Steely Dan Mafia [ENDGAME]

[dunya]

Now hold it right there Dunya, that outcry ain't my fault lol. I was messing around and thinking outloud, my apology to Juliets was because I felt bad she had to deal with all that stuff. Wouldn't a Townie apologize as well in that scenario? Why does it have to be a Mafia apology lol?

a townie would apologize to another townie. why didn't you consider juliets could be mafia like everyone else was?

[dunya]

why does townie nova apologize to juliets and just move on. it felt like mafia guilt.

[novaselinenever]

@dunya
Oh sorry, I thought you asked about Luna. I reread Nova last night along with a couple others, and I’m neutral on him. I’d like to observe a bit longer because I can’t really decide. His explanation for his vote on Mac day seemed acceptable. But today? The only reason I can think of for a vote on someone else is in case a vote switcher is in the game.

Do you have a gripe with someone voting off of guaranteed lynch? I don't think Jack having 11 votes instead of 10 would change much

[novaselinenever]

Now hold it right there Dunya, that outcry ain't my fault lol. I was messing around and thinking outloud, my apology to Juliets was because I felt bad she had to deal with all that stuff. Wouldn't a Townie apologize as well in that scenario? Why does it have to be a Mafia apology lol?

a townie would apologize to another townie. why didn't you consider juliets could be mafia like everyone else was?

I was apologizing to juliets the human being lol.

[dunya]

i've been there, pushing too hard on someone and seeing them emotionally react then going back on it cos i feel i took it to far and don't want to spoil a game for them. it felt guilty to me. and the question felt mischievous. ;p

[novaselinenever]

why does townie nova apologize to juliets and just move on. it felt like mafia guilt.

human guilt

[Long Con]

Phew, Jack was bad... I was making all that up!

[dunya]

the whole mac greeting was fake as hell. juliets didn't know the answer, but you and mac knew it cos ya'll were on the same team.

What's up, Mac?

Oh nothing much Nova just being a civ again how bout you?

Another day, another civ nova

this. this is bad.

[dunya]

also note, nova stays off mac and jack. it may be symbolic when it comes to jack, or it could be something more role related.

[novaselinenever]

[dunya]

yeah you're resembling your community self more and more.

[Matahari]

@dunya
Oh sorry, I thought you asked about Luna. I reread Nova last night along with a couple others, and I’m neutral on him. I’d like to observe a bit longer because I can’t really decide. His explanation for his vote on Mac day seemed acceptable. But today? The only reason I can think of for a vote on someone else is in case a vote switcher is in the game.

Do you have a gripe with someone voting off of guaranteed lynch? I don't think Jack having 11 votes instead of 10 would change much

No, I think it’s wise. Vote switchers were a thing for awhile , I don’t know if they still are. But you put your vote on someone else who had suspicion on them, so I thought it was a good choice.

[novaselinenever]

yeah you're resembling your community self more and more.

[novaselinenever]

Jay, please come help me

[dunya]

Spoiler: show

[dunya]

It's 3am. I should be sleeping.

[juliets]

yeah you're resembling your community self more and more.

yikes! I guess I need to take a look at that. I have back and forth on nova this whole game but landed on "good" when the interactive analysis made he and Jack look not compatible. I am capable of being fooled though.

lol that cat gif is great!

[dunya]

[mention]Matahari[/mention] in gossip girl, you nailed the scum team down plus the third party (daisy). How do you feel about daisy this game?

[dunya]

yeah you're resembling your community self more and more.

yikes! I guess I need to take a look at that. I have back and forth on nova this whole game but landed on "good" when the interactive analysis made he and Jack look not compatible. I am capable of being fooled though.

lol that cat gif is great!

Well the community comparison was a bit of an overstatement for him being a troll in response to my valid concerns ;p still he should be observed and other people who aren't DDL giving him a green pass should weigh in on why he's out of poe even if his interaction with jack makes him look good, his interaction with mac make him look bad.

[novaselinenever]

yeah you're resembling your community self more and more.

yikes! I guess I need to take a look at that. I have back and forth on nova this whole game but landed on "good" when the interactive analysis made he and Jack look not compatible. I am capable of being fooled though.

lol that cat gif is great!

