The Syndicate

I'm also fine with a Nero vote.

Vote Nerolunar

I've got a bad gut read and his actions surrounding nutella were odd.

I wouldn't mind an LC lynch, but right now I think we need unity and I also think Nero is mafia so I have no problem voting for him. Now I've gotta go to sleep.

I don't like OA's vote why did she go rouge and do that? It seems like a bad move at this time.

How about Zebra? She's been off to me all game and she came out looking worse from her interaction with 3J

I think at least one of those voters are a baddie cylon. However, it isn't enough to vote on.

True, but if her wording was a slip then we could've almost lock cleared Bea, who she was slightly pushing for.

What do you think of Glorfidnel?

*what you said was a scum slip.

Glorf what about the rest of his post about you? Also could I get a few quick reads?

linki: Wine is good, but I have school tomorrow so no thanks. :P
However, upon further consideration I don't think

I see it could be a scum slip, but I'm not sure it is. More importantly what are you drinking and do you have enough to share with the rest of the thread?

Also I'm seriously considering voting for Glorfindel he only answered one portion of Gman's case and he seemed super defensive which I seem to remember is a baddie tell of his. However, I need to think on it since I have been wrong about him before.

Another thing which bothered me is him civ reading me. Civ Glorfindel always thinks I'm mafia or at the very least he is paranoid agaisnt me, he seemed to civ read me way to quickly this game. It could be an attempt to buddy me or just to get credit if I flipped.

Did I just read that right or what?

you hope to see a civ lynched tonight????

Hi Glorf can you answer Gman's case on you?

Epignosis wrote:Lynching Lorab would confirm her claim one way or the other. The alternative is to assume Lorab is bad and pour through nutella's and Lorab's interactions to determine another teammate.

This sounds like a better plan to me, her interaction around Nutella's lynch was odd, and that combined with her being a cylon is troublesome.

I can't seem to ever read Lorab, but she could be mafia this game. I can't quite recall her doing anything very pingy besides voting for LC over nutella. So I could see it, but I'm unsure.
I think it's more likely Nero or Daisy are mafia based around their stances on nutella.

linki: @juliets the second post was me being cheeky which is why I put the emoticon. I was still at that point considering an Epi lynch though now I've changed my mind.

Good points Gman, I'd need to think about it Glorfindel isn't being his usual very civvie self, but doesn't seem to be very scummy either. Though he has been more lurkery this game.

linki 2: @Epi we can't lynch her today due to the Presidents law. However, her claiming is odd though she says she isn't a member of the mafia team so idk.

Ricochet wrote: sig
- liked JJJ's case on LC, but then made no final commitment to lynch Long Con
- found zero validity in lynching nutella
- votes Epignosis, based on Long Con connection (and on obstinately wanting Epignosis lynched)
- lobbies hard for Epignosis to develop into a lynch wagon
~ is pinged by Daisy's stance on nutella and on the last players to vote nutella
~ keeps on drumming on Epignosis being lynched

I find evidence to be not favorable to sig, but I can't put a final finger on what would profile him as a certain teammate. He had all the right preparation to wagon on Long Con. Did he get scared of being too obvious of a counter-wagoner (if indeed nutella's teammate)? His Epignosis vote only makes sense if you count his obstinancy in Epig needing to be lynched. I'm not sure how to interpret him berating Daisy for defending nutella. It could be a cover-up, it could be a genuine ping, but it is also contradictory to him not finding nutella lynchworthy himself.
.

So the issue I had with Daisy is that I didn't like the way she did it. It was very on the fence type of defense. Unlike what I did, I flat out said I'd rather she didn't get lynched since I didn't see the case.

I like I think it was 3J case on Nero and his reactions around nutella was odd, I could place my vote there.

What is the case on Lorab?

juliets wrote:ok, I will go back to deciding who I'm going to vote for. I'm not at all happy with sig's attitude towards epi and he hasn't answered the question I put out there this afternoon and I have a bad gut feeling so he may be my vote today. He also didn't see anything bad in nutella. I want to see what G-Man has to say about Glorfindel but I can't say I have noticed anything I would consider bad. I could have easily missed something though. For those who think sig is town what are you seeing?

linki

What questions? All I remember you asking was if I was really busy which I answered?

Also I don't see what at that time was wrong with my epi view. I've since evolved after doing some independent lore reading and a skim of his posts, but I don't see what was wrong with me suspecting him.

Scotty wrote:Doing a drive by vote for sig.

Will not have too much time to respond today, and this poll is looking rather empty. I suspected him last night and still do. So there ya go.

Vompatti wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Vompatti wrote:If LC was a confirmed civ, what would he benefit from "accidentally" implying he's a cylon?
*rubs eyes* WTF? Is this... actually a relevant question from Vompatti??

V, say it ain't so, are you getting into this? Talking about me is an excellent way to start. I'm interesting... the best thing since wrestling!
I'm just wondering k

Especially since Zebra said he would vote for you today, which to me doesn't make any sense no matter what way you look at it.

