Persona 5 Mafia [Game End]

[Rej]

I will point out that nutella and JJJ have had nothing to say about me.

Just like the NFL.

Two problems:

1) As of my last post in this thread, you had made one (1) post -- to cast suspicion upon the Miami Dolphins. What exactly is someone supposed to say about you?

2) The number of times each player had mentioned or responded to Epignosis as of my last post:

Creature - 0
Dragomir - 0
Jackofhearts2005 - 0
JaggedJimmyJay - 2 (one in my silly ISO)
Long Con - 0
MacDougall - 1
nutella - 0
Rej - 0
sprityo - 0
TonyStarkPrime - 0

So, that's clearly not a real thought. You're bad.

Funny Jay couldn't find a way to spin my Dolphins comment into a suspicion or vouch?

You're avoiding me. Like Cam Newton avoids questions.

This doesn’t track. Why would JJJ avoid you as scum? Why wouldn’t he as town?

connected with my previous post, you can also see this post of him taking from a perspective where he sees JJJ as town
it fits in the suspicious pattern if you look deeper into it

[Jackofhearts2005]

I don't think this is a particularly logical option I'm probably going to take it back next time I look at the thread.
Could JJJ be teamed with:

Creature? Sure but Creature is town
Drago? No
Epi? Seems actually likely
Jack? No
LongCon? Sure
Mac? that'd be insane but not completely unexpected
Nutella? No
Rej? probably not
Sprityo? Sure but Sprityo is town

The problem here is that JJJ cannot be a teammate of any of my top scum reads.

bad post

It really is.

jack I tried to have fun and all of a sudden two people came out and attacked me your theory is false

Eod is not the time to have fun like this lol.

[TonyStarkPrime]

@Rej what are your current reads?

Also has Long Con posted yet?

no

[Rej]

@Rej what are your current reads?

Also has Long Con posted yet?

I am still skimming through the ISOs of certain people, to see if I find inconsistencies, mistakes, etc, some detail stuff, that can help the current situation.
Sadly LC did not post yet, but I strongly feel that we still move forward in scumhunting.

[MacDougall]

So your answer is "I don't want to say how I feel"?

[TonyStarkPrime]

I don't think this is a particularly logical option I'm probably going to take it back next time I look at the thread.
Could JJJ be teamed with:

Creature? Sure but Creature is town
Drago? No
Epi? Seems actually likely
Jack? No
LongCon? Sure
Mac? that'd be insane but not completely unexpected
Nutella? No
Rej? probably not
Sprityo? Sure but Sprityo is town

The problem here is that JJJ cannot be a teammate of any of my top scum reads.

bad post

It really is.

jack I tried to have fun and all of a sudden two people came out and attacked me your theory is false

Eod is not the time to have fun like this lol.

[TonyStarkPrime]

I will point out that nutella and JJJ have had nothing to say about me.

Just like the NFL.

Two problems:

1) As of my last post in this thread, you had made one (1) post -- to cast suspicion upon the Miami Dolphins. What exactly is someone supposed to say about you?

2) The number of times each player had mentioned or responded to Epignosis as of my last post:

Creature - 0
Dragomir - 0
Jackofhearts2005 - 0
JaggedJimmyJay - 2 (one in my silly ISO)
Long Con - 0
MacDougall - 1
nutella - 0
Rej - 0
sprityo - 0
TonyStarkPrime - 0

So, that's clearly not a real thought. You're bad.

Funny Jay couldn't find a way to spin my Dolphins comment into a suspicion or vouch?

You're avoiding me. Like Cam Newton avoids questions.

This doesn’t track. Why would JJJ avoid you as scum? Why wouldn’t he as town?

connected with my previous post, you can also see this post of him taking from a perspective where he sees JJJ as town
it fits in the suspicious pattern if you look deeper into it

so what I'm hearing is if you look deeper into it as in you avoid the sentence that directly contradicts your theory right before the sentence that's in pink it fits the pattern

[Jackofhearts2005]

Mmmmmmm could mac and I both be right could it be Jay/Tony w/w
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hmmmmmm

I'll take that dare

vote:JJJ

This is the kinda post I would make if I was W/W with Jay.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Mmmmmmm could mac and I both be right could it be Jay/Tony w/w
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hmmmmmm

I'll take that dare

vote:JJJ

This is the kinda post I would make if I was W/W with Jay.

really

[MacDougall]

Mmmmmmm could mac and I both be right could it be Jay/Tony w/w
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hmmmmmm

I'll take that dare

vote:JJJ

This is the kinda post I would make if I was W/W with Jay.

Is it the kind of post you'd make if you were a civ?

[nutella]

@Rej what are your current reads?

