Sloonei wrote: ↑Thu May 03, 2018 8:04 pmThis is the most engaged I've seen nova in my (admittedly limited) experience with him. The piece of evidence which has been central to the discussion around him has been Colin's Day 1 vote for luna (RIP) when nova/sig/epi were on the block. colonialbob and Golden had a lengthy conversation about the two sides of this, with cbob arguing that if Colin wanted to save one of those three, he would have voted on a wagon. Golden argued that Colin's fear was over being caught saving a teammate. I lean toward cbob's side.
This is literally the basis on which Colin was caught; having said that, he disagreed strenuously with my logic. I could see it going either way.
What I would say is not 'this makes nova bad', but rather that the needle moves, because Colin's choice on day one was indiciative of certain patters. This is known baddie behaviour. I've been in that position myself (in day one of Guess Who mafia) and it's extraordinarily uncomfortable when you are faced with that situation and a teammate on the line. On the other hand, with no teammate on the line, the choice is much more odd - there's no reason not to find a legitimate reason to be on a wagon.
Given Luna's flip (and over the last day I felt more like she was town, it just felt like a better choice than daisy), if Colin got caught for his behaviour and nova was also town, colin's slip had no meaning. We just got lucky.