Principal Skinner wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 8:53 pm
That isn't the reason Krusty gave. Krusty says Lisa should be dead for making only one post today. I disagree with that, and it's lazier than when Homer came dressed up as John Belushi to the children's Halloween party. *shudders*
Fair.
Principal Skinner wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 8:53 pm
Being suspected before her absence this phase isn't a reason either.
No one is saying it is genius. Wanted to let you know that it's suspicion carrying over the previous phases. Here's the gist of how I felt about her in a few posts. Included Grampa's post which was noice.
Hugh Jass wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2020 2:54 am
Not a big fan of Lisa's little contribution. Feels like she's hunting some easy posts to go off of, and then just share some bland takes. She's kind of using them to appear as if contributing. It's not the lack of reasoning that is off to me, it's more like they seem to be random as hell. There is no train of thoughts or contuinity to them, she's not like quoting different posts about a same discussion trying to give her thoughts about them or add to the discussion. She's more putting her hand into a lot of different discussion to I guess appear more visible, and broaden her reach.
Hugh Jass wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2020 4:48 pmThat's not exactly what I was talking about. I'm not holding against her thoughts consistency stuff in general, it's not really a scum tell for me. My gripe with how she's contributing. It feels like she's mostly picking out post to quote and piggy back off, she's not really adding to discussion in a way that's game solving or advancing the game. Like there isn't really pertinent points or reaching conclusions, and it's a cheap way to milk interaction and visibility.
Hugh Jass wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 3:59 pm
I fail to see how it's got a civilian mindset behind it.
i'm not really thinking it's anything explicitly civvie-motivated rather than just...not wolf motivated.
i struggle to find a wolf faking that type of read and for what reasons. not sure if as a wolf you'd go to that length?
i mean, who would have ever thought about that type of stuff?
maybe you're right but ime I'd say that stuff is kinda hard to fake as a wolf unless it's w/w
I get the angle of thoughts that usually don't pop in the heads of wolves but like here it's pretty tame I feel since the drop off in activity and Grumple's many questions were pretty noticeable imo. It's the kind of stuff that I love to point out as scum because they're at a very superficial level. There is also like a lack of attachment to it and progression from her which usually happen when a townie gets pinged by something that no one has comment and especially when it results in an immediate read. Like an eureka moment that feels genuine lol. Here it comes off more as her wanting to put it lights I guess.
Hugh Jass wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2020 11:07 pm
Grampa's EoD2 looked pretty good. I liked our interactions and he did seems genuine in his thoughts and considering the different cases I had. Would like to hear more from him since his 2 main suspects just flipped civ. He's been trending up.
Trying to ISO Lisa with an unforgiving perspective admittedly does make her look worse than null
okay I had a whole post written out but it was word soup and I would've been guilty of that "so many paragraphs just to say a sentence worth of content" push that was used against you (inaccurately, IMO, but still)
I was going to try and argue against your "hand in every jar" argument, and propose a "she mostly town-read the dominant wagons before dipping" alternative, but when I really got down to it, her commentary about the wagons is about equal to her commentary about chopping slankers, Marge shading, and then D2 Allison shading. She's maintained a Burns scum-lean D1 and D2, voted him D2. I can't tell if she scum-leans Marge or not. I think so? She voted Marge D1 and shaded her D2, so... probably? There's just very little to work with. She doesn't say more than one or two things about any subject. Your "hand in every jar" argument is bang on.
From what I can glean, her POE is Bart, Marge, Burns, Allison, with Burns being her strongest(?) lean
Her town is... CBG? She sided with me on D1 but in a really indirect way, so can't say I'm there, especially since she called me desperate because of a bad sentence in my D2 entrance. Town-read Grumple D1 and switched that D2, but didn't commit to calling him wolf-y. Still, probably not a town-lean. And... that's it.
her only town read was the D2 wagon, and she only revealed that a few hours before the chop
Krusty the Clown wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 9:27 pm
Grumple, what's your read on me? What convinces you that I'm scum over Lisa?
Over the course of the game I've disagreed with the logic behind some of your reads and I've felt like they were opportunistic. I.E. when you went after Hugh for making a long post. Also it's just like a vibes thing.
I'm stopping. I'm going to feel bad when this game gets over and it turns out I've been arguing with a 14 year old about their syntax preferences if I don't.
Krusty the Clown wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 9:27 pm
Grumple, what's your read on me? What convinces you that I'm scum over Lisa?
Over the course of the game I've disagreed with the logic behind some of your reads and I've felt like they were opportunistic. I.E. when you went after Hugh for making a long post. Also it's just like a vibes thing.
I'm not convinced you're more scum than Lisa.
For the record, I have a town lean on Hugh. I just get cranky with a sequel to War and Peace for a post.
