honey wrote: ↑Thu Jul 15, 2021 7:41 pm
good job hk, you will get pets after we scum flip tsp but we gotta do that first
HK's attitude leaves much to be desired.
I'm going here for now, since this is scum and HK is a whole lot of bad attitude. [VOTE:
TSP] aubergine
Ah yes, the begrudging bus of a teammate because their goose is cooked.
Side note, one thanksgiving we were visiting family in Indiana and someone hit and ran on a deer outside their farm. So we find the deer dying in the woods, relative puts it out of its misery and tried skinning and cooking it to not let it go to waste. Well, it had some sort of parasite so we had to let it go anyway and LO AND BEHOLD a goose died right outside an hour before dinner and they threw that in the fryer and we had that as an addendum to our normal turkey and it was pretty damned good
Do you have an actual scumread on me or are you just sheeping HK's bad read?
The dinner does sound delicious, however. The goose, for sure, was cooked.
As I’ve previously cased, I don’t have a strong reason to NOT read you as mafia. TH (I think or maybe it was flea) filled me in that you asking questions and being in the periphery is NAI. I see it as not exactly towncore
You are scum reading me because you don't have a reason not to scumread me? But you also don't have much of a reason to scum read me. Logic isn't really my strong suit, but yours seems to be flawed. It sounds like you have a town core of a few people and then everyone else is scum. In other words, you believe that you are surrounded by scum. Everywhere you turn, there's someone who is not in your town core, and that's yet another scum. You need to build a moat filled with pirhana. Or hide. One of the two.
Do you think you deserve to be considered in the “towncore” of this game? Asking honestly
Probably not. I know that my style looks a bit scummy and that it would take a real leap of faith to put me into your town core. And I also know that people find me hard to read, or so they say.
And I will ask the same question again. Knowing that I tend to play somewhat scummy, regardless of alignment, how do you read me?
[VOTE:
HK] auberginebut sure, since I'm effectively useless I'm the right kill for today. Wolves won't ever kill me b/c I'm a potential mischop every day. I have to be resolved now.
glgl
EnderWiggin wrote: ↑Fri Jul 16, 2021 10:40 am
HK being willing to immediately vote himself just makes him more town tbh.
it's actually the towniest post that I've seen from HK, which makes me more convinced than ever that I was voting him because I didn't like his attitude, which is not a good reason for a vote.
HK's attitude leaves much to be desired.
I'm going here for now, since this is scum and HK is a whole lot of bad attitude. [VOTE:
TSP] aubergine
Ah yes, the begrudging bus of a teammate because their goose is cooked.
Side note, one thanksgiving we were visiting family in Indiana and someone hit and ran on a deer outside their farm. So we find the deer dying in the woods, relative puts it out of its misery and tried skinning and cooking it to not let it go to waste. Well, it had some sort of parasite so we had to let it go anyway and LO AND BEHOLD a goose died right outside an hour before dinner and they threw that in the fryer and we had that as an addendum to our normal turkey and it was pretty damned good
Do you have an actual scumread on me or are you just sheeping HK's bad read?
The dinner does sound delicious, however. The goose, for sure, was cooked.
As I’ve previously cased, I don’t have a strong reason to NOT read you as mafia. TH (I think or maybe it was flea) filled me in that you asking questions and being in the periphery is NAI. I see it as not exactly towncore
You are scum reading me because you don't have a reason not to scumread me? But you also don't have much of a reason to scum read me. Logic isn't really my strong suit, but yours seems to be flawed. It sounds like you have a town core of a few people and then everyone else is scum. In other words, you believe that you are surrounded by scum. Everywhere you turn, there's someone who is not in your town core, and that's yet another scum. You need to build a moat filled with pirhana. Or hide. One of the two.
Do you think you deserve to be considered in the “towncore” of this game? Asking honestly
Probably not. I know that my style looks a bit scummy and that it would take a real leap of faith to put me into your town core. And I also know that people find me hard to read, or so they say.
And I will ask the same question again. Knowing that I tend to play somewhat scummy, regardless of alignment, how do you read me?
I mean I don’t know that you tend to play somewhat scummy, because I don’t think I’ve ever played with you.
In this game, the scummy behavior I see is asking questions, seemingly doing nothing with the answers, and spending the rest of the time talking about your self prescribed scumminess as a defense.
