Bonnie Mae - N4

[Kylemii]

maybe not "crazy" but.... bold?

[Kylemii]

OoaLH seems cool and I'm glad she's here

[Golden]

OoaLH seems cool and I'm glad she's here

Agreed.

[Kylemii]

but don't let her know i think that, if people know im friendly and affable then it will be undermine my cold and unfeeling badass persona that ive been building up for years and years

[Kylemii]

is coffee tell a real thing or just a meme

[Golden]

is coffee tell a real thing or just a meme

I think just a meme. When people said it at me I was town.

[Kylemii]

glorfy ur avatar isn't working btw

[Kylemii]

unless you have a broken avatar link on purpose as like a subversive and cool joke prank that i fell for like a chump

[Kylemii]

[mention]Glorfindel[/mention] what i meant by the rumplestiltskin comment is that cus of your truth only thing you kinda remind me of like.... a fey creature cursed to never be able to like, which i think is what rumplestiltskin is?

[Glorfindel]

glorfy ur avatar isn't working btw

Yes, I am aware of that Kyle. I’m just too lazy to do anything about it and suspect I won’t be in this game long enough to make doing so worthwhile. From my recollection (it’s been a while) Owner is very experienced and very good. She seems a little unwilling to engage though and that concerns me a little.

[Glorfindel]

@Glorfindel what i meant by the rumplestiltskin comment is that cus of your truth only thing you kinda remind me of like.... a fey creature cursed to never be able to like, which i think is what rumplestiltskin is?

I accept that as a reasonable analogy my friend and truth be told, probably not entirely innacurate.

[Kylemii]

are murders really only possible to take place within the ships? where does it say that

[Kylemii]

okay im caught up. inh is going to come after me for my throw away vote on speedchuck like he does every time and if he doesn't do that i'll be extremely surprised

[Golden]

are murders really only possible to take place within the ships? where does it say that

It says this:

Night Phases:
Mafia make a team NK
Crew limited to their own ship

It's not abundantly clear so I could be making a false assumption.

[Golden]

okay im caught up. inh is going to come after me for my throw away vote on speedchuck like he does every time and if he doesn't do that i'll be extremely surprised

ninny

[Kylemii]

if kills are limited to shipmates then i want to say i feel relatively safe here?

[Glorfindel]

I agree - Novaseilnever didn’t give me a good vibe either but I have some difficulty seeing someone behaving like that so openly Wolfy. Also highly suspicious of Sig - I’ve been wrong about him before and I may be again.

Also, damn disappointed that Lapluie never turned up

[Glorfindel]

if kills are limited to shipmates then i want to say i feel relatively safe here?

Sorry, I’m not killing any of my shipmates. You’ve nothing to fear from me.

[speedchuck]

glorfy ur avatar isn't working btw

Yes, I am aware of that Kyle. I’m just too lazy to do anything about it and suspect I won’t be in this game long enough to make doing so worthwhile. From my recollection (it’s been a while) Owner is very experienced and very good. She seems a little unwilling to engage though and that concerns me a little.

She's on a new site with 90% new people. It's more difficult, and makes players more hesitant.
Like the Negan thing. She made that case, and it was a nothingburger because DH is who he is.

if kills are limited to shipmates then i want to say i feel relatively safe here?

Ditto yeah.

[speedchuck]

Ugh Mac was a good role.

Lapluie and Soneji need to get their butts on ships.

[speedchuck]

I guess I'm sorta caught up. I read the lynch post anyway.

[Spacedaisy]

There was some confusion for me with the time zones. Night 1 will end at 9 pm EDT, not 8 pm.

Also, if anyone got a screenshot or copied the poll before I stupidly deleted it, let me know. Hosting while driving cross country is not advisable and I was trying to avoid it, but things never seem to go as planned. I am very sorry guys.

[Kylemii]

[mention]KyungDaisy[/mention] can murder only happen within ships or can it happen between them

[Spacedaisy]

Murder is not restricted within ships. That informational point only referred to Night posting.

[speedchuck]

Murder is not restricted within ships. That informational point only referred to Night posting.

Bugger.

