Dropping my technicolors again at the top here for reference purposes. Below them are write-ups of what came to my mind when I read through the votes of living players looking for potential badness.
DAY 1
1. INSERTNAMHERE (Golden)<---NK'd N3 by Mafia and SK
2. TIMMER (Vompatti)<----NK'd N1 by ???
3. EPIGNOSIS (Triceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
4. INSERTNAMEHERE (JaggedJimmyJay)
5. INSERTNAMEHERE (MovingPictures07/G-Man)
6. TIMMER (Metalmarsh89)
7. INSERTNAMEHERE (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
8. EPIGNOSIS (DrWilgy)<----Lynched D2- CIVVIE
9. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Epignosis)
10. EPIGNOSIS (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
11. METALMARSH89 (Boomslang)<----NK'd N4 by SK
12. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Nijuukyugou)<----NK'd N4 by Mafia
13. INSERTNAMEHERE (Sloonei/Quin)
14. INSERTNAMEHERE (Sig)
Not Voting: A Person, Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0, Dom, Insertnamehere, LoRab
----------------------------
1. INSERTNAMHERE (Golden)<---NK'd N3 by Mafia and SK
4. INSERTNAMEHERE (JaggedJimmyJay)
5. INSERTNAMEHERE (MovingPictures07/G-Man)
7. INSERTNAMEHERE (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
13. INSERTNAMEHERE (Sloonei/Quin)
14. INSERTNAMEHERE (Sig)
3. EPIGNOSIS (Triceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
8. EPIGNOSIS (DrWilgy)<----Lynched D2- CIVVIE
10. EPIGNOSIS (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
2. TIMMER (Vompatti)<----NK'd N1 by ???
6. TIMMER (Metalmarsh89)
9. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Epignosis)
11. METALMARSH89 (Boomslang)<----NK'd N4 by SK
12. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Nijuukyugou)<----NK'd N4 by Mafia
Not Voting:
A Person<----Lynched D3- CIVVIE
Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0
Dom
Insertnamehere<----Lynched D1- CIVVIE
LoRab
DAY 2
1. LORAB (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
2. A PERSON (LoRab)
3. TIMMER (Boomslang)<----NK'd N4 by SK
4. A PERSON (DrWilgy)<----Lynched D2- CIVVIE
5. BOOMSLANG (Metalmarsh89)
6. SCOTTY (Nijuukyugou)<----NK'd N4 by Mafia
7. DRWILGY (JaggedJimmyJay)
8. BOOMSLANG (Triceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
9. BOOMSLANG (Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0)
10. DRWILGY (Golden)<---NK'd N3 by Mafia and SK
11. DRWILGY (Epignosis)
12. DRWILGY (Dom)
13. DRWILGY (MovingPictures07/G-Man)
14. BOOMSLANG (Sig)
Not Voting: A Person (2), Sloonei/Quin, Timmer
----------------------------------
7. DRWILGY (JaggedJimmyJay)
10. DRWILGY (Golden)<---NK'd N3 by Mafia and SK
11. DRWILGY (Epignosis)
12. DRWILGY (Dom)
13. DRWILGY (MovingPictures07/G-Man)
5. BOOMSLANG (Metalmarsh89)
8. BOOMSLANG (Triceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
9. BOOMSLANG (Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0)
14. BOOMSLANG (Sig)
2. A PERSON (LoRab)
4. A PERSON (DrWilgy)<----Lynched D2- CIVVIE
1. LORAB (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
3. TIMMER (Boomslang)<----NK'd N4 by SK
6. SCOTTY (Nijuukyugou)<----NK'd N4 by Mafia
Not Voting:
A Person (2)<----Lynched D3- CIVVIE
Sloonei/Quin
Timmer<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
DAY 3
1. LORAB (Sloonei/Quin)
2. A PERSON (Triceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
3. A PERSON (LoRab)
4. A PERSON (Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0)
5. METALMARSH89 (Golden)<---NK'd N3 by Mafia and SK
6. METALMARSH89 (MovingPictures07/G-Man)
7. A PERSON (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
8. DOM (Sig)
9. METALMARSH89 (Nijuukyugou)<----NK'd N4 by Mafia
10. METALMARSH89 (Boomslang)<----NK'd N4 by SK
11. A PERSON (JaggedJimmyJay)
12. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (Dom)
13. A PERSON (Metalmarsh89)
Not Voting: A Person (3), Epignosis, Scotty
-------------------------------
2. A PERSON (Triceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
3. A PERSON (LoRab)
4. A PERSON (Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0)
7. A PERSON (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
11. A PERSON (JaggedJimmyJay)
13. A PERSON (Metalmarsh89)
5. METALMARSH89 (Golden)<---NK'd N3 by Mafia and SK
6. METALMARSH89 (MovingPictures07/G-Man)
9. METALMARSH89 (Nijuukyugou)<----NK'd N4 by Mafia