So. I read you as not town-favoring. Scum lean. Could be difference in playstyle approach but if you normally play scummy, that’s…not a good approach to be read…as town.
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
I think the biggest thing that sucks here is it's super easy for wolves to vote me b/c "I have to be resolved" even though I do absolutely have to be resolved.
MacDougall wrote: ↑Fri Jul 16, 2021 8:12 am
you either can't read spew or you're a wolf. you tell me which one it is.
You tell me how "Light sus but never pushing for votes" is town spew.
Lightly sussing partners is the absolute minimum entry for bussing strats.
Scum players almost ALWAYS have at least one light sus on a team mate.
Your view of creature is my view of osie.
Michelle had her vote on osie for 24 hours, based on nothing, but osie was never in danger of getting votes. Then she soft defends osie down the line and retracts seemingly ever sussing them.
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
hollowkatt wrote: ↑Fri Jul 16, 2021 11:46 am
I think the biggest thing that sucks here is it's super easy for wolves to vote me b/c "I have to be resolved" even though I do absolutely have to be resolved.
What ALSO sucks is that Dolby made the right shot, but if Dolby were mafia, they also would have made that same shot knowing it would hit town.
Though Dolby bumps up in my ranks because he didn’t have to shoot, coulda left this to be a mislynch on TSP, then we kill you tomorrow
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
hollowkatt wrote: ↑Fri Jul 16, 2021 11:46 am
I think the biggest thing that sucks here is it's super easy for wolves to vote me b/c "I have to be resolved" even though I do absolutely have to be resolved.
What ALSO sucks is that Dolby made the right shot, but if Dolby were mafia, they also would have made that same shot knowing it would hit town.
Though Dolby bumps up in my ranks because he didn’t have to shoot, coulda left this to be a mislynch on TSP, then we kill you tomorrow
otoh shooting TSP knowing TSP flips town gives them the chance (if you are town) to kill three townies today.
Shoot TSP - flips town makes me absolutely need to be resolved
Chop Scotty via Prosecutor
Chop HK for the day b/c has to be resolved.
Scotty wrote: ↑Thu Jul 15, 2021 8:47 pm
Ah yes, the begrudging bus of a teammate because their goose is cooked.
Side note, one thanksgiving we were visiting family in Indiana and someone hit and ran on a deer outside their farm. So we find the deer dying in the woods, relative puts it out of its misery and tried skinning and cooking it to not let it go to waste. Well, it had some sort of parasite so we had to let it go anyway and LO AND BEHOLD a goose died right outside an hour before dinner and they threw that in the fryer and we had that as an addendum to our normal turkey and it was pretty damned good
Do you have an actual scumread on me or are you just sheeping HK's bad read?
The dinner does sound delicious, however. The goose, for sure, was cooked.
As I’ve previously cased, I don’t have a strong reason to NOT read you as mafia. TH (I think or maybe it was flea) filled me in that you asking questions and being in the periphery is NAI. I see it as not exactly towncore
You are scum reading me because you don't have a reason not to scumread me? But you also don't have much of a reason to scum read me. Logic isn't really my strong suit, but yours seems to be flawed. It sounds like you have a town core of a few people and then everyone else is scum. In other words, you believe that you are surrounded by scum. Everywhere you turn, there's someone who is not in your town core, and that's yet another scum. You need to build a moat filled with pirhana. Or hide. One of the two.
Do you think you deserve to be considered in the “towncore” of this game? Asking honestly
Probably not. I know that my style looks a bit scummy and that it would take a real leap of faith to put me into your town core. And I also know that people find me hard to read, or so they say.
And I will ask the same question again. Knowing that I tend to play somewhat scummy, regardless of alignment, how do you read me?
I mean I don’t know that you tend to play somewhat scummy, because I don’t think I’ve ever played with you.
In this game, the scummy behavior I see is asking questions, seemingly doing nothing with the answers, and spending the rest of the time talking about your self prescribed scumminess as a defense.
So. I read you as not town-favoring. Scum lean. Could be difference in playstyle approach but if you normally play scummy, that’s…not a good approach to be read…as town.
I don't play scummy on purpose. And, yes, I know that asking questions is considered scummy. But, for me, it has to be considered NAI. I am a journalist, and that's how I gather information, IRL and in mafia games. I don't know any other ways to get people to talk more about themselves and how they are seeing than to ask them questions, preferably open-ended questions and then to either discuss their answers with them or ask follow-up questions.
