Jack Attack Mafia (Day 5)

[Epignosis]

OHHHH. I was like I don’t remember that

Yeah, he's a slave who has to vote what you tell him to. JacktheHost is a real funny bitch.

Also, please check JJJ next chance you get.

[sabie12]

Does anyone have any idea who looks good for the poisoner? My guess is maybe one of the few unclaimed? Although, keeping in mind the mafia probably have fake role claims at the ready...

Long Con - Samurai Jack
TonyStarkPrime - ?
nutella - ?
Spacedaisy - ?
Wisp - Jack Torrance
KitsuShel - Jack Daw
sabie12 - ?
Epignosis - Jack Shepard
JaggedJimmyJay - Jack Ryan

Am I missing anyone?

Jack McCoy Law and order ....DUN DUN

[Epignosis]

Vote on JJJ. For now.

[nutella]

You're missing me. Has been said in thread. Jack Black, prevents target's abilities from being messed with.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Does anyone have any idea who looks good for the poisoner? My guess is maybe one of the few unclaimed? Although, keeping in mind the mafia probably have fake role claims at the ready...

Long Con - Samurai Jack
TonyStarkPrime - ?
nutella - ?
Spacedaisy - ?
Wisp - Jack Torrance
KitsuShel - Jack Daw
sabie12 - ?
Epignosis - Jack Shepard
JaggedJimmyJay - Jack Ryan

Am I missing anyone?

I claimed Fate Jack the Ripper back on day 2

[JaggedJimmyJay]

KitsuShel is my top candidate to be third party. Their role claim has three layers:

Odd night vigilante
Janitor
Miller

Two of three are negative. That’s atypical of the theme of roles so far. There are literal unrevealed kills. There may be evidence in the flavor.

[VOTE: KitsuShel] aubergine

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Otherwise take your pick among un”confirmed” players I guess. I don’t effing know.

[sabie12]

KitsuShel is my top candidate to be third party. Their role claim has three layers:

Odd night vigilante
Janitor
Miller

Two of three are negative. That’s atypical of the theme of roles so far. There are literal unrevealed kills. There may be evidence in the flavor.

[VOTE: KitsuShel] aubergine

I always thought janitor kills were a mafia thing but I guess who knows in this game. Maybe I'll vote there. Tony's conditional miller thing is also iffy. Shrug.

[TonyStarkPrime]

KitsuShel is my top candidate to be third party. Their role claim has three layers:

Odd night vigilante
Janitor
Miller

Two of three are negative. That’s atypical of the theme of roles so far. There are literal unrevealed kills. There may be evidence in the flavor.

[VOTE: KitsuShel] aubergine

I always thought janitor kills were a mafia thing but I guess who knows in this game. Maybe I'll vote there. Tony's conditional miller thing is also iffy. Shrug.

who are you
who
who
who
who

[sabie12]

KitsuShel is my top candidate to be third party. Their role claim has three layers:

Odd night vigilante
Janitor
Miller

Two of three are negative. That’s atypical of the theme of roles so far. There are literal unrevealed kills. There may be evidence in the flavor.

[VOTE: KitsuShel] aubergine

I always thought janitor kills were a mafia thing but I guess who knows in this game. Maybe I'll vote there. Tony's conditional miller thing is also iffy. Shrug.

who are you
who
who
who
who

That's CSI theme song close but wrong show.

[TonyStarkPrime]

if you're not exactly jack mccoy

[sabie12]

if you're not exactly jack mccoy

Jack McCoy is from Law and Order. I've watched a loooot of Law and Order.

[KitsuShel]

Long Con - Samurai Jack
TonyStarkPrime - Fate Jack the Ripper
nutella - Jack Black
Spacedaisy - ?
Wisp - Jack Torrance
KitsuShel - Jack Daw
sabie12 - Jack McCoy
Epignosis - Jack Shephard
JaggedJimmyJay - Jack Ryan

Just a running list for my old lady memory. I’m pretty damn sure name claims are going to get us nothing since the mafia probably have fakes and the write ups don’t tell much. Which I’ve been in 3 of them, doing exactly what I say I’ve done.

But sure, go ahead for the one person who you can literally “see” that they’re who they say they are.

Obviously someone is lying somewhere and it’s not me, so I’m not trusting jack shit right now. Also, I don’t trust results after the cop is outed. What ever reason is there for the mafia to let that person live? Only if they have a bigger target like a doctor or jail keeper.

In any mafia game I’ve played, once a cop or doctor is outed, they’re next on the hit list. But not this game? Weird af.

