_ExLight wrote: ↑Wed Aug 09, 2023 9:41 am
Roxy wrote: ↑Wed Aug 09, 2023 9:34 am
_ExLight wrote: ↑Tue Aug 08, 2023 5:08 pm
I reread the game last night so I'm finally caught up.
Wiml is never mafia here. Michelle is very unlikely to be mafia too.
I do not like the Quin Lynch D2, I do not mind the Epi Lynch D3, but he definitely wasn't a priority. I'm sorry for not being able to catch up by the EoD on D3.
Overall I just HATE Wilgy and Roxy's slots and those should've been the priority since D2 imo
Can the remaining players give me reads on those two without using any meta arguments?
For today I think Wilgy is the priority because I've been pinged by way too many red flags outta them. They hopped off the Lime wagon when it started to gain speed, they're among the ones who originally suggested and were vehemently pushing for the Quin/Epi/Kate PoE along JJJ (which by the way fell off BAD after mid-day 1), and their intonation shifted a lot after the D1 - becoming a lot more "serious".
That being said, I really dislike Roxy slot too. I've seen little to no contributing from them - with a noticeable lack of reads and impressions throughout most of the phases, a lot of filler mafia philosophy talk, and arguments that are quite the hypocrisy (being against meta arguments but being one of the first ones to use them in the reads). But I feel like the last mafia is someone who's been more actively influencing the game, which makes me prioritize Wilgy.
I'm 92% sure scum is one of those two slots.
Hi new player.
I like to try my best to show respect to other players while I am not perfect and do make mistakes I really really dislike someone telling me that - the "HATE", they dislike me, I am not contributing, noticeable lack of, filler talk, not influencing the game.
I am so sorry I am not playing your preferred way.
kk this is just in the first few posts of catch up so yeah, your buzz words killed my mafia playing mood .......................
It is bumming me out but I will try to continue.
oml I don't hate you on a personal level, you seem like an enjoyable person and I'm sure you're a good player
I'm just uncomfortable with the lack I'd personally consider to be AI, in particular the lack of stuff I'd consider towny from your posts
So sorry if my wording was too harsh!!!!!
Roxy wrote: ↑Wed Aug 09, 2023 9:49 am
[quote=_ExLight post_id=<a href="tel:1073246">1073246</a> time=<a href="tel:1691529412">1691529412</a> user_id=1179]
[quote=Wiml post_id=<a href="tel:1073244">1073244</a> time=<a href="tel:1691529021">1691529021</a> user_id=938]
[quote=_ExLight post_id=<a href="tel:1073242">1073242</a> time=<a href="tel:1691528905">1691528905</a> user_id=1179]
I reread the game last night so I'm finally caught up.
Wiml is never mafia here. Michelle is very unlikely to be mafia too.
I do not like the Quin Lynch D2, I do not mind the Epi Lynch D3, but he definitely wasn't a priority. I'm sorry for not being able to catch up by the EoD on D3.
Overall I just HATE Wilgy and Roxy's slots and those should've been the priority since D2 imo
Can the remaining players give me reads on those two without using any meta arguments?
For today I think Wilgy is the priority because I've been pinged by way too many red flags outta them. They hopped off the Lime wagon when it started to gain speed, they're among the ones who originally suggested and were vehemently pushing for the Quin/Epi/Kate PoE along JJJ (which by the way fell off BAD after mid-day 1), and their intonation shifted a lot after the D1 - becoming a lot more "serious".
That being said, I really dislike Roxy slot too. I've seen little to no contributing from them - with a noticeable lack of reads and impressions throughout most of the phases, a lot of filler mafia philosophy talk, and arguments that are quite the hypocrisy (being against meta arguments but being one of the first ones to use them in the reads). But I feel like the last mafia is someone who's been more actively influencing the game, which makes me prioritize Wilgy.
I'm 92% sure scum is one of those two slots.
What were your thoughts on Abi while reading through?
[/quote][/spoiler]
I always have a hard time reading her, so I'm actually glad her slot was solved tbh.
Overall, she seemed mainly towny after some big walls where she shared her thoughts (around late D1 or D2 I think? JJJ was still alive) because I know she's a bit more reluctant to do that as scum. And from a recent game it seems like she's a bit of a defeatist when in a tough spot, so she would've probably not been as cheerful as she was here.
There was only one post (#162) that had really bothered me D1 though, where Lime agreed with Abigail having good vibes as wolf, so one of the first things I wanted to do when the day started was ask her if she had ever played with him before because that seemed like a potential scumslip.
[/quote]
I disagree with your PA reads.
She is not a reluctant mafia lol far from it I have seen her call herself a "Woof God" more than once. She is never reluctant to share her one liner thoughts.
Lately she had been struggling to be cheerful so this game was a wonderful change bc it was nice to see them having fun while playing.
Last game I was a host and she said in the thread there was only 2 people she liked that were playing. Her whole mind frame seems to have changed from that game to this one.
PA and Lime have played together before - yes.
[/quote]
From my experience with her she did go through an overly confident phase that affected both her town and mafia game, but it always felt a bit of "fake til you make it" rather than her being comfortable. In another ZD game she had quite the clash with a player called alana, and since then my impression in the games with her have been a bit more ground leveled.
In the bulbagarden game I linked to Wiml which is very very recent it was pretty clear how she was hesitating, prolly due to being a 3p hostile. To be fair it's not the same as being mafia, but I feel like it's comparable since it also doesn't want to be spotted by Town.
Yea, her back at being more cheerful here is nice. And she played great. If ur reading this I'll try my best to avenge u Neon xoxo.
Mkay, good to know she had played with Lime before. Thanks. Doesnt matter much now that she got shot, though lol.