Do you have an actual scumread on me or are you just sheeping HK's bad read?
The dinner does sound delicious, however. The goose, for sure, was cooked.
As I’ve previously cased, I don’t have a strong reason to NOT read you as mafia. TH (I think or maybe it was flea) filled me in that you asking questions and being in the periphery is NAI. I see it as not exactly towncore
You are scum reading me because you don't have a reason not to scumread me? But you also don't have much of a reason to scum read me. Logic isn't really my strong suit, but yours seems to be flawed. It sounds like you have a town core of a few people and then everyone else is scum. In other words, you believe that you are surrounded by scum. Everywhere you turn, there's someone who is not in your town core, and that's yet another scum. You need to build a moat filled with pirhana. Or hide. One of the two.
Do you think you deserve to be considered in the “towncore” of this game? Asking honestly
Probably not. I know that my style looks a bit scummy and that it would take a real leap of faith to put me into your town core. And I also know that people find me hard to read, or so they say.
And I will ask the same question again. Knowing that I tend to play somewhat scummy, regardless of alignment, how do you read me?
I mean I don’t know that you tend to play somewhat scummy, because I don’t think I’ve ever played with you.
In this game, the scummy behavior I see is asking questions, seemingly doing nothing with the answers, and spending the rest of the time talking about your self prescribed scumminess as a defense.
So. I read you as not town-favoring. Scum lean. Could be difference in playstyle approach but if you normally play scummy, that’s…not a good approach to be read…as town.
I don't play scummy on purpose. And, yes, I know that asking questions is considered scummy. But, for me, it has to be considered NAI. I am a journalist, and that's how I gather information, IRL and in mafia games. I don't know any other ways to get people to talk more about themselves and how they are seeing than to ask them questions, preferably open-ended questions and then to either discuss their answers with them or ask follow-up questions.
But what do you plan to do with the information you're gathering? Like that seems to me to be what's lacking
Scotty wrote: ↑Thu Jul 15, 2021 9:31 pm
As I’ve previously cased, I don’t have a strong reason to NOT read you as mafia. TH (I think or maybe it was flea) filled me in that you asking questions and being in the periphery is NAI. I see it as not exactly towncore
You are scum reading me because you don't have a reason not to scumread me? But you also don't have much of a reason to scum read me. Logic isn't really my strong suit, but yours seems to be flawed. It sounds like you have a town core of a few people and then everyone else is scum. In other words, you believe that you are surrounded by scum. Everywhere you turn, there's someone who is not in your town core, and that's yet another scum. You need to build a moat filled with pirhana. Or hide. One of the two.
Do you think you deserve to be considered in the “towncore” of this game? Asking honestly
Probably not. I know that my style looks a bit scummy and that it would take a real leap of faith to put me into your town core. And I also know that people find me hard to read, or so they say.
And I will ask the same question again. Knowing that I tend to play somewhat scummy, regardless of alignment, how do you read me?
I mean I don’t know that you tend to play somewhat scummy, because I don’t think I’ve ever played with you.
In this game, the scummy behavior I see is asking questions, seemingly doing nothing with the answers, and spending the rest of the time talking about your self prescribed scumminess as a defense.
So. I read you as not town-favoring. Scum lean. Could be difference in playstyle approach but if you normally play scummy, that’s…not a good approach to be read…as town.
I don't play scummy on purpose. And, yes, I know that asking questions is considered scummy. But, for me, it has to be considered NAI. I am a journalist, and that's how I gather information, IRL and in mafia games. I don't know any other ways to get people to talk more about themselves and how they are seeing than to ask them questions, preferably open-ended questions and then to either discuss their answers with them or ask follow-up questions.
But what do you plan to do with the information you're gathering? Like that seems to me to be what's lacking
I sort through it but a lot of it leads me to dead ends so, then, I get stuck and am still unsure of how to read people. This is the weak link for me. Translating information into reads and action.
I didn't see an announcement when I looked at guillo's iso so I figured we still could? Unclear to me exactly how it works/worked so I could be mistaken but I thought it was still an option
Do you have an actual scumread on me or are you just sheeping HK's bad read?
The dinner does sound delicious, however. The goose, for sure, was cooked.
