The Syndicate

Hey how did you get the banner?

LittleTiger wrote:Another fun and awesome game by Andrew (and Kate, of course) well done, Andrew - you are very creative and learning fast. I cannot wait for the day that you get to play

Spaghetti - I had a lot of fun in our BTSC, you did great in this game!

Also, who killed me? And why?

It was actually my idea LT lol It was random and I said you were too quiet so most of the suggestions were mine that I ran by DP and Rey so they could send it in

But I thought you and BF were wolves and so I thought us killing you guys that weren't posting as much then lynching the talkers was a good strategy i was doing

I still am amazed i survived til the end even with my teammates saying i needed to lay low and kept doing ballsy moves. This was a very fun first mafia game even thought i wish I had been Civ haha

Kate when are the sign ups for your Tv Mafia? I loved you as a host and am excited

MP btw, I was the one who used the potion on you to make you accuse BWT hehehe It was my last attempt to save myself but unfortunately, the Villager stole Dp's power and Insanified you so it didnt quite come out with you looking as crazy as I hoped

Roxy wrote:Was everyone I killed a civvie? lol

Rey, DP, Epi, and I were the baddies. I still don't know who Hero was because I thought it was BWT towards the end. Who was?

And SEE guys i told you I wasn't Hero

I never had the opportunity to kill BF though, because I didn't want to make it too obvious

But his face when I told him i was bad was priceless hehehe I'm a sneaky boy baby

I almost made it

Good job i enjoyed my first game

Well you guys have apparently made up your minds about me. I will try to take Hero out and tie up the votes if Llama joins me. If I get lynched, you will see more clearly how I knew about my suspicions. It's going to make sense and hope you guys survive Hero and the last Baddie

Good luck baby on seeing who's been lying to you since I couldn't tell you

Boogs wrote:There are 2 possibilities i think FH:
Either MP protected the right person to help us and Hero didnt kill anyone and is still lurking along with Skeleton,
Or MP was Hero was MP or SE and just Skeleton (hopefully) is still lurking.

The reason I put hopefully is: the only confirmed baddies we had were Epi and DP? We assumed and all still hope to believe Elochin was bad so there would only be 1 remaining Baddie. But my fear is, Skeleton and Creeper are both alive. (creeper can block so maybe they blocked Hero?)

Lets just hope there is only 1 Baddie left.
BWT: I am not surprised you are still after me but lets hope you are the one to go, Skeleton

And Just a thought: I know this is my first game, but why wouldn't a Baddie vote for their own teammate to try to keep suspicion off and win? (Llama voting for DP)? I think that is a possibility being overlooked

EBWOP: (I need for read my stuff because autocorrect kills me) Or Hero was MP or SE and just Skeleton (hopefully) is still lurking

There are 2 possibilities i think FH:
Either MP protected the right person to help us and Hero didnt kill anyone and is still lurking along with Skeleton,
Or MP was Hero was MP or SE and just Skeleton (hopefully) is still lurking.

The reason I put hopefully is: the only confirmed baddies we had were Epi and DP? We assumed and all still hope to believe Elochin was bad so there would only be 1 remaining Baddie. But my fear is, Skeleton and Creeper are both alive. (creeper can block so maybe they blocked Hero?)

Lets just hope there is only 1 Baddie left.
BWT: I am not surprised you are still after me but lets hope you are the one to go, Skeleton

And Just a thought: I know this is my first game, but why wouldn't a Baddie vote for their own teammate to try to keep suspicion off and win? (Llama voting for DP)? I think that is a possibility being overlooked

Okay EBWOP: I re looked and DP cast his vote right before I voted. Sorry about that. But still, I did say i wanted them both out. I feel I was still onto something because MP voted for him too, but then again I may have been right with him being recruit or Hero could be alive and just not killed.... But I doubt he wouldn't kill because why wouldn't he take one of us out?

Roxy wrote:I don't know boogs. Maybe they decided a kill wasn't in their best interests and everyone would assume the role is dead - something I will not assume until I know it is a fact.

