The Syndicate

I'm sure there is at least one. But I also think it's much more of a gamble to guess which one than it is to lynch players for their behavior right now. It's straight up not practical for where we're at in the game. SVS, Matt, and Scotry are all likely to flip scum imo. Choosing a low-poster just ma...

How about this for something completely different: I'm not a townie. :faint: I'm independent. I've been approved to say that. Townies: lynching me does not help you win this game. Baddies: killing me does not help you win this game. Just leave me be and I'll play Mafia in peace. :noble: Y'all shoul...

The logic is that the absolute worst case scenario for the move is a 3 civilian to one mafia trade-off. The absolute worst case is still not a bad move, it's a mediocre one. Then factor in the likelihood of Jo's role being the one that is revealed. It was relatively unlikely that of all the roles a...

I like Enrique's analysis of Spacedaisy. Catching up. Headache. But trying to get through and ponder everything. I think SVS is more than capable of a crazy gambit, but why I don't think she did this in this particular case is that it wouldn't make any sense for her to post about it. It would be far...

I can only say what I would do if I was in this position. For now I'm going to assume there is only one baddie team because it says they kill every night, and most two-mafia setups will rotate the kill. The other variables: I am a baddie with the power to end at least one Day phase early. I may or ...

On why SVS voted the way she voted: German. Who needs a better theme? I've read too much Jewish philosophy this past week, mainly of Germans, to want that as a theme. I'm going with jazz. It makes my brain hurt less. Good point. TH, I was just reading back through your posts. I voted early becasue ...

HOLY SHIT FRONT POST GOLD MINE! SVS's VOTE COULD NOT HAVE BEEN FORCED! "Jo – Jo is very convincing. She can control someone’s vote each odd night. " SVS voted on Day 3. Night 2 Jo could not control it. :omg: :omg: :omg: :omg: :omg: I don't know any way around that. Maybe there us a power ...

I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that if a baddie were making that play, they wouldn't know when the complete list of roles would be revealed. And by that point, maybe the waters would be muddied enough that the damage would have been done. Let's say that there IS a civilian forced on even n...

Oh shit, I just looked back at the old outdated character list and serge is right about Gabe. We need the most votes on him right now and then other needs second most.

I'm getting off for the night. My suspicion of TH has mostly subsided, because though I completely disagree with TH's opinions, after interrogation they feel genuine.

Final thoughts:

SVS needs to go
Matt needs to go
We need to vote Other to hopefully get info on corporate

There could be another role that forces votes on even nights. Or the role is made up a la GoC 2015. I see plenty of ways around it, though I realize I'm starting to sound like I'm in denial. TL;DR making conclusions based off an incomplete list of roles is foolish. Hello scumread #4, nice to meet y...

Serge is bad. I do think JJJ and Quin are both at the same team. Quin feels like he's on the forefront of scumhunting but what I feel he's doing is intentional chaotic brewing of the mechanics and roles stew. That post, #savemepandanderin (as if hashtags weren't bad enough) serves just to confuse p...

Off to work, but I need to vote in the night poll. Gotta love dat Christmas! Peace out, good luck tonight town! @DOM, right now it says "Night 3.1". Does that mean the next night phase will be "Night 3.2" or will it be "Night 4" ? Thanks! Linki - Ummmm k lol See ya lat...

There could be another role that forces votes on even nights. Or the role is made up a la GoC 2015. I see plenty of ways around it, though I realize I'm starting to sound like I'm in denial. TL;DR making conclusions based off an incomplete list of roles is foolish. Hello scumread #4, nice to meet y...

There could be another role that forces votes on even nights. Or the role is made up a la GoC 2015. I see plenty of ways around it, though I realize I'm starting to sound like I'm in denial. TL;DR making conclusions based off an incomplete list of roles is foolish. Hello scumread #4, nice to meet y...

Epignosis wrote:I am of the opinion that 3J was bad.

Who among you was going to mount the charge against him?

Required reading.

I'm going hunting for his teammates.