[Spacedaisy]

First post has been updated with an ISO list.

[Marmot]

Well bugger.

The missions didn’t tell me what type of stat I’d need. Maybe I should research the board game.

I hope speed, glorf or marmot has some attack skill. The space bazaar sounded like a good place for diplomacy.

To fit my own style, my stat is dependent on a dice roll.

I'll contribute, though I have a 33% chance of actually helping.

[Spacedaisy]

A note for the Captain: Money can only be spent and split in denominations of $50 or $100. So you could give someone $150 or $200, but not $160

[Marmot]

Oh, and I'm River Tam.

[speedchuck]

How much do you help on the 33%?

[speedchuck]

How about Sokoth dude?
I just glanced over his ISO, and I still have a bad vibe about him. His contributive posts have been so far riddled with some good old fence-sitting. He went on about not liking the talks about Glorf, but ended up saying that he's someone we should look after.
Same thing about the Golden/I thing. Liking both posts, and feigning interest with a generic response to what could have been my motivation to not break the tie between Glorf/Golden.

...
Are you down for a CFD on Luna or not?

....
I'm already there. This was an alternative because so far only 3 of us are down for Luna but we need 6 to offset the lynch. (maybe 5 if a voter switch).

Just a note as to where we are with these quotes. The Luna lynch is near impossible at this point in thread.

NO. Don't lynch me. I'm town. I don't like people who try to push last minute lynch shifts. It usually ends in town getting lynched.

Please explain why you think Mac is bad and Golden is good. That'd be more helpful, proactive, and productive instead of not addressing anything I said and just yelling "I'M A TOWNIE!"

Has INH played with Luna? Has he not noticed that Luna has been missing half the day? Are there not MANY other non-proactive players?

DDL, switch your vote to Luna. Follow your heart, your gut, and your soul instead of giving some BS chain-of-command cop-out. You're made of sterner stuff than that, aren't you?

Yeah, this is some cool reasoning.

NO. Don't lynch me. I'm town. I don't like people who try to push last minute lynch shifts. It usually ends in town getting lynched.

Please explain why you think Mac is bad and Golden is good. That'd be more helpful, proactive, and productive instead of not addressing anything I said and just yelling "I'M A TOWNIE!"

Cool, I'll address all of your questions if I have more than 10 minutes to do so.

I realize that you don't have a lot of time to respond, but you also have to realize why I'm not at all convinced by your responses.

@insertnamehere No traction on Luna, and DDL disappeared. SokothQultuq it is!
We'll need only two since TH is already there.

I said it before, I'm only voting for one of two people today: you or Luna.
[VOTE: Novaselinenever] aubergine

No further reasoning required. Sounds principled I guess. False binary a little bit?

Nah I'm not a traitor. She invited me to her crew.
[VOTE: Mac] aubergine

inb4 me using walter white gifs represents my subliminal baddie psychology

I mean, he said it, not me.

Nah I'm not a traitor. She invited me to her crew.
[VOTE: Mac] aubergine

I thought you didn't like Mac's lynch?

My dudes, DDL is a bad.

Well, if nothing else, I now have three major suspects: DDL, Luna, and Nova.

Setting up everything for tomorrow so that he can jump back in and pursue. Also why was he trying to use two of his scumspects to lynch another? You'd think he wouldn't join Nova's wagon if suspicious of him.

If I were mafia, my posts would look a lot nicer. When I'm town, I'm not as careful and end up looking suspicious. I thought you knew that by now. I'm still addressing your earlier post.

So, if you look suspicious, that means you're town, and if you look nice, that means you're mafia?
Nope, not buying this at all.

Yeah, no player ever plays like that what even.

-----

Let's go back and look at INH's initial post.

Captains:

If one member of your squad is mafia, who is it and why?

I guess I'll do what Golden did and tell you why each might be mafia because I can't really honestly pinpoint one as being mafia over any of the rest.