Even if Herobrine is dead you can still be a mafia. You did not vote for DP last lynch. As a matter of fact you didn't listen or wait for discussion you just voted Teeth. Maybe you were hoping to help remove the spotlight from DP. Idk. I am at a loss this morning.

If you re ready posts, I said I thought DP and BWT were bad. The reason I voted for BWT over DP was because he voted for me first. DP voted for me later on that evening after my vote was already cast. I was not preferring one over the other, I wanted them both out.

Is Hero dead since there was no kill? Maybe people will start to believe me I wasn't bad or Hero

I was 99% sure SVS was Stevie. I really need to re read and think who to lynch now :/

Flyin' High wrote:
Roxy wrote:FH - I am worried about tonight tbh. If there are 2 civ kills I think its likely its game over for the civs.
Yes, I'm worried too. I hope Stevie is still alive and can make the best decision on who to kill and/or that Ambray was magically somehow Herobrine and we won't have a Herobrine kill. Or maybe Creeper can do us a favor and try to block Herobrine.

I wish SVS was alive to but unfortunately Hero NK'd her and I would still have a player who believed and knew who I was here to stop this nonsense.

I've tried to reason and tell people I'm not Hero and they have it wrong but no one seems to listen or want to believe me. I've given my reasons, even with SE being floppy and MP the most, you guys still all agree I'm Hero. I'm NOT and if I get lynched, you're going to understand all the hints I've been dropping and understand how I've known and figured out certain things. But I really wish you guys will give me a chance and not just ignore me and not ask for my input at all. Maybe Hero's NK will help me since I'm sure he wants to keep me in the spotlight so I get lynched.

Roxy wrote:Yes that too FH! Yay!

Also great points on spaghetti he has not posted nearly as much as he was. I am sure they were just trying to lay low.

I don't think spaghetti is Herobrine.

I also left Teeth off my list.
I have a role in mind for him and it is not Herobrine.

I wonder why boogs would come up with this crazy theory that makes no sense. He even said Porcu was not Herobrine. Could he be Herobrine? FH your post about him is very on point with my thinking!

Sock - why did you suddenly vote with boogs against Teeth? What exactly made you jump to that conclusion? All game long you have been saying you trust llama that he was good but then you don't trust him and vote for someone he was absolutely saying not to vote for?

Llama - I agree I hope they are the last 2.

When did i ever say DP was Hero? I've only said that MP was him then said is agree he is a recruit and the last 2 baddies i felt were DP (I was correct on and mentioned that yesterday too) and BWT.

Flyin' High wrote:
Roxy wrote:If you felt more strongly about boogs I would have followed you FH. <3
I really hope we are right today!

Well all this does not make me feel better tbs. Porcu I swear I will just flip out if I am wrong.

Oh no more talk of recruits!! My hed can't handle it tonight.
I don't think you were talking me out of Boogs.

Boogs, can you please explain how MP can both be Herobrine and have been dead Night 1? When you can explain that, I might start believing you. Otherwise I don't understand how it's possible. A recruit at this point makes more sense to me than Herobrine killing from beyond the grave.

FH I know my theory sounds crazy but I just feel like we were onto something.... It does not seem logical he is Herobrine. I will admit i may not be accurate there, but a recruit? yes, largely largely possible. We all still have no idea what the secret part of Hero's role is, which COULD be just that. Also, his constant flip flopping and wishy washy feelings on everyone throw me a HUGE

. He most caught me he wanted to tie the poll and I felt that if he were Civ, why would he ever even suggest a thing?
FH you do make me think, again Hero was dead so it must be a recruit so I am wrong on him being the actual Hero. But someone else must be. MP targeting Llama and BWT was odd like he was trying to throw us off getting them. Is he pretending to cover up suspicions? I want to kill Hero as bad as the rest of the good guys, but we have to lynch right. Hopefully we got one right tonight.

Linksy:

I was right bout one of the 2! Heck yes! It is getting down to the wire. Great job guys!

