Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]

[staypositivefriend]

Kinda wanna read Nook town for thinking those reads are townspew lol

it's so transparently not a townspew but i almost townread how brazenly he's pretending they are

[Hally]

Solid Town
tutuu
mac
tedxtr
sprityo
samusamu
poison

towny, some paranoia
Alison
DrWilgy
dyachei
Dizzy
Hally
Nanook
Tim
Oddmerta

Null
Colin
Long Con

Wafflin
Herm
Radish
spf

Slight scumlean
Jpic
FP-juliets


hm. I ended up putting more people in paranoia tier than I thought I would

@nutella talk about why you had those reads on dya, dizzy, nanook, tim and oddmerta

I don’t remember you talking about any of them prior to this

Sorry just got to this, my catchup was slowed down by a work meeting
I talked about tim and odd a bit in a response to poison last night. Though you had an interesting post about both of them that made me wonder if one or both of them could be wolf.
Think I've talked about nanook a bit as well, he feels towny but I'm always kind of wary of him.
Dya I don't really know how to read well but they had decent tone I thought. Dizzy I've seen slank like this as town before so just awaiting more from him before making a real judgment but leaning town.

you know full well I am town and yet you are hopping on with empty reasons like I'm memeing a lot

nope.

What should I have seen about you that would let me know "full well" that you're town? My mind is not a closed door so talk to me.

I mean you know I'm town because you're a wolf

So I ask you to tell me why you're town and you answer by saying I already know you're town because I'm a wolf, instead of pointing to towny things you may have done. That's not very convincing and I'm not a wolf.

everything I've done has been towny because I'm town

I meme a lot that's just me
I've given lots of reads and takes and interactions

I vibe with this response but you realize how incredibly unhelpful it is yeah

@Hally these should make me pretty clear town imo

First one look at her read on me—it’s a nothing read, it’s “I might as well townread him rn cause he isn’t dying today, but I’m leaving the “idk I’m paranoid” window open for later,” that isn’t how you treat a partner

The second if we were both mafia it means I’d be openly coaxing her into how to get townread, that isn’t what a partner interaction looks like

nook this is non-negotiable for me. i hate to be demanding or difficult here but there’s good reason for it. you, sprit amd jpic must full claim

[tutuu]

One reason to encourage caution here: having been in the front row of popcorn munchers to the last syndicate game with a day 1 wolf kill and no night 1 kill, I know full well that things can be a little shaky.

amdibals in the zoo also had a day 1 wolf kill

That’s why I added the next five words

wait u were literally also in the game lol sry i forgot i airhead

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’m not going to, live with it

[Alison]

[mention]Timsup2nothin[/mention] That didn't sound like a "wake up and reassess me" slap to the face. That sounded like you were trying to get heat off you from the audacity of trying to attack Mac coming into D2. It's what I'd do if I had to wolf in this situation. Do something wild and audacious, get some people to say "...would they really be playing this way as scum", and stay just above the bottom POE, and hold that position day after day until I'm in the endgame. To some extent, that's how I played Space Invaders, which had a really similar start (D1 and D2 mafia kills), so I'm on the lookout for your attack on Mac being an attempt to pull something like that. And you immediately turned around and claimed you were just trying to get us to reasses right after you saw that the response to that play was negative, and I'm not buying it.

[Hally]

I’m not going to, live with it

[VOTE: nanook] aubergine

[Timsup2nothin]

Tim, why did you say your song name to nutella? How could you trust someone who is a top wagon and tell your role name?

Somebody had to. The only way to test her claim was for someone to get in the boat. I was lock POE, so a good candidate for the experiment. Better than someone who is lock town.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I have a role that visits people, I visited broseph, not getting more than that

[Alison]

Kinda wanna read Nook town for thinking those reads are townspew lol

Nah. I agree it's absurd to think those reads are townspew, I disagree it's out of nook's scum range to pull out some random nutella posts and try to gaslight people into thinking they spew him town.

[MacDougall]

Hey Tim.

Let's consider you're town.

Realise, that I am very obviously town.

Realise that I am probably one of two people who could have caught a save, so I might even be a confirm to someone.

I am also reading the game well. I nailed Nutella to the wall and only backed off cuz she fake claimed.

I have given you a seven player POE.

You're apparently a town in that POE. So you actually have info I don't have.

Rather than get butthurt that I am townreading you lamist style why not use the information you have to the town's benefit.

Go forth and find the mafia. I've narrowed the game down to an immense degree for you friend.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’m basically confirmed that isn’t ever how mafia partners interact towards EOD

[staypositivefriend]

I’m basically confirmed that isn’t ever how mafia partners interact towards EOD

okay i take back anything i said about tr'ing him for believing his interactions with nutella are townspew. this is so obviously fake lol

[Timsup2nothin]

@Timsup2nothin That didn't sound like a "wake up and reassess me" slap to the face. That sounded like you were trying to get heat off you from the audacity of trying to attack Mac coming into D2. It's what I'd do if I had to wolf in this situation. Do something wild and audacious, get some people to say "...would they really be playing this way as scum", and stay just above the bottom POE, and hold that position day after day until I'm in the endgame. To some extent, that's how I played Space Invaders, which had a really similar start (D1 and D2 mafia kills), so I'm on the lookout for your attack on Mac being an attempt to pull something like that. And you immediately turned around and claimed you were just trying to get us to reasses right after you saw that the response to that play was negative, and I'm not buying it.