As a player in that game I don't necessarily see the similarities. How do you suppose he died last night then if you think he is mafia?

There could be another role that forces votes on even nights. Or the role is made up a la GoC 2015. I see plenty of ways around it, though I realize I'm starting to sound like I'm in denial. TL;DR making conclusions based off an incomplete list of roles is foolish. Hello scumread #4, nice to meet y...

Also, we should all vote for OTHER today. The other four roles are likely civs (Gabe could maybe be indy, and there is a VERY slim chance that Ryan could be mafia since he was corporate for a very small period of time).

Yes. For Epignosis.

HOLY SHIT FRONT POST GOLD MINE! SVS's VOTE COULD NOT HAVE BEEN FORCED!

"Jo – Jo is very convincing. She can control someone’s vote each odd night. "

SVS voted on Day 3. Night 2 Jo could not control it.

ALSO,re framing, I am mega mega mega MEGA surprised that no one has tried to imply I was the one to kill Rabbit (or if they did I missed it). I know that when I kill someone when I am bad in order to frame another person, I NEVER bring it up myself. I wait for the civvies to bring it up under those...

How about this for something completely different: I'm not a townie. :faint: I'm independent. I've been approved to say that. Townies: lynching me does not help you win this game. Baddies: killing me does not help you win this game. Just leave me be and I'll play Mafia in peace. :noble: Y'all shoul...

Switched my vote to Quin For the sake of a little Certainty tonight :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :eye: :eye: :eye: :eye: :eye: :eye: :eye: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: RIP Quin There is a vote forcer in this game, a civ. When *I* am vote forced to vote for ...

SVS real quick, I provided them as resources that Pam could check at her choosing. You are basing your defense on providing them, that's the difference.

@ linki - and it seems mafia took out the indep for some reason. Neat.

How about this for something completely different: I'm not a townie. :faint: I'm independent. I've been approved to say that. Townies: lynching me does not help you win this game. Baddies: killing me does not help you win this game. Just leave me be and I'll play Mafia in peace. :noble: Y'all shoul...

Switched my vote to Quin For the sake of a little Certainty tonight :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :eye: :eye: :eye: :eye: :eye: :eye: :eye: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: :suspish: RIP Quin There is a vote forcer in this game, a civ. When *I* am vote forced to vote for ...

I don't have much resembling a case on Epi yet. I'm underwhelmed by what I've seen from him so far. Those questions he asked ^ felt like he was talking down to the town rather than contributing, a minor ping. And no words for his NK'd wife Elo? Maybe he knew she wanted out and was happy to oblige :...

bea wrote:
Epignosis wrote:If S~V~S is bad, and is shown as such, where do you go?

If S~V~S is good, and is shown as such, where do you go?
tbh. Waiting a lot of time not talking about anyone else.

Start the conversation then. Name your top suspicions.

Too bad I'm watching OitNB now. Neener neener. The sooner we lynch you, the more time you'll have to watch :dark: Make a case please, I'd love to hear it. @ SVS - "It is also my experience that when you have no choice but to do a thing, either do it immediately and get it out of the way, or wa...

It looks like we have a decent supply of people, is anybody willing to do GTH right now?

LoRab? Epi? TH? SVS?

How about this for something completely different: I'm not a townie. :faint: I'm independent. I've been approved to say that. Townies: lynching me does not help you win this game. Baddies: killing me does not help you win this game. Just leave me be and I'll play Mafia in peace. :noble: Y'all shoul...

TH, what if though you had a reliable cover that you could use to stop it from being a self-sacrifice? Quin's forced SVS vote the previous night provides said baddie with an easy excuse if they locked it early enough. Additionally, would your scenario remain the same if it took out three civilians? ...

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Maybe we should do some live GTH reads.

I would be down. Might want to wait for more people to be around though, so its not just the two of us providing them again.

I am appalled that anyone thinks I am enough of an idiot to do this. I mean, I can be an idiot, but I am a player whose best use to a bad team is via manipulation & talking in thread, not out of self sacrifice. But whatevs, if you want to lynch me Drum, go for it. You will be dissappointed if y...