SE hasn't voted?

blindfaeth wrote:Sorry DP. You're making me emotional and cause me to hesitate. Still, I promised I'd vote this way and I don't trust MP so heres to hoping we got a baddie >.<

Here's to hoping we got one! Hope we all can see the light about MP next and BWT

I still would love a BWT over DP to see what MP was agreeing with me for. I'm very intrigued

Flyin' High wrote:It's done. I've voted. Now I'm just going to cross my fingers and toes that DP is Herobine and I didn't allow myself to get talked out of a Boogs lynch today.

he's not hero as I've tried to tell you guys, MP is. But I do believe we will get 1 of the 2 Baddies since he and BWT are on the chopping block. But you can believe me if DP gets lynched and doesn't turn up Hero. I know my hunch is right.

MovingPictures07 wrote:The original slut Blindfaeth in the basement of her hole

Lol. My Boyfriend isn't a slut

blindfaeth wrote:MP, you are being difficult and you know it. I think you are trying to sow confusion. Since I've noticed you can post smilies, for god's sake, please quote this post.

means you want us to lynch boogs

means you want us to lynch BWT

means you want us to lynch DP

Obviously, since I dont trust you, I will probably do the opposite of what you suggest.

I honestly don't understand how you could possibly be hero either, and I could be completely wrong you've been recruited, but whatever. You say I'm off, I say you're way off. Your post trying to condemn me compared to the post you used to catch Epig pales in comparison, it was a stark difference and TBH a sad attempt. You are posting these long confusing jumbled posts often instead of simply responding with yes nods and no shakes to peoples questions of you, I think you're trying to sow confusion. Then, tomorrow whatever outcome happens you can hide behind the fact "I never said that". To eliminate that excuse & simplify guesswork, please just comply with that request.

On top of that, you talked about lynching me while I was not here to defend myself yesterday, talked about tying it up and then in the end ABSTAINED from voting. If thats not weird MP behavior, I don't know what is. Then trying to blow off my logic of Boogs not having teammates because he's been asking me all these OT questions as not being civvie BF. I think thats a perfectly sound conclusion to jump to. He'd be putting a lot of extra unnecessary weird effort into trying to trick me when he can learn all his tricks from his alleged teammates. The more you post, the more I don't agree with you. And the fact that you are still with us as a "confirmed civvie" worries me even more. The fact that Epig tried to convince everyone you'd been recruited on his way out and then we lynched him and he came back baddie, tells me that maybe they had a recruitment up their sleeve, and that was your ticket out: WIFOM.

Anyway, I'm getting way off topic, because I know no one will vote MP with me today as he's insanified but I think in contrast HE needs to be looked at next lynch TBQH. The post that I keep remembering in my head was when you first mentioned boogs as being suspicious, you said something along the lines of "Oh don't worry, after you lose you get over it, i've played a lot of games and only won x amount of times" ... as if it were a sure thing Boogs would get lynched, just because you deemed it should happen. If you are good, I just want you to come off the pedestal. I want to remind you that in all I'm saying nothing is personal of course and I don't want any argument that follows to become heated. I just think your role is bad now, or perhaps to begin with, though I don't understand how it could have occurred.

That being said, I'll wait and see if MP complies by posting a smiley or continues to confuse people and derail the thread with their trying to interpret his meanings. I could be convinced to vote for DP or BWT, or Roxy if anyone can come up with a case against her, I don't have the time to but I just have a bad feeling in my gut. SE is also someone I could vote for if there were a case. Roxy says I've been blendy, what about SE?

I would have voted MP myself but I figured no one would believe me like I said and hope the Baddies NK him since he's Hero. But, at least I can try to lynch BWT or DP because I know if I survive, MP is gonna NK me for everything and we got a Baddie lynched before i died.

thellama73 wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Is Birdwithteeth (A)

Don't vote for BWT, Alex. Vote for DP.

? Lol. I don't get how you interpreted that. I read vote for him since he brought up his name lol. But we will see what happens and the votes

I would like to point out, if MP thought i should be lynched from his blabber, why didnt he cast his vote for me? He kept mentioning BWT and DP also. I'm just saying.

