Being town and in the POE makes you have better reads.Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:47 pmYou’re twisting your own words tho. Of course you can trust iawy because he flipped. You literally said because he was in the poe (implying before being flipped) he had better reads in general.Alison wrote: ↑Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:39 pmIt doesn't matter how good your reads are if I think you are mafia. I only care about the goodness of your reads if I think you are town in the first place.Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Feb 20, 2023 3:42 pm Huh.
This isn’t so much a gotcha as it is a logical fallacy from my POV.
>“Iawy has decent reads in general” is pretty subjective. Who’s to say mine aren’t decent?
> “POE members tend to have better reads because they have a green check on themselves and so have slightly better perspective than everyone else in the thread”
Ok, so. I have a green check on myself.
>”This is enough to put him in the POE”
To put it another way: ‘I like the taste of beef burgers’
‘If someone makes a beef burger, odds are it’ll be good’
‘Someone made a fake beef burger’
‘I’m not even going to bother trying that garbage’
IAWY flipped town so I can trust him. What reasons have you provided me to trust you? Mac and Sloonei see something in your posting which is the only reason I'm keeping you out of the POE, but I haven't seen you do anything pro town other than shoot IAWY... which could easily have been a loud shot you are pretending is a silent one for cred.
I see that someone mentioned you were gifted a shot. Why do you think you out of all people were selected for that gift?
But we’re talking in circles
The problem is that being in the POE in the first place makes me unable to trust you.
But if you are in the POE and then flip town, now I can go back to your old reads (that I didn't trust) and have more faith in them knowing you are trustworthy and have good reads.
This is what happened to IAWY.
His legacy was that you and Kate were mafia.