Don't listen to her. You're actually the person that read me the best I believe

[dunya]

(I have to admit I haven't finished checking the analysis you did with him and jack) (I hate those damn things lol )

[novaselinenever]

yeah you're resembling your community self more and more.

yikes! I guess I need to take a look at that. I have back and forth on nova this whole game but landed on "good" when the interactive analysis made he and Jack look not compatible. I am capable of being fooled though.

lol that cat gif is great!

Well the community comparison was a bit of an overstatement for him being a troll in response to my valid concerns ;p

I'm just joking around

[dunya]

yeah you're resembling your community self more and more.

yikes! I guess I need to take a look at that. I have back and forth on nova this whole game but landed on "good" when the interactive analysis made he and Jack look not compatible. I am capable of being fooled though.

lol that cat gif is great!

Don't listen to her. You're actually the person that read me the best I believe

Don't worry. I've been playing mafia for like 9 years and all that time my biggest weakness was never being able to assemble a following. Doesn't matter how good my intuition is, or how much people trust me, my case building skills sucked because I can't focus or articulate my feelings well.

[novaselinenever]

Your concern seems genuine (I wouldn't say valid, 'cause they're wrong after all ), but I honestly can't say anything else. You've talked ad nauseam about the Mac stuff, and the Juliets stuff isn't as deep. All I can say is that I felt bad and it's not Mafia guilt 'cause I'm good

[dunya]

yeah you're resembling your community self more and more.

yikes! I guess I need to take a look at that. I have back and forth on nova this whole game but landed on "good" when the interactive analysis made he and Jack look not compatible. I am capable of being fooled though.

lol that cat gif is great!

Well the community comparison was a bit of an overstatement for him being a troll in response to my valid concerns ;p

I'm just joking around

#metoo

[juliets]

[mention]dunya[/mention], I do understand what you're saying about his interactions with Mac looking bad. I will look back at that particularly.

I also have to say I thought nova was just messing with me in a friendly way when he asked that question that set everyone off. I was shocked there was such a brouhaha over something I interpreted as only half serious. I guess I feel like we bonded over those games we just played and that affected my read of what he was doing. Maybe I'm just naive.

[juliets]

I think I need a game break for the rest of the night. My head hurts.

[Matahari]

@Matahari in gossip girl, you nailed the scum team down plus the third party (daisy). How do you feel about daisy this game?

I thought from her first posts that she was town. But- I’ve been gone from mafia for five years, and Daisy's good. She could fool me now, I’m sure. But I didn’t buy Jacks case on her and Juliet’s, and I can’t find any trace of bad in her posts.

[dunya]

Dunya, I do understand what you're saying about his interactions with Mac looking bad. I will look back at that particularly.

You can check the interactive analysis jay did if thise are up your alley though Jay still town read him after that iirc. Something about him seeming genuine. Whatever

[dunya]

@Matahari in gossip girl, you nailed the scum team down plus the third party (daisy). How do you feel about daisy this game?

I thought from her first posts that she was town. But- I’ve been gone from mafia for five years, and Daisy's good. She could fool me now, I’m sure. But I didn’t buy Jacks case on her and Juliet’s, and I can’t find any trace of bad in her posts.

Well, you were able to suss her out in GG so I wouldn't downplay your intuition.

I think she looks great from the Jack flip.

[novaselinenever]

Dunya, I do understand what you're saying about his interactions with Mac looking bad. I will look back at that particularly.

You can check the interactive analysis jay did if thise are up your alley though Jay still town read him after that iirc. Something about him seeming genuine. Whatever

[dunya]

Spacedaisy had some real emotions in her responses to Jack. Not teammate stuff. But real real frustration and passion. Likewise, elochin's eod1 outburst and anger oozed sincerity and while I try to say it's nai, I just can't see bad eloh drawing that much attention to herself when she knows exactly what the flip was gonna bring. She would have bitched about it in btsc maybe. She's like won the most mafia games on this site. Girl knows how to be mafia. And that just doesn't feel right for me. Coupled with the fact Jack used her for his stolen role cop check, I'm not buying they were bad together.