Boogs wrote:Lets hope the baddies agree you are Hero and NK you since no one will lynch you even though I tried to show who you really are

Directed at my dear MP the imposter

Lets hope the baddies agree you are Hero and NK you since no one will lynch you even though I tried to show who you really are

I'm voting BWT. Going with my gut for him being one of the last 2 baddies. I should vote you MP, but it seeks your blabber may say you see I'm not bad since you brought up DP and BWT like I've tried pointing out last night.

Not saying much more per rules, but remember how I've been good at noticing things and re read all the roles. It's my final plea to tell you to trust SVS and Russ and think of who are the real suspects.

You guys also fail to notice there are Indies in this game too and haven't thought maybe I'm not as bad as you suspect and even think of that possibility.

birdwithteeth11 wrote:I've read the full story. And I have come to the conclusion that Boogs is very likely bad. I don't see how lynching him helps Epig or his team however.

And unfortunately I've made up my mind. I'm willing to bet the outcome of this game at this point on Boogs.

MP and you can poop his socks when you see I'm not Hero and I've been right about my hunches on you and him being Hero himself.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Fishing Birdwithteeth fishing Birdwithteeth fishing catch God for life.

Roxy wrote:MP's insanification posts while very very funny are most unhelpful.

I am down with a boogs lynch and if you are too Sockdude quote this post.

Llama - the spider could have died - maybe - it all depends on which PM's were receieved first according to Andrew and Kate's rules.
But yes, any suitable sauna Sauna Boogs Boogs Boogs. Or say that it removes NG:

thellama73 wrote:I have got to go with my gut. Boogs is probably bad, but my gut has been screaming DP since day one and I can't shake it. Also, the air of desperation in MP's insanified posts is making me paranoid that he thinks we are making a mistake with our Boogs talk.

*Votes DP*
DP: I agree, but sound, copper, bronze, Birdwithteeth Boogs catch I agree with.

Flyin' High wrote:
Roxy wrote:So in other words it was never my suppostion it was something I read in SVS's posts. Why does it really matter who is alive? The point is there are still baddies and tbh I do not care what baddie we lynch as long as we do indeed lynch a baddie.
It matters because the point I keep trying to make is I was trying to use that as actual confirmation that Elohcin was bad so we'd have a better idea of how many mafia are actually left alive. Now I clearly was wrong since MP is insanified today, but I don't think SVS was right that indi was bad as I've explained.

thellama73 wrote:Last night just before I went to bed, I had a stabbing pang in my gut that tells me we should lynch DP instead of Boogs. It is still here this morning. The pressure, oh god the pressure!
I had the same one llama. And it came from the realization that DP also was someone who chose Bank. I hadn't realized it initially since his vote wasn't on the screencap that LT posted.

I've been trying to think about the players that Herobrine has chosen to nightkill--indi, Ambray, FH(me), SVS. But honestly, I can't see a trend. We've all gone after different players this game and generally our ideas haven't even been that similar.

I am very torn about this lynch and feel that if we don't find a killer, it will spell doom for us.
Boogs, Birdwithteeth, DP is not necessarily to win. There is no need or even the bad news.

BWT? Are you actually agreeing with with me about BWT?

reywaS wrote:

I didn't think you were bad and we lost 3 Civs

Kate wrote:OK guys I have to do this real quick and dirty. I have a bit of a situation here.

My apologies.

Ambray has been killed by the Villager.
Reywas has been killed by Stevie.
SVS has been killed by Herobrine.

Please don't post until I say so.

Sh*t!!! I really felt strongly SVS was Stevie and we just lost her

There goes Stevie helping us NK Herobrine.
We're gonna lose if we can't kill the right people guys. Seriously.
FH: I'm saying MP has rubbed me the wrong way ever since he came back and his "you know I am civ so believe me" and holier than thou has really pushed me to post what I have felt. I'm not copying Epi, I am saying I really Believe he was onto MP and MP wants to call us wishy washy? He wanted to kill Russ then he didnt, and he thought BF was so bad and now he thinks he isn't? Same with him doing it to me. He is drawing attention to us to get the lynches while he kills the quiet players at night. I really need you to trust me FH and I felt SVS's posts meant she was onto it also. Especially when she kept trying to tell you guys she felt i was civ and the fact I trusted her and by her posts felt strongly she was Stevie. I even said i didn't think she was bad and tried to say we shouldn't lynch her earlier in the game. I need you guys to think and stop listening to MP and draw your own conclusions before he wins this as Hero!!

