Batman: The Animated Series mafia win

[EnderWiggin]

everyone wolf reads alison but its not relevant

We call this statement an Exaggeration where I come from.

[Epignosis]

[VOTE: Falcon45ca] aubergine

[VOTE: Falcon45ca] aubergine

Thats unexpected, I expected you to go for finger, lime, sean or Tran

The cart before the horse play-by-play while standing on the sidelines doesn't sit well with me.

Falcon looks too comfortable with how today is shaping up, and I for damn sure am not.

Whatever happened to this read? Given Made's flip, I'd have thought Epi would come roaring after me, but he hasn't said a word

If there's a script I'm supposed to be following, nobody mailed it to me.

[EnderWiggin]

@NotAnAxehole

Who is your top townread atm.

[NotAnAxehole]

that seems needlessly insulting axehole

Welcome to Axe.

Insulting but townreads wolves. =P

In fairness, I did say last game that when Nanook and I are T/T, we don't lose... That remains true.

[EnderWiggin]

[VOTE: Falcon45ca] aubergine

[VOTE: Falcon45ca] aubergine

Thats unexpected, I expected you to go for finger, lime, sean or Tran

The cart before the horse play-by-play while standing on the sidelines doesn't sit well with me.

Falcon looks too comfortable with how today is shaping up, and I for damn sure am not.

Whatever happened to this read? Given Made's flip, I'd have thought Epi would come roaring after me, but he hasn't said a word

If there's a script I'm supposed to be following, nobody mailed it to me.

Postal delays. Give it a week.

[EnderWiggin]

that seems needlessly insulting axehole

Welcome to Axe.

Insulting but townreads wolves. =P

In fairness, I did say last game that when Nanook and I are T/T, we don't lose... That remains true.

In fairness, you did.

In fairness, you also hard-defended him as a wolf.

[NotAnAxehole]

that seems needlessly insulting axehole

Welcome to Axe.

Insulting but townreads wolves. =P

In fairness, I did say last game that when Nanook and I are T/T, we don't lose... That remains true.

In fairness, you did.

In fairness, you also hard-defended him as a wolf.

Yeah, I need a sounding board to work with in order to seperate what I think is true, and what I want to be true.

[EnderWiggin]

I'm just going to drop that subject methinks.

[falcon45ca]

Hi fam

You suck for missing all of D1 except some ghost votes right at EOD.


What's your reasoning behind your votes, including on myself?

I wanted to demonstrate how easily your behavior can be dictated by another player in the game.

It's a team game, so yeah. You proved that the circle's are round, and triangles have 3 sides.



What other self-evident truths do you have in store for us?

Epi probably stopped pushing you because he realizes that you are probably incapable of playing mafia, and therefore, have limited possibility to end up as a ML. What they probably failed to recognize is that everyone pretty much has the attention span of a gnat, they will end up with too many town reads, re-evaluate and then you become killable even though you can't play the game, and are an obvious read.

Still upset you never got picked for dodgeball at recess, eh?

See, what you fail to realize is that being picked for dodgeball and other sports has little to do with your skill level when you're a kid.


It has to do with whether people like you or not...so, not.

[Kami]

so notanaxehole is an axehole?

[EnderWiggin]

Falcon, top 5 reads in terms of how convinced you are they're true?

[EnderWiggin]

so notanaxehole is an axehole?

Yes.

[EnderWiggin]

Head hurts so I can't sleep so you'll have to put up with me a bit longer tonight.

[Epignosis]

My original suspicion of him (as stated) was mostly to do with how he had a ton of votes and then the heat backed away off of him. Then I voted for him when the vote was tied as I didn’t want the mafia to be the deciding.

This reasoning finds Made guilty on the basis of what other people do rather than what Made has done himself. It's also a reasoning that can apply to anyone regardless of content. What's the alternative here? Made stays in the lead all of Day 1 and dies anyway?

I have to struggle to believe this was a genuine suspicion on your part.

[falcon45ca]

[VOTE: Falcon45ca] aubergine

[VOTE: Falcon45ca] aubergine

Thats unexpected, I expected you to go for finger, lime, sean or Tran

The cart before the horse play-by-play while standing on the sidelines doesn't sit well with me.

Falcon looks too comfortable with how today is shaping up, and I for damn sure am not.

Whatever happened to this read? Given Made's flip, I'd have thought Epi would come roaring after me, but he hasn't said a word

If there's a script I'm supposed to be following, nobody mailed it to me.