As I’ve previously cased, I don’t have a strong reason to NOT read you as mafia. TH (I think or maybe it was flea) filled me in that you asking questions and being in the periphery is NAI. I see it as not exactly towncore
You are scum reading me because you don't have a reason not to scumread me? But you also don't have much of a reason to scum read me. Logic isn't really my strong suit, but yours seems to be flawed. It sounds like you have a town core of a few people and then everyone else is scum. In other words, you believe that you are surrounded by scum. Everywhere you turn, there's someone who is not in your town core, and that's yet another scum. You need to build a moat filled with pirhana. Or hide. One of the two.
Do you think you deserve to be considered in the “towncore” of this game? Asking honestly
Probably not. I know that my style looks a bit scummy and that it would take a real leap of faith to put me into your town core. And I also know that people find me hard to read, or so they say.
And I will ask the same question again. Knowing that I tend to play somewhat scummy, regardless of alignment, how do you read me?
I mean I don’t know that you tend to play somewhat scummy, because I don’t think I’ve ever played with you.
In this game, the scummy behavior I see is asking questions, seemingly doing nothing with the answers, and spending the rest of the time talking about your self prescribed scumminess as a defense.
So. I read you as not town-favoring. Scum lean. Could be difference in playstyle approach but if you normally play scummy, that’s…not a good approach to be read…as town.
I don't play scummy on purpose. And, yes, I know that asking questions is considered scummy. But, for me, it has to be considered NAI. I am a journalist, and that's how I gather information, IRL and in mafia games. I don't know any other ways to get people to talk more about themselves and how they are seeing than to ask them questions, preferably open-ended questions and then to either discuss their answers with them or ask follow-up questions.
I don’t think asking questions is inherently scummy, GG. That’s how to get conversation going. But what I see is someone that stands by the punch at a party and smiles and waves at people that choose to interact with them, then the party is over.
So it’s what you do with the information- you’re a journalist, so I just want to see some breadth of conclusions you’ve come to. I don’t see the discussion of their answers part
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
You are scum reading me because you don't have a reason not to scumread me? But you also don't have much of a reason to scum read me. Logic isn't really my strong suit, but yours seems to be flawed. It sounds like you have a town core of a few people and then everyone else is scum. In other words, you believe that you are surrounded by scum. Everywhere you turn, there's someone who is not in your town core, and that's yet another scum. You need to build a moat filled with pirhana. Or hide. One of the two.
Do you think you deserve to be considered in the “towncore” of this game? Asking honestly
Probably not. I know that my style looks a bit scummy and that it would take a real leap of faith to put me into your town core. And I also know that people find me hard to read, or so they say.
And I will ask the same question again. Knowing that I tend to play somewhat scummy, regardless of alignment, how do you read me?
I mean I don’t know that you tend to play somewhat scummy, because I don’t think I’ve ever played with you.
In this game, the scummy behavior I see is asking questions, seemingly doing nothing with the answers, and spending the rest of the time talking about your self prescribed scumminess as a defense.
So. I read you as not town-favoring. Scum lean. Could be difference in playstyle approach but if you normally play scummy, that’s…not a good approach to be read…as town.
I don't play scummy on purpose. And, yes, I know that asking questions is considered scummy. But, for me, it has to be considered NAI. I am a journalist, and that's how I gather information, IRL and in mafia games. I don't know any other ways to get people to talk more about themselves and how they are seeing than to ask them questions, preferably open-ended questions and then to either discuss their answers with them or ask follow-up questions.
But what do you plan to do with the information you're gathering? Like that seems to me to be what's lacking
I sort through it but a lot of it leads me to dead ends so, then, I get stuck and am still unsure of how to read people. This is the weak link for me. Translating information into reads and action.
That’s fair, I appreciate the candor, I get like that too, especially when I come into thread, have a thought, then read further and that thought has been expounded upon and answered by the individual and I’m just like…cool cool cool I have nothing to say
So again GG, you are my scum lean because of this, but you are by no means a top scum read. You could very well jump my ladder (not that my ladder is something to be climbed lol)
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Fri Jul 16, 2021 12:59 pm
I didn't see an announcement when I looked at guillo's iso so I figured we still could? Unclear to me exactly how it works/worked so I could be mistaken but I thought it was still an option
Takes 8 votes off scotty, I'm pretty sure we bopped that.
I’m gonna publicly ask this because it’s important: @Guillotine since the night phase is open tonight, and the rules state that there is a post limit per day phase,
A) is there a post limit for the night phase
B) if there is, is it separate from the already-accrued day phase post count?
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