blindfaeth wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Rox, I don't necessarily think you're baddie. Those are my paranoid candidates, i.e. if one of you is tricking me. And yes I know it's the second time I've mentioned you; it's partially by process of elimination and lately I have had the occasional thought that you could be baddie. You did focus on Snow Dog and I found it weird that you said you couldn't read DP, so I have had the paranoid thought that you two could be the other two on that team. I've wondered about all of those I listed in that grouping, but I'm far for advocating any of your lynch. I just am trying to keep open to all possibilities, and that if BF and SE aren't on Epig's team, for example, and there are still two others left, then it would have to be one of those two, including you. We are getting at least somewhat down to the wire, so we can't afford to make any mistakes, and I don't want to blindly trust you or anyone else just because you're reading civvie to me, does that make sense?

Does anyone else have a read on Rox for that matter or rey, S~V~S, etc. (who hasn't commented about any of those already)?

Boogs wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Okay, not a TON to say here, and my brain feels okay enough now, apparently, lol. I definitely am on with a Boogs lynch; it makes total sense that he could be mafia or Hero.

BF, thank you very much for your response and for clarifying your train of thought re: a few of your posts. Also, I'm sorry I contemplated railroading you without you being there to respond yesterday, but I am really reading Ambray as civvie and I was reading Snow Dog as civvie (but with some paranoia), so they were two terrible options. I was reading Boogs as bad for quite a bit, but then Russ flipped civ, and he kind of dropped off my radar, unfortunately.

I think if Boogs is not Hero, and he very well could be, then he must be either the last member of Epig's team (assuming indi was bad), OR he's a third member and the fourth member could very well be BF or SE.

I'm not planning on voting BWT or llama any time soon. Even before BWT's response, I highly anticipated there being a likely reason for llama's viewpoints, and it actually makes both of their behavior throughout the game rather clear. Now that BWT has responded, it has confirmed those suspicions, so I don't think distrusting either of them would be wise. It does fall in line with my favorable (but was still questioning at times) reads on both of them as well.

In summary: Boogs, BF, and SE seem most likely to be our remaining baddies, without a doubt. Worst case scenario, I'm also considering rey, DP, Rox, and S~V~S, but I'm currently leaning civvie on those individuals. I agree we definitely lynch Boogs tomorrow and go from there.
It's highly unlikely both couples were on a team but sure. I'm not bad but if you east to try to lynch me MP hoping I am Hero or Baddie, you're in for a shock tomorrow and lost another civ. Read me how you want, but the Rogue is loving this.
How? It's just as likely as any other combination, correct?

Who is baddie then?

Roxy wrote:Also MP - you have said nothing about Rey. What do you think of what I said about him and also what I said about spaghetti
I've been reading rey as civvie, but I don't know. He has been a bit on the quiet side. I'd have to re-read him again, but he hasn't given me any reason to distrust him. That being said, he has been focused entirely on llama and relatively unhelpful, but he was the first to pick up on Snow Dog's role. I don't know about him.

I definitely think SE could be baddie, but I'm not sure. Good observations about him, I do agree he's been blendy. I'm not sure if it's because he's bad or not though, but he's up there in terms of for me.

blindfaeth wrote:Maybe boogs has blindsided me, but I just dont think he's bad. If he is, I'd say he has to be hero, because all of his off topic mafia-related questions are being directed to me outside of the game. For example "How do i edit a post" - "You can't, say EBWOP, it means edit by way of post". So unless he's putting forth a lot of extra effort to do something like that, I just don't think he has temamates.

In any case MP, I am not bad, so apparently you are wrong about two people, I suggest you start working out those possibilities in case things go south.

I guess at this point re: MP's feedback on Ambray I'm inclined to look at DP and Roxy and SE as candidates? I'm just really not sure.
This doesn't mean anything though. He could be mafia asking you those same questions, correct?