I'm freestylin' yo

[EnderWiggin]

Most "Freestyle" raps are either scripted or bad, change my mind.

[NotAnAxehole]

so notanaxehole is an axehole?

I would argue that I'm just honest to a fault, it's why I suck at mafia.

I don't see the point in taking a roundabout path to say something ala Falcon.

[fingersplints]

funnily enough it was fingersplints who pointed out that ties are decided by the wolves in this game

This isn’t true.

Here is my mention of it:

Splints vote is kinda sus tbh. where was Fingersplints vote before?

Also the mafia decides the tie, so if I was mafia why wouldn’t I just leave the vote tied and decide it secretly behind the scenes.

Oh yea because I’m not mafia

And here is earlier mentions:

Dont want the wolves being able to pick who they want. I want to know you switched to HK and HK gets lynched

Wolves only pick if it's still tied at EOD. Watching votes dance around at the end is where you get fun info.

[Epignosis]

Hi fam

You suck for missing all of D1 except some ghost votes right at EOD.


What's your reasoning behind your votes, including on myself?

I wanted to demonstrate how easily your behavior can be dictated by another player in the game.

It's a team game, so yeah. You proved that the circle's are round, and triangles have 3 sides.



What other self-evident truths do you have in store for us?

Epi probably stopped pushing you because he realizes that you are probably incapable of playing mafia, and therefore, have limited possibility to end up as a ML. What they probably failed to recognize is that everyone pretty much has the attention span of a gnat, they will end up with too many town reads, re-evaluate and then you become killable even though you can't play the game, and are an obvious read.

Eh?

[NotAnAxehole]

Hi fam

You suck for missing all of D1 except some ghost votes right at EOD.


What's your reasoning behind your votes, including on myself?

I wanted to demonstrate how easily your behavior can be dictated by another player in the game.

It's a team game, so yeah. You proved that the circle's are round, and triangles have 3 sides.



What other self-evident truths do you have in store for us?

Epi probably stopped pushing you because he realizes that you are probably incapable of playing mafia, and therefore, have limited possibility to end up as a ML. What they probably failed to recognize is that everyone pretty much has the attention span of a gnat, they will end up with too many town reads, re-evaluate and then you become killable even though you can't play the game, and are an obvious read.

Eh?

So the latter then.

[falcon45ca]

Most "Freestyle" raps are either scripted or bad, change my mind.

Watch the video

[falcon45ca]

Falcon, top 5 reads in terms of how convinced you are they're true?

Syn town, Transcend town, Sean scum, HK scum, Finger scum

[EnderWiggin]

Most "Freestyle" raps are either scripted or bad, change my mind.

Watch the video

I did.

He starts out strong then really stretches to pull it all together (Especially the whole tradewar segue that was bad.)

To his credit, those were some wild suggestions he had to knit together.

[fingersplints]

My original suspicion of him (as stated) was mostly to do with how he had a ton of votes and then the heat backed away off of him. Then I voted for him when the vote was tied as I didn’t want the mafia to be the deciding.

This reasoning finds Made guilty on the basis of what other people do rather than what Made has done himself. It's also a reasoning that can apply to anyone regardless of content. What's the alternative here? Made stays in the lead all of Day 1 and dies anyway?

I have to struggle to believe this was a genuine suspicion on your part.

Just because you struggle doesn’t make in both genuine. Day 1 suspicions have never been my strong suit.

Made wouldn’t have needed to stay in the lead all of the day. It was how the votes died away AND the discussion. Seemed like possible maybe some teammates voted early then backed off when they thought safe. Seemed to make more sense to figure out Made before deciding who could be possible teammates.

Plus hollowkat was engaging with me and asking me questions whereas Made had just voted for me so I retaliated with a vote back because between the two I would have preferred Made to go in that moment. And I’m almost 8 months pregnant, so my voting is a bit reactionary like that these days.
Obviously Made is town and I don’t know about HK so the vote for Made was wrong but tbd if not wanting HK lynched that day was the wrong move too

[EnderWiggin]

Fingers, top five reads you're confident in, either Alignment

[RondoDimBuckle]

Falcon, top 5 reads in terms of how convinced you are they're true?

Syn town, Transcend town, Sean scum, HK scum, Finger scum

OK, so full disclosure...I am thoroughly invested in Epi being town right now.


He's my boy, Blue. Won't reevaluate til F3

What happened?

[falcon45ca]

Falcon, top 5 reads in terms of how convinced you are they're true?