[dunya]

I'm too nice to play mafia with.

[dunya]

I also feel speedchuck would have hopped on the bus train rather than try to be the one talking with Jack while we all had our pitchforks out ready to spike him.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Spacedaisy had some real emotions in her responses to Jack. Not teammate stuff. But real real frustration and passion. Likewise, elochin's eod1 outburst and anger oozed sincerity and while I try to say it's nai, I just can't see bad eloh drawing that much attention to herself when she knows exactly what the flip was gonna bring. She would have bitched about it in btsc maybe. She's like won the most mafia games on this site. Girl knows how to be mafia. And that just doesn't feel right for me. Coupled with the fact Jack used her for his stolen role cop check, I'm not buying they were bad together.

I also feel speedchuck would have hopped on the bus train rather than try to be the one talking with Jack while we all had our pitchforks out ready to spike him.

There is only one solution.

Let's join the low poster lynch hype train.

[dunya]

You might be sarcastic DDL but I am not opposed to that for the first time in my mafia life

My low posters would include Kites and Lunalee.

Kites
Lunalee
Niju
Neverwhere
ReyWas

I hope kites can engage us more. Just knowing his thoughts helps us figure him out like I've managed to do with Matahari (I think)

[nutella]

Like, even nova's refusal to lynch Mac, while questionable, it's fairly believable for a civ. He came in, saw a suspicious wagon and got paranoid. I do that all the time myself.

questionable? it was fucking awful and exactly what i expect a possible save to look like. he's already defended himself against this and cant really say more to appease me, but i can't shake the nagging feeling away. how carelessly he handled it, like it was nothing after mac was a big suspect felt like teammate tmi (hi, teammate, i gtg later but i'm gonna make sure my distancing doesnt get you lynched before i disappear). i think i just stated my biggest beef with nova.

also, that post "does juliets know the answer to these?" and coming in after creating such a fucking outcry over that to say "lol sorry juliets" was kinda bad looking--mafia apologizing to juliets for creating real frustration kinda bad.

you should be scared. i am taking the wool out of people's eyes.

Isn't that timmer's job

[dunya]

I forgot leetic. Just saw him online lol.

[dunya]

Isn't that timmer's job

I don't get the joke it's late here...

[novaselinenever]

I wouldn't include Reywas in low-posters. He should have a separate category

[Dragon D. Luffy]

You might be sarcastic DDL but I am not opposed to that for the first time in my mafia life

My low posters would include Kites and Lunalee.

Kites
Lunalee
Niju
Neverwhere
ReyWas

I hope kites can engage us more. Just knowing his thoughts helps us figure him out like I've managed to do with Matahari (I think)

I'm with Jay here, the blooper vote was atrocious and it must be punished.

[nutella]

Isn't that timmer's job

I don't get the joke it's late here...

lol, niche joke. in some other game he mentioned that his job involved grinding up bits of human flesh or something and everyone freaked out

[Matahari]

It used to be assumed that a no show player who wasn’t modkilled, was probably a mafioso, and the host was trying to get a replacement. Is this still likely, or not so much?

[dunya]

I've not seen anyone get modkilled here. When I first joined I saw people would guess the first replacement in a game would go to mafia though lol.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

It used to be assumed that a no show player who wasn’t modkilled, was probably a mafioso, and the host was trying to get a replacement. Is this still likely, or not so much?

Pretty sure Epi is looking for a replacement.

Getting one is a different story though.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Modkills are extremely rare though. I've seen people get replaced on Day 10 and no modkills.

[Jackofhearts2005]

rez plz

[dunya]

Isn't that timmer's job

I don't get the joke it's late here...

lol, niche joke. in some other game he mentioned that his job involved grinding up bits of human flesh or something and everyone freaked out

Wtf lmao

[Long Con]

rez plz

miss you boo

[JaggedJimmyJay]

DADDY DON'T LIVE IN THAT NEW YORK CITAY NO MORE