Zebra is a she

However, why doesn't it make sense the only one who is civ clearing LC is LC.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I will call you Sigbad like the fellow Sinbad from the old sailor tales.

But, I'm not bad.

@SVS could he have not cared since his resurrection ship was still in play? So I'm thinking if we have one per row maybe each cylon has their own ship and only the bad cylons have them, which would be six bad cylons and one good one. Thoughts?

linki: I mentioned it in the sign up thread.

Did anyone get anything from that back and forth between Zebra and JJJ? Since it seemed like 3J was pinged by Zebra saying LC was almost confirmed town, and then they got in an argument about a question?

Furthermore why is LC close to confirmed at all? People are saying he was the counterwagon to Nutella, however how do we know they weren't teammates? I just find it very odd LC wouldn't vote to save himself unless they were on the same team, or if he knew the resurrection ship would bring him back.

Also I'm done the second draft of my paper if all goes well it will be the last draft and my activity should hopefully pick up this week.

Glorfindel wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Glorfindel wrote:I notice reading back, that there were some exchanges between the two of you - do you doubt my opinion of him? Despite those exchanges, I don't consider either of to be Mafia.
I don't really doubt your opinion, no. At least not its sincerity. I am a little suspicious of sig for his interactions with nutella.
So Say We All!
May I call you Jimmy? 3J seems a little impersonal... Looking at his interactions with Nutella kinda proves my point. Take this post:
sig wrote:Okay so I'm considering three people for today.

LC...
Zebra...
Epi, He is an outed Cylon and with the ship gone I'd like to see if we can lynch him and how he will flip. If he flips mafia then we know most cylons are bad. I also think he could've been the one to kill Ika, seeing how Ika was pushing to lynch Epi again. So I'm leaning towards mafia on Epi.

So here is a thought, in past games civs or mafia members could create events, usually polls but I've seen events before. Could there be no resurrection ship and this is all a ploy created by the cylons?
Maybe Epi just had a lynch proof power or something?

I don't see the reasons for a nutella lynch or for Rico.
We already know Epi is a Cylon and his identity, what more information is he expecting to gain from lynching him As for his assertion that the whole resurrection ship thing was a ploy created by the Cylons To me, this is indicative of someone struggling to keep up as a consequence of external factors, not Mafia alignment.

Yes, but we didn't know what alignment Epi was. At that time since nobody else was lynched I thought we'd see who was bad. For the record I'm still not agaisnt an Epi lynch. Also it could've been a ploy created by the cylons to distract us like a troll event. :P
But, that is neither here nor there anymore.

Long Con wrote:As the resident Confirmed Civ, I still think sig is bad. Rico, sig, JJJ... all bad.

I'm not bad you're bad.

but, in all seriousness I did some independent lore research and looked everything over and I'm willing to consider some cylons don't need to be lycnhed. However, nutella made this post.

nutella wrote:sig, people familiar with the show have insisted that Athena is a good character, are you ignoring that info? like I get that maybe we shouldn't assume that it's reflected in the roles in this game, but it would make some sense. are you not willing to entertain that possibility?

lorab I am so jealous!!!!!

So does that mean she was trying to cover for Athena and they're teammates. What does everyone think of this?

Okay so we had a long night phase, but we didn't see much.

RIP indi I hope to play with you again.

Also yay we got another ship and neither of our pilots died.

I think we should lynch them. :P

starting with Epi a cylon who is outed.

I don't think the humans need to kill all the cylons

Yayyyyyyy, take that toasters.

Scotty wrote:
sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

Yo, sig. I'm voting for you tomorrow most likely. I don't like your place in what happened, nor your stances against Epi this game. I think you are bad.

What do you mean by my place? Also what about my stance on Epi why don't you like it.

Nero we're still in the night phase. It's lasting 48 hours this time. :P

Was I the only one laughing when I read the Silver/Matt thing. Like lol you two are great.

Matt remember when you thought Glorfindel was two face for saying twice and things like that? I think that's the same sort of thing going on right now. However, I'm now reading both of you as solid civs so kudos.

I'd like to see some more posts and reads from the lower posters. Nero, Glorfindel, DF, ect

So Matt you're saying she was mafia faking her anger. Or the anger was real, but she's having fun since she is mafia fooling the town.

Epignosis wrote:
sig wrote:Epi is acting the same way he acted when he was suspected in Turf War. He blew people's suspicion off and acted more abrasive and discounted/ignored those who suspected him, he is acting almost the same way to me this game as in Turf Wars when I thought he was mafia.
I just...don't...know how to be different...when I'm bad! Someone please help me!

Thanks just keep proving my point.

Epi is acting the same way he acted when he was suspected in Turf War. He blew people's suspicion off and acted more abrasive and discounted/ignored those who suspected him, he is acting almost the same way to me this game as in Turf Wars when I thought he was mafia.

@Matt Okay I'll do that.

@OA Matt is always like that regardless of alignment, re the scum RYM thing. However, I do see your point I'll need to consider it.