Syn town, Transcend town, Sean scum, HK scum, Finger scum

OK, so full disclosure...I am thoroughly invested in Epi being town right now.


He's my boy, Blue. Won't reevaluate til F3

What happened?

My read changed. I quoted Epi and stated why

[fingersplints]

Fingers, top five reads you're confident in, either Alignment

I’ve included my last ranking so I could talk about changes in my thoughts from last time I listed everyone:

Spoiler: show

I sorted everyone into a list for further clarification about where my thoughts stand.


Epignosis
Alison
Seanzie
Transcend

Kami
EnderWiggin

LimeCoke
Falcon
Hollowkatt
Syn
Esooa

Made
Rondo

N/A NAA

Most notably for me since my last posting is that I find I have felt better about EnderWiggin’s posting as of late. Not enough to put in my top town tier, but I thought he held up decently to Epi.

I don’t see the case on Kami. and have agreed with some comments. I’m starting to think that this is a similar case to myself that they just play a little differently.

I still think Epi and Alison are town even though they dont feel the same.
Transcend and Seanzie have moved lower down on the list. Not as confident there. They would actually probably switch places with you and kami, who I feel more confident both of you are town.

I don’t feel good about Rondo still. Their posts have been better, but the suspicious part of my brain wonders if it’s because they have a teammate who arrived in the chat to help them. I didn’t like NAA’s vote no posts yesterday.

So

More confident town
Epignosis
Alison
Kami
EnderWiggin

Probably town
Seanzie
Transcend
Esooa

POE/ less confident suspicions
Falcon
Hollowkatt
Syn

More confident suspicions:
Rondo
NAA

I’ve only skimmed since the night post, so I’d still like to read more fully but this is how I’m feeling right now

[hollowkatt]

@fingersplints I get me, rondo, and naa on your bad guys list. But why Syn and Falcon?

[falcon45ca]

@fingersplints I get me, rondo, and naa on your bad guys list. But why Syn and Falcon?

I have that same question, I don't recall seeing her mention us really in her posting

[hollowkatt]

@fingersplints I get me, rondo, and naa on your bad guys list. But why Syn and Falcon?

I have that same question, I don't recall seeing her mention us really in her posting

yeah. Mostly it's you and Syn there. My presence towards the bottom isn't a surprise

[falcon45ca]

Rondo does not seem the type who needed a teammate to help him out in BTSC, kind of a strange read IMO

[fingersplints]

@fingersplints I get me, rondo, and naa on your bad guys list. But why Syn and Falcon?

Because I don’t have town reads on either.

[hollowkatt]

@fingersplints I get me, rondo, and naa on your bad guys list. But why Syn and Falcon?

Because I don’t have town reads on either.

do you wolf read them?

[fingersplints]

Rondo does not seem the type who needed a teammate to help him out in BTSC, kind of a strange read IMO

Is it really that strange of a read to think someone who has said this is the first forum game might get advice from a teammate? I don’t think it’s strange at all. Especially given they changed entirely how they were playing.

[Transcend]

Fingers, top five reads you're confident in, either Alignment

I’ve included my last ranking so I could talk about changes in my thoughts from last time I listed everyone:

Spoiler: show

I sorted everyone into a list for further clarification about where my thoughts stand.


Epignosis
Alison
Seanzie
Transcend

Kami
EnderWiggin

LimeCoke
Falcon
Hollowkatt
Syn
Esooa

Made
Rondo

N/A NAA

Most notably for me since my last posting is that I find I have felt better about EnderWiggin’s posting as of late. Not enough to put in my top town tier, but I thought he held up decently to Epi.

I don’t see the case on Kami. and have agreed with some comments. I’m starting to think that this is a similar case to myself that they just play a little differently.

I still think Epi and Alison are town even though they dont feel the same.
Transcend and Seanzie have moved lower down on the list. Not as confident there. They would actually probably switch places with you and kami, who I feel more confident both of you are town.

I don’t feel good about Rondo still. Their posts have been better, but the suspicious part of my brain wonders if it’s because they have a teammate who arrived in the chat to help them. I didn’t like NAA’s vote no posts yesterday.

So

More confident town
Epignosis
Alison
Kami
EnderWiggin

Probably town
Seanzie
Transcend
Esooa

POE/ less confident suspicions
Falcon
Hollowkatt
Syn

More confident suspicions:
Rondo
NAA

I’ve only skimmed since the night post, so I’d still like to read more fully but this is how I’m feeling right now

I guess it's consistent w ur d1 but it's still kinda sus that ur top two trs rn are the ones voting u

Also i dropped for ??? reasons

[fingersplints]

@fingersplints I get me, rondo, and naa on your bad guys list. But why Syn and Falcon?