Yeah, don't care.

"That's too audacious, he'd never do that as a wolf" is a defense that's not available to me.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Saying something repeatedly isn’t gaslighting, I’ve never gaslit someone AFAIK as either alignment and I don’t super appreciate the declaration that I would tbh

[tutuu]

i think every single person in hally's list of 3 is mafia

+ tim

+ oddmerta the 3p

GG

[Alison]

[Dayvig this man immediately]
Timsup2nothin
nanook

[Hally]

I have a role that visits people, I visited broseph, not getting more than that

acceptable

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Omg how do you guys think that’s ever a scum interaction between me and nutella

Like we’re both good at playing scum thats so obviously not how mafia interact

[Poison]

Tim, why did you say your song name to nutella? How could you trust someone who is a top wagon and tell your role name?

Somebody had to. The only way to test her claim was for someone to get in the boat. I was lock POE, so a good candidate for the experiment. Better than someone who is lock town.

What are the chances that you are the scum and baited town to follow you and use their roles?

[tutuu]

Saying something repeatedly isn’t gaslighting, I’ve never gaslit someone AFAIK as either alignment and I don’t super appreciate the declaration that I would tbh

she just meant like "deception", "deceive" u nkow. gaslight = manipulate

[Hally]

i will wait to see what sprit and jpic claim

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Tbh if you want to dayvig me so I can meme in spec I won’t argue with you tho

[Alison]

Saying something repeatedly isn’t gaslighting, I’ve never gaslit someone AFAIK as either alignment and I don’t super appreciate the declaration that I would tbh

Don't care what you want to call it. You can replace the word with "convince" or "proof by assertion" or "repeat it until people buckle and believe it". My point is that it's pretty well within your scumrange to pull out an argument that you were spewed town and harp on it until people believe it and clear you out of exhaustion.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I will mock you tho

[MacDougall]

Omg how do you guys think that’s ever a scum interaction between me and nutella

Like we’re both good at playing scum thats so obviously not how mafia interact

You are right that it's not teammate indicative, it's just not to a clearing degree.

But I think you're town anyway.

[MacDougall]

i will wait to see what sprit and jpic claim

If it helps pre-empt you. I townshielded JPIC a bit and townread him and I probably tilted Sprityo into putting a kill on me.

Like if you are doing what I think you are doing, it's Sprityo lol.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Gaslighting is a specific and deeply shitty thing, I prefer you find a different word when you’re actually trying to say something like “say it until people believe it”

[Hally]

when sprit and jpic get here make them full claim and say who they targeted please

[Alison]

Gaslighting is a specific and deeply shitty thing, I prefer you find a different word when you’re actually trying to say something like “say it until people believe it”

Okay. Pretend I said the word "convince".

[MacDougall]

Like Nook probably doctored me (maybe even jailed), JPIC probably put some rand role on me and Sprityo carried a gun to my front door would be my guess.

[MacDougall]

Gaslighting is a specific and deeply shitty thing, I prefer you find a different word when you’re actually trying to say something like “say it until people believe it”

How's about coerce?

[Hally]

Like Nook probably doctored me (maybe even jailed), JPIC probably put some rand role on me and Sprityo carried a gun to my front door would be my guess.

i cannot comment further

[Alison]

"strongarm"

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Gaslighting is a specific and deeply shitty thing, I prefer you find a different word when you’re actually trying to say something like “say it until people believe it”

How's about coerce?

Sure that’s fine, thanks

[Timsup2nothin]

Hey Tim.

Let's consider you're town.

Realise, that I am very obviously town.

Realise that I am probably one of two people who could have caught a save, so I might even be a confirm to someone.

I am also reading the game well. I nailed Nutella to the wall and only backed off cuz she fake claimed.

I have given you a seven player POE.

You're apparently a town in that POE. So you actually have info I don't have.

Rather than get butthurt that I am townreading you lamist style why not use the information you have to the town's benefit.

Go forth and find the mafia. I've narrowed the game down to an immense degree for you friend.

LOL...I'm not butthurt, I just honestly DGAF that you are reading me wrong. If you are town reading me wrong, great, reassess when I'm dead. Win for me. If you aren't, deal with having me call you out a little bit and get on about your business. I'm not going to "win you over" and at this point I'm pretty sure I could deliver a wolfhead on a spike and you'd conf bias it away, so here we are.

I'll give a legacy before you kill me, and hopefully it will be useful. That's all I can promise.

[Poison]

I think I would like to be back later and play the game properly, I am missing quite a few posts to read. Wi be back in some hours.

[Hally]

what i will say though is keep killing in sprit/jpic/nook until you find mafia because they’re very unlikely all town

[tutuu]

Like Nook probably doctored me (maybe even jailed), JPIC probably put some rand role on me and Sprityo carried a gun to my front door would be my guess.

town watcher is the most powerful town role period imo. lol if we have a town watcher hally. disgustingly strong

given that all roles seem complicated / there arent any vanilla simple prs i doubt thhey'r just a watcher but just wanted to say it

[MacDougall]

Also I was hit by a post limiter. I have a cap today.