And I don't like your response in the second line here. Seems pingy to me. I don't understand how you're so sure of him being civvie. How about you go on his in-game behavior?

This doesn't feel like civvie BF to me. I could be wrong, but it just seems off.
You've seemed off to me ever since you came back a confirmed civvie TBQH, I still don't trust you fully. Yet in the midst of being accused by you constantly I hold faith that you'll come to your senses and find the real baddies

Glad someone said it. Anyone else, can you honestly say MP is acting normal? He keeps saying he is right about things because he "is Civ" because he was shown to be the Armor. I don't think that theory Epi left with as a bang and SVS mentioned could be all that false this deep in the game. I have kept quiet to not be targeted more by MP.
And what is all that CIV wanting a tie for the lynch yesterday? You asked me who it think it Hero? We've been looking him in the face the whole game and he's fooling us all. I can't say much about my role, but I was waiting for the daytime to say MP I am onto you and know you've been Hero. I didn't want to risk you NK me.

Keep your suspicions if you want, but he's been staring you all in the face acting CIV but he's going to win if we can't stop him and the last 2 Baddies. Don't believe me and keep thinking i am Hero, but you guys will see if we don't lynch him soon.

I had said earlier MP:

Boogs wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Boogs wrote:
Flyin' High wrote:
thellama73 wrote:If we trust Russ that either indi or Boogs is bad, I would bet Boogs since he voted for a civvie four nights in a row.
Right, and indi was an Epignosis voter and was killed by Herobrine so it couldn't have been her. Whoever Russ targeted on Night 1 or 2 must have been targeted by both indi and Boogs on the same night and was also either killed or had a kill attempted on them that night which would have led Russ to say that.

After I'm done reading through Day 3 I want to go back through boogs' posts again and also see who may have been defending boogs (blindfaeth immediately comes to mind).
I had voted for Snow 2 times because I felt he was bad and have been consistent with voting on how I felt. It is my first game so maybe I don't pick up as some others. I felt confident Snow was bad but obviously was proven wrong. Honestly, I really feel the lynch needs to be BWT because Ambray was on to something but I'm not going to say more to give info to the baddies.

As for BF, we both have been busy and haven't been on and posting as much as MP and others. That doesn't make us being low posters "bad" because we have other thing going on. BF has been pretty good seeing who is bad and I think he is also Civ.

Others have been wrong lynching Civs including MP himself leading the Russ lynch.
If you think BF is good, Boogs. Who do you think the remaining baddies are, besides BWT?
I think Elochin was Baddie, and the remaining Baddies are BWT and DP. Something about that porcupine's posts and hiding back are poking me the wrong way. (Pun intended) I just haven't wanted to outright say anything about those 2 and draw more attention looking like I know something but I can't say much more. Just gonna have to trust me.

As for Herobrine, I really can't pinpoint them but still looking for clues. I know we really need to think Day 5's lynch carefully and get them out. (I think Andrew/Kate haven't updated and it should start Day 5 tonight)

EBWOP *If you want

MovingPictures07 wrote:Okay, not a TON to say here, and my brain feels okay enough now, apparently, lol. I definitely am on with a Boogs lynch; it makes total sense that he could be mafia or Hero.

BF, thank you very much for your response and for clarifying your train of thought re: a few of your posts. Also, I'm sorry I contemplated railroading you without you being there to respond yesterday, but I am really reading Ambray as civvie and I was reading Snow Dog as civvie (but with some paranoia), so they were two terrible options. I was reading Boogs as bad for quite a bit, but then Russ flipped civ, and he kind of dropped off my radar, unfortunately.

I think if Boogs is not Hero, and he very well could be, then he must be either the last member of Epig's team (assuming indi was bad), OR he's a third member and the fourth member could very well be BF or SE.

I'm not planning on voting BWT or llama any time soon. Even before BWT's response, I highly anticipated there being a likely reason for llama's viewpoints, and it actually makes both of their behavior throughout the game rather clear. Now that BWT has responded, it has confirmed those suspicions, so I don't think distrusting either of them would be wise. It does fall in line with my favorable (but was still questioning at times) reads on both of them as well.