10. METALMARSH89 (Boomslang)<----NK'd N4 by SK
1. LORAB (Sloonei/Quin)
8. DOM (Sig)
12. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (Dom)
Not Voting:
A Person (3)<----Lynched D3- CIVVIE
Epignosis
Scotty<----NK'd N6 by SK
DAY 4
1. SLOONEI/QUIN (Sig)
2. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Epignosis)
3. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Boomslang)<----NK'd N4 by SK
4. TRICERATOPZEUHL (JaggedJimmyJay)
5. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Dom)
6. METALMARSH89 (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
7. TRICERATOPZEUHL (LoRab)
8. METALMARSH89 (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
9. METALMARSH89 (Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0)
10. METALMARSH89 (Nijuukyugou)<----NK'd N4 by Mafia
11. METALMARSH89 (MovingPictures07/G-Man)
12. METALMARSH89 (Triceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
13. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Metalmarsh89)
Not Voting: Sloonei/Quin (2)
-------------------------------------------
2. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Epignosis)
3. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Boomslang)<----NK'd N4 by SK
4. TRICERATOPZEUHL (JaggedJimmyJay)
5. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Dom)
7. TRICERATOPZEUHL (LoRab)
13. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Metalmarsh89)
6. METALMARSH89 (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
8. METALMARSH89 (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
9. METALMARSH89 (Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0)
10. METALMARSH89 (Nijuukyugou)<----NK'd N4 by Mafia
11. METALMARSH89 (MovingPictures07/G-Man)
12. METALMARSH89 (Triceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
1. SLOONEI/QUIN (Sig)
Not Voting:
Sloonei/Quin (2)
DAY 5
1. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (Metalmarsh89)
2. TRICERATOPZEUHL (LoRab)
3. TRICERATOPZEUHL (JaggedJimmyJay)
4. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
5. SCOTTY (Quin)
6. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
7. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Dom)
8. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (Tirceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
9. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Epignosis)
Not Voting: Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0 (2), MovingPictures07/G-Man, Sig
-----------------------------------
2. TRICERATOPZEUHL (LoRab)
3. TRICERATOPZEUHL (JaggedJimmyJay)
6. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
7. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Dom)
9. TRICERATOPZEUHL (Epignosis)
1. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (Metalmarsh89)
4. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
8. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (Tirceratopzeuhl)<----Lynched Day 5- Potential Indy?
5. SCOTTY (Quin)
Not Voting:
Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0 (2)
MovingPictures07/G-Man
Sig
DAY 6
1. BIRDWITHTEEH11 (Metalmarsh89)
2. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
3. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Dom)
4. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (JaggedJimmyJay)
5. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (G-Man)
6. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Quin)
7. METALMARSH89 (LoRab)
8. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
9. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Epignosis)
Not Voting: Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0 (3), Sig (2)
---------------------------------
2. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Timmer)<----NK'd N6 by Mafia
3. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Dom)
5. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (G-Man)
6. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Quin)
8. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Scotty)<----NK'd N6 by SK
9. JAGGEDJIMMYJAY (Epignosis)
1. BIRDWITHTEEH11 (Metalmarsh89)
4. BIRDWITHTEETH11/DRWILGY 2.0 (JaggedJimmyJay)
7. METALMARSH89 (LoRab)
Not Voting:
Birdwithteeth11/DrWilgy 2.0 (3)
Sig (2)
BIRDWITTEETH/DRWILGY 2.0
Day 1- Hard pressed to fault someone for missing a vote Day 1 but if you sign up, you should play. Verdict- frustrating.
