Bird Mafia [TOWN VICTORY]

[Don Wurzeloni]

[VOTE: Don Wurzeloni] aubergine

You never answered my question yesterday about why you are scum reading me. It sounded like your case was that I made some reads when I said I would, which makes no sense.

[Don Wurzeloni]

So here's the deal.

Over the next four chops if we kill Nanook, Wurzel, Wiml, and Kza we will have eliminated enough wolves to have time to sort out whatever else needs to be done, and will have enough red flips to inform us how to do that.

I'll be back well before EoD.

Y'all decide which of those you wanna kill first.

I can see why you are scum reading Nanook, KZA and myself (although remember wheel of fortune) but why WIML?

[Duskfall]

Deciding between falcon or kza rn both are bad but I think kza feels more intentionally bad, falcon feels more misguided

[Duskfall]

Kza it is

[Wiml]

Thinking falcon is prob wolf here. Been mostly pushing for town only.

How the hell do you know who's town?

As fair I have seen, you were on Herm, Ydrasse, Duskfall and me and I believe we're all town here so you've been mostly pushing town.

Oh, cuz I'm not pushing your reads, then I must be scum right?


That's not a towny mindset.


You have no reason to be so certain they're town, and even if they are, what you expect all town to only push your wolf reads?

Okay hopefully Gavial/Ydrasse I don't need to explain because they already had that whole fiasco and claimed PR in a position wolves wouldn't have any reason to claim.

Herm was Gavial's townread and I'm willing to trust him there because Gavial correctly found hollowkatt was non-town. I think I also had particularly seen towniness from Herm.

Duskfall is probably my least solid townread out of the three, but I still have a feeling they're just town here and their posts didn't struck me as wolf.

You shouldn't sheep Gavial's reads at all. I know hollowkatt quite well (he plays or spectates all the games on my home community) and the things Gavial cased him on were honestly all NAI or town-indicative. The case was pure luck and while I'm glad we got an anti-town 3p out of it, it doesn't make the rest of his reads any better.

The best player at reading HK in this player list is by far Tim and Tim thought HK was still actually town.

Tl;dr Don't sheep Gavial's reads just because one of them was randomly semi-correct for the wrong reasons.

[Wiml]

[VOTE: Herm] aubergine

[lost monkey]

Cool my reads have been good, creature, tim I feel are still town and falcon still scum. I think i was asked a bunch of questions last game day, will catch up after work and post more.

[lost monkey]

gavials slot is town as well since i thought he was town.

[Wiml]

Orange/LoMo/KZA are null slots for me and those are the ones I'm going to look at more today.

GTH Dusk is town.

[Wiml]

After thinking some stuff through I'm more confident in my Wurzel townread too.

[Wiml]

Currently my PoE is something like:

Herm
Nanook
KZA

After that I would be looking at sig and long con. There's a pretty large gap in towniness above that point.

[Wiml]

I'm discarding the mostly inactive players from that list.

[Wiml]

I don't think wolf-Dusk says "good chance Glabial is an incorrect towny" then scumreads Glavial on the next (reads) post without explaining it. I think the way they went about that read and how they described it in the next post shows a genuine progression of thought.

[Duskfall]

I don't think wolf-Dusk says "good chance Glabial is an incorrect towny" then scumreads Glavial on the next (reads) post without explaining it. I think the way they went about that read and how they described it in the next post shows a genuine progression of thought.

i never scumread glavial btw

[Duskfall]

did i typo or did you misread both are possible omegalol

[Wiml]

I don't think wolf-Dusk says "good chance Glabial is an incorrect towny" then scumreads Glavial on the next (reads) post without explaining it. I think the way they went about that read and how they described it in the next post shows a genuine progression of thought.

i never scumread glavial btw

That makes way more sense! Lol.

I'll link the post I meant.

[Wiml]

Ok my D1 townies:
Alison
Ender
Hollokat
----
Glavial
Herm

Oh the gap is not scumreads but weaker townreads. I get it now.

I thought you saying "Gavial is probably wrong town" and then you scumreading Gavial in the next post was so random and non-agendary it was surely town indicative.