[KitsuShel]

Like, seriously. What if Wisp is scum and he only shared the cards of his teammates because they told him what the fake info was? Or they just tweaked the roleS? That gets everyone to trust his info and gets scum off the POE early.

Idk. This has me all paranoid to hell right now. I know I’m town. I’m pretty sure JJJ by his diligence since Day 0, whether I agreed with the methods or not.

[KitsuShel]

This game is pretty much jack trolls all of us as much possible.

Quote from Day One. Accurate as fuck...

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Like, seriously. What if Wisp is scum and he only shared the cards of his teammates because they told him what the fake info was? Or they just tweaked the roleS? That gets everyone to trust his info and gets scum off the POE early.

Idk. This has me all paranoid to hell right now. I know I’m town. I’m pretty sure JJJ by his diligence since Day 0, whether I agreed with the methods or not.

There’ve still been zero “mafia” night kills. They’d have to concoct that entire master plan AND abstain kills — nah.

There is no mafia. I am still on Tony out of some last ditch hope that I’m wrong about that. But I see zero mafia in this game.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[VOTE: TonyStarkPrime] aubergine

[sabie12]

Like, seriously. What if Wisp is scum and he only shared the cards of his teammates because they told him what the fake info was? Or they just tweaked the roleS? That gets everyone to trust his info and gets scum off the POE early.

Idk. This has me all paranoid to hell right now. I know I’m town. I’m pretty sure JJJ by his diligence since Day 0, whether I agreed with the methods or not.

That thought also crossed my mind maybe I don't know.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Epi, do you have evidence that the poisoner is 3P?

[TonyStarkPrime]

Mechanically of who’s left it makes the most sense to be Jay, and outside of a strong tone read on Jay probably Long Con is the second most likely. Has Long Con even revealed his power yet?

[Millium]

meh I gave him a chance to claim
He is a doctor, he can protect a person from a single nightkill, every night?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

meh I gave him a chance to claim
He is a doctor, he can protect a person from a single nightkill, every night?

The language is specifically "night kill" and not "poison"?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Mechanically of who’s left it makes the most sense to be Jay, and outside of a strong tone read on Jay probably Long Con is the second most likely. Has Long Con even revealed his power yet?

I'm a civilian.

I dunno where you come up with these conclusions.

[Millium]

his is specifically night kills
while Epi's is specifically during the day, and says he can remove poison

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]Long Con[/mention] who have you protected dude, you may have confirmed civilians.

[Millium]

Well when I asked him before, he was implying he only had one shot? but from the role PM I have, that does not seem to be the case?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

LC protects from Pawn and Epi protects from poisoner

[TonyStarkPrime]

Either LC has protected someone every night or LC has protected 0 people. Weird world to be in.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Gonna be cranky if the poisoner's fake is exactly "protects from poison"

[TonyStarkPrime]

Gonna be cranky if the poisoner's fake is exactly "protects from poison"

would be funny but presumably he's been protecting from poison

[TonyStarkPrime]

Mechanically of who’s left it makes the most sense to be Jay, and outside of a strong tone read on Jay probably Long Con is the second most likely. Has Long Con even revealed his power yet?

I'm a civilian.

I dunno where you come up with these conclusions.

You have the weirdest power claim when everyone else is doing something semi-normal. There is no confirmation of your role having any impact at any stage of the game. Everyone else has had some part of their claim verified. Is this not the case?

[Epignosis]

Epi, do you have evidence that the poisoner is 3P?

I do not.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Mechanically of who’s left it makes the most sense to be Jay, and outside of a strong tone read on Jay probably Long Con is the second most likely. Has Long Con even revealed his power yet?

I'm a civilian.

I dunno where you come up with these conclusions.

You have the weirdest power claim when everyone else is doing something semi-normal. There is no confirmation of your role having any impact at any stage of the game. Everyone else has had some part of their claim verified. Is this not the case?

sabie
spacedaisy
you

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I'm glad I'm not a non-civilian, or this role of mine would have been an even worse fake claim than it is a real role.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Mechanically of who’s left it makes the most sense to be Jay, and outside of a strong tone read on Jay probably Long Con is the second most likely. Has Long Con even revealed his power yet?

I'm a civilian.

I dunno where you come up with these conclusions.

You have the weirdest power claim when everyone else is doing something semi-normal. There is no confirmation of your role having any impact at any stage of the game. Everyone else has had some part of their claim verified. Is this not the case?

sabie
spacedaisy
you

Spacedaisy is true but there's some weird circumstantial evidence that shows otherwise. Sabie is true and why I'm currently voting there. as far as roles go, I have the least confidence in that one. But I trust Sabie more than I trust you. I have a town check on me, at least.