Enri - Hedging his bets when he weighs in on discussions in the thread
Mac - Has been present but hasn't contributed much if anything to the actual hunting of mafia.
Owner - A lot of her suspicions a few pages back were basically defensive responses on behalf of other players, which I found odd.
INH - Haven't seen him much in-thread. Low profile shit.
Soq -Buddy Buddy for the Yucks

If anyone on DH's crew feels personally victimized, you are welcome to jump ship and come join the Bonanza. We get along. At least until our mission is done.

What are your responses to Epi's question, Luna? You cast shade against DH for his honesty, while you've been apprehensive to discuss any of your crewmates.

Perusing your ISO, you have some weird shit in there.

I see no way that Golden isn't town in this game. So why is MacDougall and DrWilgy voting to lynch him? Not a good look for either of them.

This was followed by a vote against Mac that jump-started his wagon, but seems utterly asinine. Just, Golden = definitely town, and therefore Mac must be lynched. Dumb. Yes, I agree that Golden reads civ, but, as I said, I think that due to his strong responses to Nova. From the following post, I assume Luna read maybe five words of that conversation.

Would Golden and Nova state the case against each other in like, ten words or less? I drown when I look at that argument chain.

My current take:
Golden - "Nova's captain votes are weird and probably bad"
Nova - "Nu uh they normal and you are bad for your fake accusation"
Golden - "Man, what an overreaction. Calling it scum"
Nova - "Town Golden wouldn't have a case this bad"

Is that anywhere close?

Thank you for that summary. I don't like reading novels in mafia threads.

So yeah, that's Luna so far. Empty buddying propping up easy lynch-wagons. I voted for Luna to be a captain, because I thought I'd be able to read her pretty well, and that her reactions would be especially revealing. Nearing the end of Day 1, I'm leaning towards her being scum.

The list of people I'd be happy voting for today now consists of Nova and Luna.

Dunno what his opinion on Nova is, other than that it is consistent.

Is INH being real here, or is this him trying to look like he hates the Macdougall lynch? Because IMO Luna is playing to her usual meta, and INH is all like "WHAT IS THIS?" after having voted her as captain because she's "easy to read."
And then the nova vote keeps hanging around as a side option. Distancing?

I'm not adding much to this. What do you guys think of INH, and specifically his last minute push (which contains 50% of his posts)?

[Marmot]

How much do you help on the 33%?

2.0

[speedchuck]

How much do you help on the 33%?

2.0

So including me, we have a 1/3 chance of 2/3, and a 2/3 chance of 1/3.

I feel like that probability works out to be 1/2.

[Golden]

Daisy, will we find out the result of marmots dice role?

Here’s my plan. If we succeed, every crew member gets a share of $200. Of the remaining $200, speed will get $150 for definitelyncontributing and marmot will get $50 for possibly contributing.

[Golden]

Frustrating that killing can happen across ships. I thought this would be a way to keep myself safe.

Regarding inh, I thought the case on Luna was bunk but I can’t read inh to know whether he’s sincere. He never thinks something I understand. One thing I do wonder about is whether his town read of me is a way of not putting me offside, because it’s very unusual, maybe even the first time ever.

[speedchuck]

Egh. Split it even betwixt I and Marmot. He's trying.

[Glorfindel]

Daisy, will we find out the result of marmots dice role?

Here’s my plan. If we succeed, every crew member gets a share of $200. Of the remaining $200, speed will get $150 for definitelyncontributing and marmot will get $50 for possibly contributing.

What is the purpose of this money again? I’m happy for whatever share you’d nominated for me (we have to win it first...) to go to the one of us least likely to be lynched or NKd. To be honest, I think I’m a prime target for a NK as EPI pointed out and the money might as well go to someone that will more likely be able to use it.

[Glorfindel]

I’d also respectfully suggest Cap, that perhaps it might be a good idea to gaine some consensus amongst the crew as to our next stop on this trip? I’ll confess, I wouldn’t have chosen Space Bazaar as our first stop.

[Golden]

Consensus is a good thing. I wasn’t sure if we could discuss our stats before or even who would join, but I assumed the bazaar would use diplomacy which I had, so it was the right call before I had a certain crew I think. Our skills are quite varied so it might not make much odds, but I’m happy for a vote on it. Look at the locations and vote now if you like.

