am gonna laugh my ass off.

But I believe Mac and the way he's been acting and I think he's gonna flip town because he just doesn't care about mafia anymore and if I'm wrong... well I've been wrong a lot lately.

I'm catching up ignore me if any of this no longer applies.

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

In my time away the only thing that has held true is that we need to yeet Neon.

...why?