[Duskfall]

Feel free to keep the townread on me though

[Wiml]

I don't have a strong read on Dusk any more lol.

[Wiml]

Dusk has anything changed for you at all since the last time you posted your reads?

[Duskfall]

I've posted reads since that one you quoted but currently I'm at

Falcon kza should die soonish

I think you've been towny in thread, I think Nanook is like slight town, glavial spot is still town

Im leaving esooa for now since they are getting widespread town reads and other people probably know the slot better than me, though I still dislike esooas play and if they are town then I think they were just being overly edgey for no reason.

Creature long con and Tim are all people ive no interest killing anytime soon currently

Wurzel I'm stuck on they are a hard read for me to make currently even though I feel like I should have a read there I kinda am still null

[Duskfall]

Oh also would not kill herm rn they are slight town

[Wiml]

I've posted reads since that one you quoted but currently I'm at

Falcon kza should die soonish

I think you've been towny in thread, I think Nanook is like slight town, glavial spot is still town

Im leaving esooa for now since they are getting widespread town reads and other people probably know the slot better than me, though I still dislike esooas play and if they are town then I think they were just being overly edgey for no reason.

Creature long con and Tim are all people ive no interest killing anytime soon currently

Wurzel I'm stuck on they are a hard read for me to make currently even though I feel like I should have a read there I kinda am still null

Thanks! Yeah I'm pretty good at reading both of Esooa/Wurzel usually so I can tell you that I think both slots are pretty solidly town right now if that helps.

[Wiml]

Oh also would not kill herm rn they are slight town

Would you explain this one please? Particularly, what made you progress from town lean -> dropping the town lean -> slight town here again?

[Duskfall]

Oh also would not kill herm rn they are slight town

Would you explain this one please? Particularly, what made you progress from town lean -> dropping the town lean -> slight town here again?

Oh i dropped it because they were being underwhelming i guess but then actually forgot i dropped it for them being underwhelming because usually i just let my reads sit until someone does something to warrant it changing unless its like end game. I think early they were tonally town/seemed to be trying to solve when i first pointed it out, which puts them ahead of others in the game for me in terms of towniness but its not strong at all and i can see why others are pushing them, would still like to see more but would not vote them rn because they were kinda towny early whereas others have not been towny at all.

[Wiml]

Oh also would not kill herm rn they are slight town

Would you explain this one please? Particularly, what made you progress from town lean -> dropping the town lean -> slight town here again?

Oh i dropped it because they were being underwhelming i guess but then actually forgot i dropped it for them being underwhelming because usually i just let my reads sit until someone does something to warrant it changing unless its like end game. I think early they were tonally town/seemed to be trying to solve when i first pointed it out, which puts them ahead of others in the game for me in terms of towniness but its not strong at all and i can see why others are pushing them, would still like to see more but would not vote them rn because they were kinda towny early whereas others have not been towny at all.

Ah ok I can understand that, thank you!

[Wiml]

I think Dusk admitting to forgetting a read when given an opportunity to fake read progression is probably towny? Like I know if I were a wolf asked the question I just asked and had forgotten about revoking my read on Herm, I would try to save face / fake read progression to look better instead of just owning up to it? So I think the honesty of that in this case when that honesty is unnecessary is towny.

Maybe that's a weak argument but Dusk didn't answer that the way I would expect a wolf to.

[Wiml]

The thread being much less active worries me that the wolf team is not feeling under much pressure right now. I'd like to hear a lot more from half of the game still.

[lost monkey]

wiml probably town, dont know about dusk.

[Duskfall]

The thread being much less active worries me that the wolf team is not feeling under much pressure right now. I'd like to hear a lot more from half of the game still.

we arent into america time yet

[orangecrush]

wurzel seems like a wolfy town leader

[Wiml]

The thread being much less active worries me that the wolf team is not feeling under much pressure right now. I'd like to hear a lot more from half of the game still.

we arent into america time yet

Fair but activity has completely died down still. I know I had to do a lot of backreading after I went to bed during D1 (although admittedly the highest posters dying might have something to do with that... the second highest poster alive is Herm I think lol).