Also has Long Con posted yet?

I sent him a facebook message on Friday morning, and he had apparently been active right before I sent it but hasn't been since (and hasn't been here on the site in a week). Maybe he went away for the weekend still having no idea this game is happening

[Jackofhearts2005]

Mmmmmmm could mac and I both be right could it be Jay/Tony w/w
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hmmmmmm

I'll take that dare

vote:JJJ

This is the kinda post I would make if I was W/W with Jay.

really

Really really.

Or else I’d make it to make it look like that.

Idk why I’m hesitating to vote for you. I mean, I do know why. It’s because your reads are so counter consensus I’m trying to figure out how wolf you comes up with them.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Mmmmmmm could mac and I both be right could it be Jay/Tony w/w
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hmmmmmm

I'll take that dare

vote:JJJ

This is the kinda post I would make if I was W/W with Jay.

Is it the kind of post you'd make if you were a civ?

Only if i was really fucked and also suspected Jay.

He’s saying “I’ll prove I’m not scum with Jay” which is a) distancing or b) tmi or c) giving up on hunting as a townie at eod1.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Piss break for children.

JJJ, you have two voters on you. What is your take on them. Neither of them are ignorant so and sos. So what are they?

I think they were nutella and Jack at this point, so:

Jack is wrong. He means well, but he is wrong. I don't think he sounds disingenuous, and I understand what drives him here. Particularly that recent post where he feels that there's something meaningful in the conglomeration of regulars opening the game with suspicion on me -- I believe that he believes that. I'd be surprised to him turn out mafia.

nutella is wrong, though I make that assertion less confidently. I believe that in general, she has acted a bit outside what I'd expect of her mafia-aligned range (in terms of severity of language and some of her stronger expressions of confidence). If she turns out mafia I wouldn't be super surprised. There's room for it if I look hard enough. Her excuse for ignoring my comments about her very recent experience being my mafia teammate was absolute trash (applies to Mac too) even if it's true -- all it takes is a trip to the thread museum to check out my posts in that game.

Long story short I think they're both probably civilians. If one of them isn't, it's nutella.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I’m annoyed at myself for not just voting Tony.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Mmmmmmm could mac and I both be right could it be Jay/Tony w/w
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hmmmmmm

I'll take that dare

vote:JJJ

This is the kinda post I would make if I was W/W with Jay.

Is it the kind of post you'd make if you were a civ?

Only if i was really fucked and also suspected Jay.

He’s saying “I’ll prove I’m not scum with Jay” which is a) distancing or b) tmi or c) giving up on hunting as a townie at eod1.

I wanted to see what nutella would do honestly didnt expect the rest of the fireworks

[MacDougall]

Mmmmmmm could mac and I both be right could it be Jay/Tony w/w
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hmmmmmm

I'll take that dare

vote:JJJ

This is the kinda post I would make if I was W/W with Jay.

Is it the kind of post you'd make if you were a civ?

Only if i was really fucked and also suspected Jay.

He’s saying “I’ll prove I’m not scum with Jay” which is a) distancing or b) tmi or c) giving up on hunting as a townie at eod1.

He didn't leave the vote there. How does that factor into your hypothesis?

Niners.

[Rej]

I will point out that nutella and JJJ have had nothing to say about me.

Just like the NFL.

Two problems:

1) As of my last post in this thread, you had made one (1) post -- to cast suspicion upon the Miami Dolphins. What exactly is someone supposed to say about you?

2) The number of times each player had mentioned or responded to Epignosis as of my last post:

Creature - 0
Dragomir - 0
Jackofhearts2005 - 0
JaggedJimmyJay - 2 (one in my silly ISO)
Long Con - 0
MacDougall - 1
nutella - 0
Rej - 0
sprityo - 0
TonyStarkPrime - 0

So, that's clearly not a real thought. You're bad.

Funny Jay couldn't find a way to spin my Dolphins comment into a suspicion or vouch?

You're avoiding me. Like Cam Newton avoids questions.

This doesn’t track. Why would JJJ avoid you as scum? Why wouldn’t he as town?

connected with my previous post, you can also see this post of him taking from a perspective where he sees JJJ as town
it fits in the suspicious pattern if you look deeper into it

so what I'm hearing is if you look deeper into it as in you avoid the sentence that directly contradicts your theory right before the sentence that's in pink it fits the pattern

because I differencise between the main question and the followup question. The followup questions often hold secrets.

sry for my bad english at this point lmao, dunno if it made gramatical sense

[Jackofhearts2005]

Mmmmmmm could mac and I both be right could it be Jay/Tony w/w
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hmmmmmm

I'll take that dare

vote:JJJ

This is the kinda post I would make if I was W/W with Jay.