Day 2- 9th overall, 3rd for Boomslang. "A Person didn't really catch on today, so let's nudge Boomslang out there as the leader." Verdict- sneaky
Day 3- 4th overall, 3rd for A Person. "Looks like we can make this A Person train a thing today." Verdict- advantageous
Day 4- 9th overall, 3rd for Marmot. "Don't want to hop on the Trice train too late, and this Marmot thing may get interesting, so let's go there." Verdict- strategic
Day 5 & 6- Missed the vote. It feels like BWT has a tendency to either show up late or disappear partway into a game. I can't really judge that. Verdict-
OVERALL: His three votes are very well placed. In a vacuum, it looks shady but he's buffered by those three missing votes. That either helps a baddie hide or makes a civvie look worse.
DOM
Day 1- Missed the vote. Hard to judge. Verdict- frustrating
Day 2- 12th overall, 4th for DrWilgy 1.0. "Plenty of votes to come in yet, so let's nudge Wilgy ahead and let the rest of them decide the day and take the heat for it." Verdict- assuming
Day 3- 12th overall, 1st and only for BWT. "Keeping my hands clean on the A Person train but I don't want to tie it and draw suspicion. Better vote sideways." Verdict- strategic
Day 4- 5th vote overall, 4th for Trice. "Better hop on the Trice train while it's still early." Verdict- convenient
Day 5- 7th overall, 4th for Trice. "Looks good to vote him again." Could also be, "Vote him again to nudge him two ahead of a teammate (BWT)." Verdict- strategically consistent
Day 6- 3rd overall, 2nd for Jimmy. "A day spent chasing Trice's SK accusation is a day I can relax." Verdict- convenient
OVERALL: Two strategic votes are worth considering but it's not a sure thing. The convenient votes cut both ways. Consistent votes also cut both ways.
EPIGNOSIS
Day 1- 9th overall, 1st and only for Trice. "Take the higher ground by not voting for an existing train to help my case." Verdict- strategic
Day 2- 11th overall, 3rd for DrWilgy 1.0. "Why have a runaway civ train on Boomslang when you can have competing civ trains?" Verdict- strategic
Day 3- Missed the vote. I can't fault him because stuff happens but it helps because the A Person train looked awful from a vote perspective. Verdict- neutral
Day 4- 2nd overall, 1st for Trice. "I voted for him once and I can make myself look good if others follow me on this one." Verdict- advantageous
Day 5- 9th overall, 5th for Trice. "Consistency, consistency, consistency. And it keeps the SK from getting a teammate." Verdict- obvious
Day 6- 9th overall, 6th for Jimmy. "Well duh." Verdict- obvious
OVERALL: There's not much to like here but I do have a tendency to read Epi like a James Bond villain.
JAGGEDJIMMYJAY
Day 1- 4th overall, 2nd for INH. "Might as well nudge one of these three into the lead." Verdict- opportunisitc
Day 2- 7th overall, 1st for DrWilgy 1.0. "None of the others satisfy me, so let's try this." Verdict- risky
Day 3- 11th overall, 5th for A Person. "I'm not afraid to break a tie because I can talk my way out of any heat that may come of it." Verdict- risky
Day 4- 4th overall, 3rd for Trice. "Let's see if we can get others on board and make this a runaway train." Verdict- advantageous
Day 5- 3rd overall, 2nd for Trice. "Consistent and persistent- that's the Jimmy way." Verdict- vengeful (if Trice claimed against him already); otherwise opportunisitc
Day 6- 4th overall, 2nd for BWT. "Self-preservation mode... engage!" Verdict- obvious
OVERALL: It's the two risky votes that steer me away from him as mafia. Why go that route?
I'll try to work on the other four later this afternoon. Gotta get back to work.