[Wiml]

wurzel seems like a wolfy town leader

Would you explain what you mean by this please?

[Creature]

wurzel seems like a wolfy town leader

Why?

[falcon45ca]

Deciding between falcon or kza rn both are bad but I think kza feels more intentionally bad, falcon feels more misguided

Do you have any reads besides OMGUS?

[falcon45ca]

Cool my reads have been good, creature, tim I feel are still town and falcon still scum. I think i was asked a bunch of questions last game day, will catch up after work and post more.

Why bother catching up? Your reads don't change. All your reads are spot on so far, eh?



[VOTE: LOMO] aubergine

[orangecrush]

wurzel seems like a wolfy town leader

Would you explain what you mean by this please?

pretty hard to explain other than It looks like he is trying to solve the game but i don't really trust him

[falcon45ca]

LoMo hasn't posted a vote once ITT, did they vote last RD?



For someone so confident in their reads, you'd think they'd want to be on record w/ voting.

[Duskfall]

is falcon just lhf anyone have experience?

[Duskfall]

even if lhf they feel kinda awful in their accusations like very little underlying thought its very base level, dont know if thats how they normally play or its cheap excuses as mafia to put out reads?

[falcon45ca]

even if lhf they feel kinda awful in their accusations like very little underlying thought its very base level, dont know if thats how they normally play or its cheap excuses as mafia to put out reads?

Do you think it's OK for LoMo to drop in and say "All my reads are right", and never put a vote ITT?

[Duskfall]

even if lhf they feel kinda awful in their accusations like very little underlying thought its very base level, dont know if thats how they normally play or its cheap excuses as mafia to put out reads?

Do you think it's OK for LoMo to drop in and say "All my reads are right", and never put a vote ITT?

he said hes at work and gonna play later?

[falcon45ca]

even if lhf they feel kinda awful in their accusations like very little underlying thought its very base level, dont know if thats how they normally play or its cheap excuses as mafia to put out reads?

Do you think it's OK for LoMo to drop in and say "All my reads are right", and never put a vote ITT?

he said hes at work and gonna play later?

His reads haven't changed and he's given little to no reason for any of his reads, go thru his ISO

[falcon45ca]

even if lhf they feel kinda awful in their accusations like very little underlying thought its very base level, dont know if thats how they normally play or its cheap excuses as mafia to put out reads?

It's funny you call me out for having "very little underlying thought", but you're totally w/ LoMo barely playing and giving no reasons for their reads and defending that. Garbage.

[Wiml]

wurzel seems like a wolfy town leader

Would you explain what you mean by this please?

pretty hard to explain other than It looks like he is trying to solve the game but i don't really trust him

Do you mean his tone possibly?

[Duskfall]

I have played with many good players who have reads that they dont share the reasoning for, i am waiting to see how lomo plays later when he has posted more as they have said they will

I consider bad reasoning and lack of giving any reasoning completely different topics, one is a logical failure to me, the other is declining to provide and logic which ive seen good town do too

I dont even think lomo is towny lmao, im just waiting to read them

[KZA]

even if lhf they feel kinda awful in their accusations like very little underlying thought its very base level, dont know if thats how they normally play or its cheap excuses as mafia to put out reads?

It is not unusual for Falcon although he's more scattergunned than I've usually seen, he's voted for like 4 people already on D2 which is causing me concern since it feels like he's trying to look unrestrained rather than really exploring his suspects

[KZA]

I don't think LoMo and Falcon are w/w due to that comment from LoMo about falcon looking the same as last game

[falcon45ca]

I don't think LoMo and Falcon are w/w due to that comment from LoMo about falcon looking the same as last game

Which is ridiculous, I'm playing nothing like the Elder Scrolls game I scummed w/ LoMo.

[Don Wurzeloni]

Currently my PoE is something like:

Herm
Nanook
KZA

After that I would be looking at sig and long con. There's a pretty large gap in towniness above that point.

Who are your top three town reads right now?