Is it the kind of post you'd make if you were a civ?

Only if i was really fucked and also suspected Jay.

He’s saying “I’ll prove I’m not scum with Jay” which is a) distancing or b) tmi or c) giving up on hunting as a townie at eod1.

He didn't leave the vote there. How does that factor into your hypothesis?

Niners.

Then idk. He’s fucking around and it’s not town indicative.

[VOTE: Tonystarkprime] aubergine

[TonyStarkPrime]

I will point out that nutella and JJJ have had nothing to say about me.

Just like the NFL.

Two problems:

1) As of my last post in this thread, you had made one (1) post -- to cast suspicion upon the Miami Dolphins. What exactly is someone supposed to say about you?

2) The number of times each player had mentioned or responded to Epignosis as of my last post:

Creature - 0
Dragomir - 0
Jackofhearts2005 - 0
JaggedJimmyJay - 2 (one in my silly ISO)
Long Con - 0
MacDougall - 1
nutella - 0
Rej - 0
sprityo - 0
TonyStarkPrime - 0

So, that's clearly not a real thought. You're bad.

Funny Jay couldn't find a way to spin my Dolphins comment into a suspicion or vouch?

You're avoiding me. Like Cam Newton avoids questions.

This doesn’t track. Why would JJJ avoid you as scum? Why wouldn’t he as town?

connected with my previous post, you can also see this post of him taking from a perspective where he sees JJJ as town
it fits in the suspicious pattern if you look deeper into it

so what I'm hearing is if you look deeper into it as in you avoid the sentence that directly contradicts your theory right before the sentence that's in pink it fits the pattern

because I differencise between the main question and the followup question. The followup questions often hold secrets.

sry for my bad english at this point lmao, dunno if it made gramatical sense

I understand I guess but I mean it's a two part question where both parts are functionally identical

[MacDougall]

Piss break for children.

JJJ, you have two voters on you. What is your take on them. Neither of them are ignorant so and sos. So what are they?

I think they were nutella and Jack at this point, so:

Jack is wrong. He means well, but he is wrong. I don't think he sounds disingenuous, and I understand what drives him here. Particularly that recent post where he feels that there's something meaningful in the conglomeration of regulars opening the game with suspicion on me -- I believe that he believes that. I'd be surprised to him turn out mafia.

nutella is wrong, though I make that assertion less confidently. I believe that in general, she has acted a bit outside what I'd expect of her mafia-aligned range (in terms of severity of language and some of her stronger expressions of confidence). If she turns out mafia I wouldn't be super surprised. There's room for it if I look hard enough. Her excuse for ignoring my comments about her very recent experience being my mafia teammate was absolute trash (applies to Mac too) even if it's true -- all it takes is a trip to the thread museum to check out my posts in that game.

Long story short I think they're both probably civilians. If one of them isn't, it's nutella.

I agree...

[MacDougall]

I’m annoyed at myself for not just voting Tony.

Weird

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

[Jackofhearts2005]

Mac being certain Epi is town (I’m like 80% sure Mac is town atp) makes me want to preserve Rej onto Tony anyway but the last half hour or so of Tony posts seem real scummy.

[MacDougall]

Nah I changed my mind. TSP's explanations are too sincere. It doesn't vibe.

I also don't like how Jack did all that stuff he just did, at all.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I did something very similar with RDW in the late stages of the scrimmage game. People were wrongly linking me to him, and I made deliberately fishy posts to further promote those theories.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I’m annoyed at myself for not just voting Tony.

Weird

You never had nagging doubts?

[MacDougall]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

You may not have noticed but he voted for Epignosis without announcing it, then moved it to Rej.

It feels like Mafia but it's too obvious I think.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

You may not have noticed but he voted for Epignosis without announcing it, then moved it to Rej.

It feels like Mafia but it's too obvious I think.

I'm currently looking for any good reason why TSP would vote for Rej.

[MacDougall]

I’m annoyed at myself for not just voting Tony.

Weird

You never had nagging doubts?

Just weird thing to post. Like you are belabouring your emotions to us in order to make us aware of how civ you are. I, in fact, hate it.

[MacDougall]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

You may not have noticed but he voted for Epignosis without announcing it, then moved it to Rej.

It feels like Mafia but it's too obvious I think.

I'm currently looking for any good reason why TSP would vote for Rej.

Well I just voted for Rej too. I have my reason but I'm gonna reserve them. I want to see what TSP says.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I’m annoyed at myself for not just voting Tony.

Weird

You never had nagging doubts?

Just weird thing to post. Like you are belabouring your emotions to us in order to make us aware of how civ you are. I, in fact, hate it.