As for money - I’m not going to split based on the possibility of your death, glorf. We can buy items - for all we know, you might buy one that keeps you safe from a nk or something. You get your fair share, and I won’t hear a protest in that or it’ll be the brig

[Spacedaisy]

Daisy, will we find out the result of marmots dice role?

Here’s my plan. If we succeed, every crew member gets a share of $200. Of the remaining $200, speed will get $150 for definitelyncontributing and marmot will get $50 for possibly contributing.

Yes.

[Golden]

OK, well I hope that all of you have agreed to help out!

Since we'll know if Marmots role helped, the last 200 will be split evenly between him and speedchuck if he does, and will be given to speed if he doesn't. This is a meritocracy!

[Glorfindel]

Consensus is a good thing. I wasn’t sure if we could discuss our stats before or even who would join, but I assumed the bazaar would use diplomacy which I had, so it was the right call before I had a certain crew I think. Our skills are quite varied so it might not make much odds, but I’m happy for a vote on it. Look at the locations and vote now if you like.

As for money - I’m not going to split based on the possibility of your death, glorf. We can buy items - for all we know, you might buy one that keeps you safe from a nk or something. You get your fair share, and I won’t hear a protest in that or it’ll be the brig

I’m not completely sold on your logic there, Cap but you ARE our Captain so...

[Glorfindel]

Consensus is a good thing. I wasn’t sure if we could discuss our stats before or even who would join, but I assumed the bazaar would use diplomacy which I had, so it was the right call before I had a certain crew I think. Our skills are quite varied so it might not make much odds, but I’m happy for a vote on it. Look at the locations and vote now if you like.

As for money - I’m not going to split based on the possibility of your death, glorf. We can buy items - for all we know, you might buy one that keeps you safe from a nk or something. You get your fair share, and I won’t hear a protest in that or it’ll be the brig

I’m not completely sold on your logic there, Cap but you ARE our Captain so...

To clarify, I wasn’t referring to the logic you applied to selecting our first visit - which I think is entirely logical

[Golden]

Consensus is a good thing. I wasn’t sure if we could discuss our stats before or even who would join, but I assumed the bazaar would use diplomacy which I had, so it was the right call before I had a certain crew I think. Our skills are quite varied so it might not make much odds, but I’m happy for a vote on it. Look at the locations and vote now if you like.

As for money - I’m not going to split based on the possibility of your death, glorf. We can buy items - for all we know, you might buy one that keeps you safe from a nk or something. You get your fair share, and I won’t hear a protest in that or it’ll be the brig

I’m not completely sold on your logic there, Cap but you ARE our Captain so...

I mean, it could just as easily be me who dies. What's say I took your share for myself because I was afraid of you dying then I died? It's sharing the risk out a bit... they can't kill us all in one go.

[Spacedaisy]

Daisy, will we find out the result of marmots dice role?

Here’s my plan. If we succeed, every crew member gets a share of $200. Of the remaining $200, speed will get $150 for definitelyncontributing and marmot will get $50 for possibly contributing.

Yes.

Actually, I will tell Marmot what he rolled and it’s up to him if he shares it. I didn’t think my first answer through.

[Golden]

Daisy, will we find out the result of marmots dice role?

Here’s my plan. If we succeed, every crew member gets a share of $200. Of the remaining $200, speed will get $150 for definitelyncontributing and marmot will get $50 for possibly contributing.

Yes.

Actually, I will tell Marmot what he rolled and it’s up to him if he shares it. I didn’t think my first answer through.

Well in that case the split is 150/50

That's not all so bad, though, marmot... I'll keep giving you money each time you might have contributed if we win, so it should even out.

[Glorfindel]

How long until dawn and does this chat remain open during the day?

[Spacedaisy]

This thread is now locked, Results and Night Post incoming

[Spacedaisy]

The crew of Bonnie Mae failed to pass the skill check with a total of only 4.

You will all be included on the lynch poll.

See you shortly in the Day thread.

[Spacedaisy]

Night 2 has begun. I will be sending out job options to the Captain shortly. I will update the first post after dinner.

Night 2 will end at 8 PM eastern time on August 13.