dunya wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 1:53 pm
you asking nutella to replace sabie with mac was a total WTF moment for me tbh. felt very slimy.
protocultures wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 1:41 pm
Nothing I have seen is AI.
come on now lol. did you iso her and come to the conclusion NONE of her posts or communication with Rej/Soneji or even her mechanical analysis which you're a fan of can be AI? i cannot believe that you are unable to weigh in on even her mechanical analysis.
protocultures wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 1:41 pm
I cant trust what you say about Mac because you might not be telling me the truth.
and yet you trusted the fact that mac cannot have been involved with killing hally because i said it's probably not a syndicat who did that. so you're believing one thing i said, but refusing to believe the other. this is why i don't believe you and think you're picking and choosing what to believe based on the same criteria but telling me now you can't do that.
protocultures wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 1:41 pm
Psychology is not my strong element in mafia because I am not good at predicting people's behaviour in any given situation. Theres no reason why my weak opinion on it is better than consensus. Id prefer to use the consensus take on it than my own.
this is a game of offering opinions and reading people. every consensus starts with an opinion after all!
plus if you don't offer opinions on people beyond hard mechanics and "logic", how can we read you? also, you come across as a very confident player so your self-description of it being a "weak opinion" feels like you're intentionally downplaying yourself for sympathy and emotion.
protocultures wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 1:41 pm
My entire recent read on Alison is based on inactivity bias.
when do you plan on actually forming a read on an active player in the game?
protocultures wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 1:41 pm
I feel like you read where I was telling Dizzy that the more they scumread me, the more town I will read them, and are trying to apply this on me with a delay.
i don't care if you town read me or not. my goal in this game is to be townread first by epi (personal goal, don't @ me) and then by nutella.
you yourself have stressed that it's only nutella's opinion that matters, so why do you think i've shifted on you? logically, why would maf dunya push a universally town read proto instead of continuing with mac, carot, alison, tsp?
I explain my reasoning for Mac over Sabie. I also said I read Mac as scummier than Sabie. Not intending to be patronising, but did you follow my reasoning as to why I preferred Mac over Sabie?
I havent Isoed Carotenoid in a while correct. They got some town credit from me early on and everything else seemed reasoanble, which is why I townshielded them during some of their cases. I dont remember anything massively AI from them recently. Im sorry?
i didnt trust that Mac didnt kill Hally, Mac is not lock town. I feel like I put this theory out there and people can agree/disagree or confirm Mac's meta. I'm sorry if you think I am cherrypicking facts to believe and not believe. Its not intentional.
Opinion. I had one.
people have been reading me so far though. I assume its on the basis that my posts are pro town wincon and anti alien wincon. Cant say I know why they read me a specific way.
Not intentionally downplaying myself. I introduced myself to the thread as someone who has never played forum mafia before. This is my first. I do not have extensive mafia experience either. I have played maybe 40 or 50 games of video mafia. Thats it. No IRL mafia, or town of salem or whatever other forms of mafia there are. I said please read me as a level 1 player. Pretty sure I said that or something similar. This is all entirely consistent. I feel like you are projecting something onto me which I didnt put out there and saying its inconsistent.
You read me as a confident player. You may be confusing confidence for lack of social inhibition.
Epi is active - I read them town.
Why alien Dunya would shift on me? Throwing scum onto town is to alien wincon. Looking paranoid is towny. Making a case and "re-assessing" looks towny. Making a case and convincing Nutella I am an alien, is to alien wincon. You feel under pressure as an alien. I dont know, there are lots of reasons why. I said it feels weird and asked what triggered it.
i wanted to know the trigger for your paranoia about me to help solve your alignment. You can choose not to tell me because my opinion doesnt matter - which is fine. Seems kind of anti fun though.
On another note, I am unsure how to read the emotion in this post. Its like frustration or paranoia or anger. I dont know. I dont understand why you would be angry.