[Hally]

i’m not allowed to claim anything more specific than what i have already so i can neither confirm or deny anything that’s being said

[juliets]

I am so pumped about this day but starting to fall asleep over the computer. I'll be back in the morning. GG!!

[TonyStarkPrime]

Like Nook probably doctored me (maybe even jailed), JPIC probably put some rand role on me and Sprityo carried a gun to my front door would be my guess.

town watcher is the most powerful town role period imo. lol if we have a town watcher hally. disgustingly strong

given that all roles seem complicated / there arent any vanilla simple prs i doubt thhey'r just a watcher but just wanted to say it

hm

[MacDougall]

The post limiter role that hit me is clearly a mafia power.

The power is that the person can only make 50% of the volume of posts they made on day 1. So I still have a pretty big cap lol.

[Timsup2nothin]

Tim, why did you say your song name to nutella? How could you trust someone who is a top wagon and tell your role name?

Somebody had to. The only way to test her claim was for someone to get in the boat. I was lock POE, so a good candidate for the experiment. Better than someone who is lock town.

What are the chances that you are the scum and baited town to follow you and use their roles?

Well, from here that would be zero. From where you are that is a reasonable concern.

Question though...would you describe the post where I revealed my song title as low key, or as containing a "c'mon guys let's gooooooo!" sort of vibe?

[Alison]

Like Nook probably doctored me (maybe even jailed), JPIC probably put some rand role on me and Sprityo carried a gun to my front door would be my guess.

I find it kinda coincidental that all three people who visited you were in the lowest of the low POE.

I also find it weird that Sloonei would slap down an infodump restriction on a Watcher of all roles.

I think it's something along the lines of Hally submits 3 names and then gets some kind of info about them. Could be role info (maybe that's why they want the role claims, to see if it matches up) or something else. If only one of those roles was one that visits people and that role was a town-sided or clearly positive effect one, then nanook claiming to visit Mac might make Hally think it was an acceptable answer for now until sprityo or JPIC counterclaim it.

This would make more sense to put down infodump restriction on because Sloonei doesn't want half the role cards in the game getting outed in one post from Hally. It would explain why all three individuals were in the bottom POE, because Hally investigated the most suspicious people. And the phrasing "there is a very high chance one of these three is mafia" simply suggests that they saw a role that was very strongly linked with mafia members, like a strongman or ninja.

[MacDougall]

Noting that Nutella also claimed her song, then it was actually not her real song. So even she was afraid of claiming her real songname.

[tutuu]

The post limiter role that hit me is clearly a mafia power.

The power is that the person can only make 50% of the volume of posts they made on day 1. So I still have a pretty big cap lol.

could be a town role that needs to do this to unlock some kinda further power dunno. but then again they wouldnt put u under the bus over someone else

actually if its not mafia role its a town role that, while saccing ur post limit, maybe it gave u a benefit. maybe it doctored u in return for the post cap or something

[MacDougall]

Like Nook probably doctored me (maybe even jailed), JPIC probably put some rand role on me and Sprityo carried a gun to my front door would be my guess.

I find it kinda coincidental that all three people who visited you were in the lowest of the low POE.

I also find it weird that Sloonei would slap down an infodump restriction on a Watcher of all roles.

I think it's something along the lines of Hally submits 3 names and then gets some kind of info about them. Could be role info (maybe that's why they want the role claims, to see if it matches up) or something else. If only one of those roles was one that visits people and that role was a town-sided or clearly positive effect one, then nanook claiming to visit Mac might make Hally think it was an acceptable answer for now until sprityo or JPIC counterclaim it.

This would make more sense to put down infodump restriction on because Sloonei doesn't want half the role cards in the game getting outed in one post from Hally. It would explain why all three individuals were in the bottom POE, because Hally investigated the most suspicious people. And the phrasing "there is a very high chance one of these three is mafia" simply suggests that they saw a role that was very strongly linked with mafia members, like a strongman or ninja.

Your assumptions re: Sloonei's mindset on infodump restrictions are 100% incorrect. Source: my own role.

[MacDougall]

The post limiter role that hit me is clearly a mafia power.

The power is that the person can only make 50% of the volume of posts they made on day 1. So I still have a pretty big cap lol.

could be a town role that needs to do this to unlock some kinda further power dunno. but then again they wouldnt put u under the bus over someone else

actually if its not mafia role its a town role that, while saccing ur post limit, maybe it gave u a benefit. maybe it doctored u in return for the post cap or something

Possible, it's a pretty shitty mafia power cuz I still get 129 posts lol.

[Hally]

Noting that Nutella also claimed her song, then it was actually not her real song. So even she was afraid of claiming her real songname.

i mean her song name literally had wolf in it. i wouldn’t claim that as scum lol

scum probably has fake claims or nut wasnt lying about having a list of all songs in the game so she knew what she could get away with claiming. something like that