Because I don’t have town reads on either.

do you wolf read them?

Don’t have a solid feeling on either. So neutral/POE for lack of any town feels

[falcon45ca]

Rondo does not seem the type who needed a teammate to help him out in BTSC, kind of a strange read IMO

Is it really that strange of a read to think someone who has said this is the first forum game might get advice from a teammate? I don’t think it’s strange at all. Especially given they changed entirely how they were playing.

We were told they love trolling, so yeah it is strange. Plus, such a sudden about face in playstyle seems pretty obvs way to draw attention if they're a wolf, no?

[Transcend]

Katt respond to my opening post pls

[hollowkatt]

Katt respond to my opening post pls

why, is it a good post?

[hollowkatt]

@fingersplints I get me, rondo, and naa on your bad guys list. But why Syn and Falcon?

Because I don’t have town reads on either.

do you wolf read them?

Don’t have a solid feeling on either. So neutral/POE for lack of any town feels

weird, putting neutral/null into poe this early.

[falcon45ca]

How do you have a probably TR on Sean w/ his 60 posts, but have no read on Syn and I who both have double the number of posts?


What did Sean do that allows you to read him @fingersplints ?

[Kami]

yeah that list is weird as fuck ngl

[Transcend]

Katt respond to my opening post pls

why, is it a good post?

Probably not good for u

But i'm p much locked in on u as wolf unless u can prove me otherwise

[fingersplints]

Fingers, top five reads you're confident in, either Alignment

I’ve included my last ranking so I could talk about changes in my thoughts from last time I listed everyone:

Spoiler: show

I sorted everyone into a list for further clarification about where my thoughts stand.


Epignosis
Alison
Seanzie
Transcend

Kami
EnderWiggin

LimeCoke
Falcon
Hollowkatt
Syn
Esooa

Made
Rondo

N/A NAA

Most notably for me since my last posting is that I find I have felt better about EnderWiggin’s posting as of late. Not enough to put in my top town tier, but I thought he held up decently to Epi.

I don’t see the case on Kami. and have agreed with some comments. I’m starting to think that this is a similar case to myself that they just play a little differently.

I still think Epi and Alison are town even though they dont feel the same.
Transcend and Seanzie have moved lower down on the list. Not as confident there. They would actually probably switch places with you and kami, who I feel more confident both of you are town.

I don’t feel good about Rondo still. Their posts have been better, but the suspicious part of my brain wonders if it’s because they have a teammate who arrived in the chat to help them. I didn’t like NAA’s vote no posts yesterday.

So

More confident town
Epignosis
Alison
Kami
EnderWiggin

Probably town
Seanzie
Transcend
Esooa

POE/ less confident suspicions
Falcon
Hollowkatt
Syn

More confident suspicions:
Rondo
NAA

I’ve only skimmed since the night post, so I’d still like to read more fully but this is how I’m feeling right now

I guess it's consistent w ur d1 but it's still kinda sus that ur top two trs rn are the ones voting u

Also i dropped for ??? reasons

Tiers aren’t necessarily in order. Just grouped by similar feelings.
I try not to let other people’s feelings on my game dictate what I feel about theirs. People can be wrong

[Transcend]

How do you have a probably TR on Sean w/ his 60 posts, but have no read on Syn and I who both have double the number of posts?


What did Sean do that allows you to read him @fingersplints ?

Bad

[RondoDimBuckle]

Rondo does not seem the type who needed a teammate to help him out in BTSC, kind of a strange read IMO

Is it really that strange of a read to think someone who has said this is the first forum game might get advice from a teammate? I don’t think it’s strange at all. Especially given they changed entirely how they were playing.

I changed how I was playing because you all sucked the fun out of it

[Kami]

i wouldnt say its a list from a wolf though

[hollowkatt]

Katt respond to my opening post pls

why, is it a good post?

Probably not good for u

But i'm p much locked in on u as wolf unless u can prove me otherwise

oh, that's sad then. Guess I'll die

[hollowkatt]

How do you have a probably TR on Sean w/ his 60 posts, but have no read on Syn and I who both have double the number of posts?


What did Sean do that allows you to read him @fingersplints ?

Bad

I dunno, that seems good to me. Oops I spewed falcon town my bad wolf bros