[TonyStarkPrime]

oh I'm currently voting for long con. I have no idea what's going on in this game

[TonyStarkPrime]

Not gonna lie, I was hoping I'd get Jack Nicholson. Didn't, but I wasn't disappointed either.

uh. hmm.

makes it less likely that he got jack nicholson's joker? or made it more likely?

[TonyStarkPrime]

This game is weird enough that I don't really have much of a self defense. I don't think anyone really thinks I'm a wolf, there just maybe needs to be a reset day.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Maybe we're putting too much stock into mechanics here.

[TonyStarkPrime]

i mean I guess I'll point out that I'm literally greenchecked but so are like 6 other people so incuding the person I've voted for

[JaggedJimmyJay]

This game is weird enough that I don't really have much of a self defense. I don't think anyone really thinks I'm a wolf, there just maybe needs to be a reset day.

It's a shit sandwich. If there's a mafia, I think you're the most likely candidate. If not,

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]KitsuShel[/mention] [mention]sabie12[/mention] what are your reads on one another?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]Spacedaisy[/mention] who should be chopped?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I can tell you that it is good for the town that I do not claim my role at this time. If you're town, I hope that you trust me on mechanics enough to understand that --

I trust your mechanical aptitude, but not your alignment.

[sabie12]

@KitsuShel @sabie12 what are your reads on one another?

I mean I always thought janitor kills were a mafia thing or 3p. And kitsu has been admitted to killing players. I don't know if she got results and isn't sharing them? I find it weird a town vig is a miller and janitors kills.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@KitsuShel @sabie12 what are your reads on one another?

I mean I always thought janitor kills were a mafia thing or 3p. And kitsu has been admitted to killing players. I don't know if she got results and isn't sharing them? I find it weird a town vig is a miller and janitors kills.

So to be clear: do you think Kitsu should be chopped?

[sabie12]

@KitsuShel @sabie12 what are your reads on one another?

I mean I always thought janitor kills were a mafia thing or 3p. And kitsu has been admitted to killing players. I don't know if she got results and isn't sharing them? I find it weird a town vig is a miller and janitors kills.

So to be clear: do you think Kitsu should be chopped?

I think if your theory is correct and there's no mafia and we need to get rid of threats to town then yes. I can also see why people are voting tony and that makes sense as a chop too. Him bringing up the soup kill thing and being adamant about knowing who people are ehhh. I'm having a hard time deciding. I think we may be entering monsters are due on maple street territory now but not sure.

Just got a tattoo feeling a little drained. I ordered some food though so hopefully that'll help.

[KitsuShel]

@KitsuShel @sabie12 what are your reads on one another?

I mean I always thought janitor kills were a mafia thing or 3p. And kitsu has been admitted to killing players. I don't know if she got results and isn't sharing them? I find it weird a town vig is a miller and janitors kills.

So to be clear: do you think Kitsu should be chopped?

I mean, sure knock yourself out. This is why I didn’t say anything sooner, and I guess should’ve stayed quiet. But I figure at this point, cooperation is what will help us win.

Both times I had a target, I chose the one the majority of the town wanted gone. If I had been mafia, I definitely wouldn’t have targeted FG or Colin. I’d have gone after JJJ or Wisp.

@KitsuShel @sabie12 what are your reads on one another?

I think it’s one of the weaker claims here tbh. Like, who does that power even help? It feels kind null to me.

[sabie12]

Mechanically of who’s left it makes the most sense to be Jay, and outside of a strong tone read on Jay probably Long Con is the second most likely. Has Long Con even revealed his power yet?

I'm a civilian.

I dunno where you come up with these conclusions.

You have the weirdest power claim when everyone else is doing something semi-normal. There is no confirmation of your role having any impact at any stage of the game. Everyone else has had some part of their claim verified. Is this not the case?

sabie
spacedaisy
you

Problem is there have been no ties so my role hasn't been used.

I think it would be useful to know if LC has used his protects on anyone so far.

[KitsuShel]

I think if your theory is correct and there's no mafia and we need to get rid of threats to town then yes. I can also see why people are voting tony and that makes sense as a chop too. Him bringing up the soup kill thing and being adamant about knowing who people are ehhh. I'm having a hard time deciding. I think we may be entering monsters are due on maple street territory now but not sure.

Just got a tattoo feeling a little drained. I ordered some food though so hopefully that'll help.

There might be something shifty going on with that theory. I re-read my role and while it specifies that I’m town, it doesn’t mention anything about a win condition. I didn’t think about it sooner, but I don’t think I’ve ever played in a game where it didn’t tell me “You win when x,y, or z happen.”

Wtf... maybe it’s a free-for-all and the last Jack standing wins.