I made it pretty clear upfront that the list was kneejerk reactions. Yes, Made was easy to have a kneejerk reaction for, and I spent about 1.5 seconds considering his alignment. Don't know what more to tell you there.Timsup2nothin wrote: ↑Wed May 12, 2021 8:01 pmI was actually just asking you how you came up with Made as town. Based on his position in the list it seems like it was one of the "easy ones" and I legit do not see how it could be. This response to being asked about it sort of supports the idea that you just threw him onto the list in a predetermined "looks good here" position rather than actually considering what his alignment might be...so feel free to list me as "downed" because I feel pretty much the same about you.Seanzie wrote: ↑Wed May 12, 2021 7:42 pmI didn't think, I just sorted. My kneejerk reaction is that Made should go in "up".Timsup2nothin wrote: ↑Wed May 12, 2021 7:26 pmSince Syn pinged me just in time to see this...why Made?Seanzie wrote: ↑Wed May 12, 2021 7:05 pm No thought, just sort. The order in tiers is not perfectly sorted, but the people who come before others in the same tier I had an easier time making a kneejerk read on (I copied the whole list, then sorted the ones I had insta-feelz for first, then once I had a smaller list, forced myself to go through each person and sort them).
Up
Scotty
MacDougall
Made
Marmot
lost monkey
Kylemii
KZA
Long Con
DaisyCloud
Syn
falcon45ca
BoKnows
Neither
Jackofhearts2005
Qwags
Nachomamma8
Alison
Timsup2nothin
Gavial
Quin
Stupid Sexy Flanders
Down
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Enrique
TonyStarkPrime
Seanzie
I can, if forced, go along with "well, open claiming mafia is just what Seanzie does, it's NAI" and continue studying you, but Made throwing an "I'm just gonna post music vids, screw it" party is distinctly not in line with his town behavior and is a lot closer to his play in Double Elimination where he came right out the gates looking to eat the day one bus for his team.
I can get as far as this being NAI maybe, because sure, wolfMade maybe doesn't want to just die day one twice in a row and get a reputation as that wolf...but in that case why not just play his town game?
I don't think I normally open claim mafia. I just decide to this game. Nothing is NAI, everything is AI if given enough context.
I feel like you said a lot of words about Made just now, but actually reading it, I get the sneaking feeling you aren't actually trying to communicate with me. Consider yourself officially downed.
In case I am wrong though, can you explain what you're saying? You seem to say that Made is playing just like wolf!Made in a recent game where he wanted to give his town a path to victory by getting bussed, but then you're saying this is NAI? Why? because wolf!Made might not want to play that way? I don't see how this would be reason to think what you're seeing in Made is NAI at all (aside from the fact that nothing is NAI).
You didn't clarify what you were saying about Made. None of it makes sense. If you're town, help me find you by explaining please.
I still can't believe we pulled it out.