Or I’m just actually annoyed with my uncertainty.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Creature town, Rej slight town, Drago more scum than Jack or Epi, Nutella scummish Mac probably town no reads on anybody else

I figure it’s one of you or Drago (which Jack says is stupid and so maybe I should revisit that) and I didn’t like some of your replies yesterday and there was something else that I didn’t like that I don’t have the energy to go find right now

Tony I need to know what changed in this general space. That you changed your mind is fine, but I can't figure out why.

[MacDougall]

Creature came and checked out the thread before and didn't post a single thing btw.

[MacDougall]

Nutella and TSP are both too quiet.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Everybody already townreads me. Who the fuck cares, Mac?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

You may not have noticed but he voted for Epignosis without announcing it, then moved it to Rej.

It feels like Mafia but it's too obvious I think.

[mention]TonyStarkPrime[/mention] please tell me about the Epignosis vote as well. Hurry up, time is of the essence.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Creature came and checked out the thread before and didn't post a single thing btw.

Is this more or less suspicious than if he came in and posted that the game was boring and then left?

[MacDougall]

Jack why do you protect Creature so much? Every time I've looked at him side eyed you've angrily shouted me down.

[MacDougall]

Everybody already townreads me. Who the fuck cares, Mac?

Sorry I don't understand what you are saying.

[TonyStarkPrime]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

i mean i can tell you that this is not what I wanted to do but i guess the "see gang I voted jjj and then backed off isn't that juicy" part is correct. I can say honestly that I had no motivations other than wanting to see what would happen cause I was bored.

linki @Mac
I explained my rej vote but to reemphasize he's been opportunistic in numerous cases and he's doing the scum thing where he wants town to call him town

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

i mean i can tell you that this is not what I wanted to do but i guess the "see gang I voted jjj and then backed off isn't that juicy" part is correct. I can say honestly that I had no motivations other than wanting to see what would happen cause I was bored.

linki @Mac
I explained my rej vote but to reemphasize he's been opportunistic in numerous cases and he's doing the scum thing where he wants town to call him town

Why are you "bored" as one of the most likely lynches on the table?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Jack why do you protect Creature so much? Every time I've looked at him side eyed you've angrily shouted me down.

Because he’s shirt that says “easy mislynch” and people are treating him like a Jack or a Nutella instead of like a Sig or a Simon.

I don’t even have a strong read on him. I just think pointing out scummy shit that is typical Creature is unhelpful at best.

[MacDougall]

I think TSP is a wolf and Jack is bussing him.

[TonyStarkPrime]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

You may not have noticed but he voted for Epignosis without announcing it, then moved it to Rej.

It feels like Mafia but it's too obvious I think.

@TonyStarkPrime please tell me about the Epignosis vote as well. Hurry up, time is of the essence.

rej vote: I reread him and found issue with the post where he responded to being asked about Drago I will go find it for you if you want
Epi vote: I was gonna vote for Rej and then I was like "nah if I vote for Epi maybe I can get him to join in this fiasco" and then I decided it was enough of a fiasco

[MacDougall]

Jack why do you protect Creature so much? Every time I've looked at him side eyed you've angrily shouted me down.

Because he’s shirt that says “easy mislynch” and people are treating him like a Jack or a Nutella instead of like a Sig or a Simon.

I don’t even have a strong read on him. I just think pointing out scummy shit that is typical Creature is unhelpful at best.

Yeah more like TMI.

[Jackofhearts2005]

My kingdom to be able to edit out typos.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I think TSP is a wolf and Jack is bussing him.

Okay.

[MacDougall]

I am going back to TSP for now. If he flips wolf I am gonna fuck you up Jack.

[TonyStarkPrime]

@JaggedJimmyJay how do you feel about the fact that TSP just voted for you?

Bad. Worse that he promptly moved it. Answering nutella's JJJ/Tony theory in that manner looks like a challenge, and it looks like one intended to make her or others believe the theory to be true. The movement of the vote accentuates that. See gang! I voted JJJ and then backed off! Isn't that juicy??? After you lynch me you can take him out next like you already want to do so bad!

i mean i can tell you that this is not what I wanted to do but i guess the "see gang I voted jjj and then backed off isn't that juicy" part is correct. I can say honestly that I had no motivations other than wanting to see what would happen cause I was bored.

linki @Mac
I explained my rej vote but to reemphasize he's been opportunistic in numerous cases and he's doing the scum thing where he wants town to call him town

Why are you "bored" as one of the most likely lynches on the table?

cause that's not interesting? I don't understand the question. I die, oh well, no fun. also my alternative is writing this paper