A few thoughts/questions on the situation: ~ It would not be idiotic for a baddie to do this. To call attention to oneself is not a significant sacrifice to eliminate a beloved princess role with a significantly shortened day phase (amounting essentially to four straight night phases as DFaraday sa...

A few thoughts/questions on the situation: ~ It would not be idiotic for a baddie to do this. To call attention to oneself is not a significant sacrifice to eliminate a beloved princess role with a significantly shortened day phase (amounting essentially to four straight night phases as DFaraday sa...

Okee DB, look: @ Scotty - Huge assumption jumps that Leetic was mafia, considering his actions made him the biggest roll of a dice alignment out there. You're willing to make assumptions based upon but not upon SVS, who is so clearly behind the Quin death . Also, I'm just saying, if I were mafia an...

I am appalled that anyone thinks I am enough of an idiot to do this. I mean, I can be an idiot, but I am a player whose best use to a bad team is via manipulation & talking in thread, not out of self sacrifice. But whatevs, if you want to lynch me Drum, go for it. You will be dissappointed if y...

It's not at all an idiotic thing for SVS to do though. All you're doing is proving to me why this was a brilliant move for the scum. @ juliets - Yes, but if you are using "You should have noticed that I provided many clear and direct statements for Pam to check" as your defense, you better...

Also, I wanted to point out too that SVS was afraid to break the tie between BWT and Leetic and put out a throwaway vote on Day 2. Being afraid to tie-break is a scumtell imo, because if you tie-break towards a civilian, you instantly become suspect. Not being certain of leetic's alignment muddies t...

Nope. That's not a move SVS makes this early in the game as a baddie. She blew up her whole game if she did. Someone set her up. My only question for SVS is why she voted so early. I haven't read back yet so maybe her answer is already there. Did she really blow her game though? I'm the only one wh...

Drum beats, I have not been afraid to make clear statements for Pam. (1) I have nothing to hide. (2) I don't have btsc with anyone. (3) I am not on any Mafia team. (4) I had nothing to do with ending the day early. I do not know who ended the day. (5) I did not know the day was going to be ended. (...

I just found out that I've actually got at least another 30 minutes before I leave, so I'm going to finish up what I started.

Nope. That's not a move SVS makes this early in the game as a baddie. She blew up her whole game if she did. Someone set her up. My only question for SVS is why she voted so early. I haven't read back yet so maybe her answer is already there. Did she really blow her game though? I'm the only one wh...

I've got to go, I'll do the last post when I get back later. Skimming over it again, I see three seemingly valid and checkable statements in the first paragraph. The rest look uncheckable. Though those three look pretty solid. Also want to note how calm SVS is about the Quin flip. If I were in her s...

SVS's role could might as well be a townie role. Erin's role to stop a lynch is almost the opposite of this role. SVS, do you deny the allegations? I deny them categorically. (1) I am not on any team. (2) I did not knowingly have anything to do with Quins death. (3) Doing what I did would be the st...

S~V~S could have been forced. It'd require a baddie role to exist which parallels Meredith's or comes close. That's a guess, but it's plausible enough to consider. S~V~S seemed to imply that Quin understood her vote on some level, and he didn't react adversely to it. That's something she can talk a...

Drum beats, I have not been afraid to make clear statements for Pam. I have nothing to hide. I don't have btsc with anyone. I am not on any Mafia team. I had nothing to do with ending the day early. First, why do you think the bad team knew Quins role during the night? It's intriguing that all you ...

@ Scotty - Huge assumption jumps that Leetic was mafia, considering his actions made him the biggest roll of a dice alignment out there. You're willing to make assumptions based upon but not upon SVS, who is so clearly behind the Quin death. Also, I'm just saying, if I were mafia and Leetic was as w...

Rip deadies I agree with this: I'll wait to see what svs has to say but she might just be taking one for the team. Voting SVS. I do not recommend that she be lynched, unless of course further information comes to light that would support it. Either way, don't take my vote to mean I even suspect SVS...

Search found 587 matches