JamminJimmyJay wrote:Wilgy's vote is an enigma of science. Philosophers are known to throw their tomes across the auditorium in a fit of frustration after failing to solve its mystery.
insertusernamehere wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2017 11:50 pm
WTF was up with Wilgy's entire deal?
Krusty the Clown wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 9:27 pm
Grumple, what's your read on me? What convinces you that I'm scum over Lisa?
Over the course of the game I've disagreed with the logic behind some of your reads and I've felt like they were opportunistic. I.E. when you went after Hugh for making a long post. Also it's just like a vibes thing.
I'm not convinced you're more scum than Lisa.
For the record, I have a town lean on Hugh. I just get cranky with a sequel to War and Peace for a post.
Krusty the Clown wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 9:27 pm
Grumple, what's your read on me? What convinces you that I'm scum over Lisa?
Over the course of the game I've disagreed with the logic behind some of your reads and I've felt like they were opportunistic. I.E. when you went after Hugh for making a long post. Also it's just like a vibes thing.
I'm not convinced you're more scum than Lisa.
For the record, I have a town lean on Hugh. I just get cranky with a sequel to War and Peace for a post.
Krusty the Clown wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 9:27 pm
Grumple, what's your read on me? What convinces you that I'm scum over Lisa?
Over the course of the game I've disagreed with the logic behind some of your reads and I've felt like they were opportunistic. I.E. when you went after Hugh for making a long post. Also it's just like a vibes thing.
I'm not convinced you're more scum than Lisa.
For the record, I have a town lean on Hugh. I just get cranky with a sequel to War and Peace for a post.
Amen
So many unnecessary words about stuff and things on this internet mafia website host gaming forum for people who want to play a game called mafia on the internet in an online forum for mafia players.
Krusty the Clown wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 9:27 pm
Grumple, what's your read on me? What convinces you that I'm scum over Lisa?
Over the course of the game I've disagreed with the logic behind some of your reads and I've felt like they were opportunistic. I.E. when you went after Hugh for making a long post. Also it's just like a vibes thing.
I'm not convinced you're more scum than Lisa.
For the record, I have a town lean on Hugh. I just get cranky with a sequel to War and Peace for a post.
Krusty the Clown wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2020 9:27 pm
Grumple, what's your read on me? What convinces you that I'm scum over Lisa?
Over the course of the game I've disagreed with the logic behind some of your reads and I've felt like they were opportunistic. I.E. when you went after Hugh for making a long post. Also it's just like a vibes thing.
I'm not convinced you're more scum than Lisa.
For the record, I have a town lean on Hugh. I just get cranky with a sequel to War and Peace for a post.
We interrupt this broadcast of Dial 'M' for Murderousness to bring you startling news.
The dead have risen in Springfield and are running amok! Citizens are urged to board up their windows, keep their loves ones close, and make use of whatever projectile weapons you may find. Those with big brains should be especially cautious.
The zombies have already claimed several victims, including local 2nd grader and honor roll student, Lisa Simpson. Hers was the biggest brain of all, and a zombie spokesperson was quoted as saying they, "couldn't resist."
Lisa Simpson has been abducted by zombies. She was Vanilla Town.
It is Night 3. Players have 22 hours to submit night actions. Day will begin at 9:30 PM Eastern Time.
This just in: the dead continue to terrorize downtown Springfield and, for some reason, the Simpson family in particular. Their latest victim is the Simpson family matriarch, Marge Simpson. Speculation is that the zombies believed there to be an extra large human brain underneath her patented blue beehive hairstyle.
Springfield police could not be reached for contact, and details on both the zombie uprising and the Lincoln Squirrel investigation remain unknown. Whether or not these events are connected, who's to say?
For Channel 6, I'm Kent Brockman. May God have mercy on us all.
Marge Simpson has been abducted by zombies. She was Vanilla Town.
It is Day 4. You have 48 hours to eliminate somebody.
Marge hella pushed Allison EOD and didn't participate in either of the wagons, so I'll look through that ISO and see if Marge's thoughts align with my weak half-assed "idk man" read from yesterday
Grampa Simpson wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2020 10:18 pm
Marge hella pushed Allison EOD and didn't participate in either of the wagons, so I'll look through that ISO and see if Marge's thoughts align with my weak half-assed "idk man" read from yesterday
Bart Simpson wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2020 1:13 am
Who is the lock town?
I assume Skinner
I don't think wolves have a reason to make WIFOM kills at this stage in the game so Krusty probably just town for not killing Skinner.
can't make up my mind on whether or not gramps is scummy for taking aim at me after marge's death or townie for giving enough of a shit to even make a push
Everyone marge said was town has flipped town so I guess I'm just going to trust her read on you. if you outplayed all of us so be it I guess and we don't have enough misexes to get there on you anyway.