Matt wrote:3J has also shown little to zero interest in helping with the Rezz ships, unless he was lecturing Long Con for participating.

indi - I really don't know about SW, I had a clear "townie" feeling on her until I read those words of hers...I'm really liking this game. From my pov, that has not been the case at all.

I'm townreading her at the moment.
What do you think of Epi not wanting to help find or caring about the resurrection ships?

Epi is green
Nutella was red.

Maybe we destroyed the red resurrection ship and not the green one?

Silverwolf wrote:
Golden wrote:Why are people saying so say we all?
Cuz I screwed it up once and saw someone else do it.

lol Same tbh.

So say we all.

I'm thinking maybe every cylon has a certain ship tied to them? So like one ships = three cylons.

Also I'll point out Epi didn't seem to vote, but was planning to vote for LC.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Immediate notes: nutella was a cylon and she stayed dead. No further alignment indicated.

Yes since we blew up one of their ships.

I'm thinking Daisy is a good candidate tomorrow so is epi.

Long Con wrote:
sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

That nutella portion of your post was very fencey Daisy.

nutella wrote:sig, people familiar with the show have insisted that Athena is a good character, are you ignoring that info? like I get that maybe we shouldn't assume that it's reflected in the roles in this game, but it would make some sense. are you not willing to entertain that possibility?

lorab I am so jealous!!!!!

Ugh fine, obviously I'm the super minority here. I'll ISO Epi over the night phase and see what I think and I'll take into consideration what they've said. However, I still don't believe we should put to much weight in the show. Take the Final five for example whatever they are they've been randomized and aren't the same people as they were in the show. I think getting to deep into the shows lore isn't good, especially with some of the text in game. You'll be seen as a cylon sympathizer if you don't say this ect.

Which didn't make much sense, but I figured I'd role with it. :P

Oh I thought you were saying it was to pro town.

Polo wrote:
sig wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:#ibelieveinsig

EPI

Wilgy must be civ.
Maybe you're both mafiosi.

And we both voted together for an outed teammate hmmm maybe.

Can you explain your vote?

I think the case from day 1 has merit, but I'll work on building one over the next phase. Also you're assuming it is 20 vs. 8 vs.1 there could be other third party humans and there's the final five in play.

DrWilgy wrote:#ibelieveinsig

EPI

Wilgy must be civ.

Matt wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
Matt wrote:Epi and Black Rock, follow Marmot!
What's with the Marmot trust?
Well, two reasons...

1) He joke voted Epi on Day One and got us a Cylon. A good cylon, but still.

2) Curiously, he is listed as "Marmot" on the poll, and I know Golden already "explained" it, but I can't help feel that it makes Marmot special somehow.

Why are you assuming Epi is a good cylon? You've got no proof what so ever of this.

@Juliets we have no evidence pointing to this being true, and Golden said it wasn't necessary to have knowledge about the show. I think in the sign ups when looking at the roles it makes it kind off clear the cylons are the mafia. I believe they're the ones with the nightkill and they're the ones who we are activity hunting. I mean every six hours we are sending two civs out to try and blow up their ships. I don't see how everyone here is taking for granted that Epi must be a civ.

This was done in Turf Wars to and he turned out to be mafia.

I think he's mafia and has you all fooled into believing he is a "good" cylon.

S~V~S wrote:
Matt wrote:Epi and Black Rock, follow Marmot!
No,vote Nutella

Nah Epi is the way to go.

Epignosis wrote:
sig wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I've made a deal with Long Con, and unless he accepts, my vote goes to him. I'm sorry.
Why do you think he's good?
He's being stubborn, not manipulative.
I agree. This is not a baddie LC I see here.
Fine then maybe LC isn't bad, just misguided about me.

I still believe Epi is bad and should be lynched.
I mean this is like if we had a game where the cop claimed a red check and yet we didn't lynch the player who was red checked, since they might not be bad. The cylons look like the mafia it makes sense for them to be the mafia, we have a cylon who wasn't lynched since their resurrection ship was floating around and came back. Yet we aren't lynching him today why? This baffles me.
You should go stand in the corner of you Cylon ship and think about what you just said.

hmm MAKE ME.

Black Rock wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I've made a deal with Long Con, and unless he accepts, my vote goes to him. I'm sorry.
Why do you think he's good?
He's being stubborn, not manipulative.
I agree. This is not a baddie LC I see here.

Fine then maybe LC isn't bad, just misguided about me.

I still believe Epi is bad and should be lynched.
I mean this is like if we had a game where the cop claimed a red check and yet we didn't lynch the player who was red checked, since they might not be bad. The cylons look like the mafia it makes sense for them to be the mafia, we have a cylon who wasn't lynched since their resurrection ship was floating around and came back. Yet we aren't lynching him today why? This baffles me.

Epignosis wrote:
sig wrote:...You think LC is stubborn/hijacking town? That is a very strange reason to vote for LC. I don't like it.

@Epi if you're both cylons and he can be resurrected then why wouldn't you distance vote.
Because that would be obvious and stupid?

So it makes sense why you and LC would come up with it then?

:P

Search found 287 matches