In summary: Boogs, BF, and SE seem most likely to be our remaining baddies, without a doubt. Worst case scenario, I'm also considering rey, DP, Rox, and S~V~S, but I'm currently leaning civvie on those individuals. I agree we definitely lynch Boogs tomorrow and go from there.

It's highly unlikely both couples were on a team but sure. I'm not bad but if you east to try to lynch me MP hoping I am Hero or Baddie, you're in for a shock tomorrow and lost another civ. Read me how you want, but the Rogue is loving this.

birdwithteeth11 wrote:Alright. Here's what I came up with on my re-read of Boogs.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=13582#p13582 This is where Boogs first brings up Snow Dog. To be honest, I was surprised it was as early as Day 1. I thought it wasn't until Day 2 or 3 that Boogs had tossed his name in there.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=13610#p13610 Here he says he is suspicious of Snow Dog still, but throws llama into the mix. Given the whole SD/llama/Roxy fiasco, this looks like a whole bunch of very easy targets in retrospect.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=13746#p13746 Here is his vote for Snow Dog. Mostly based on the fact that he feels SD had info on the Day 0 poll.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=13752#p13752 Now THIS is the part of his vote I was looking for. He says he "re-read" and realized Snow Dog was pushing house, but still feels strong about casting his vote that way. This definitely pings me.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=13903#p13903 Here he thinks the biggest possibility is that the sword switched the lynch. I highly doubted it back then but left it open as a possibility. After everything that's happened though, I think it's fairly obvious that the sword did not switch a lynch.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=13947#p13947 Again, saying it's very likely the sword switched the lynch.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=13984#p13984 More of the same.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=14112#p14112 Here's another very eye-opening one. He name-drops llama very causally again (a little too casually if you ask me), and then says he thinks the whole Epig/Elo thing was just a wife defending her husband. But given that Epig was bad and there's a fairly good chance Elo was as well, I think Boogs knows something else and is trying to plant an idea in the thread that might not be true.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=14217#p14217 This looks like Boogs is trying to cover his tracks after Epig starts getting more pressure and actual votes. He re-opens the idea of "Hey, maybe Epig and Elo COULD actually be bad..." but still votes for llama anyway.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=14275#p14275 Another push for looking at Snow Dog and llama.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=14421#p14421 Wait, you "still stand by thinking Elochin being Baddie"? This is your first time mentioning it as a definite, for-sure thing! You've completely done a 180 where you thought there was a possibility of them being bad, but not likely, to suddenly Elo is bad. No explanation as to why either. Also, he thinks Russ could be odd, but manages to twist that suspicion back on Snow Dog.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=14542#p14542 Now Boogs votes Russ here saying he'll "be busy", but offers no concrete explanation as to why he is voting Russ. This feels too much like a drive-by vote.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=14587#p14587 Your RIP doesn't feel very genuine here. Especially given that you gave almost zero reason for your vote for Russ.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=14836#p14836 Of course you're going to pick Snow here. You've been subtly pushing for him the entire game! Oh, and posts like these make me think we need to look at BF a bit closer if Boogs gets lynched and comes back baddie. I've seen some slight defending from both of them this game, and not just in the "because they are a couple" way.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=15068#p15068 Here he attempts to justify his reason for voting Snow Dog twice, but there's too much evidence against him for it to seem valid. He also mentions me. Trying to subtly get another civvie lynched I see?

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=129&p=15076#p15076 Okay, but why do you think I'm bad? You haven't given any reason yet. Actually, you never really gave a reason for anyone you've voted for. Have you? Also, the only possibility I see that both Boogs and DP are bad is if one of them is Hero.

In conclusion, I would like to thank FH for mentioning Boogs and pulling a few quotes. Because I think there is a VERY strong possibility that Boogs is a baddie and that he will be getting my vote today. Also, I think if Boogs flips bad, that we need to seriously consider looking at BF. Because they could be teammates given the subtle defending I've seen going on. I didn't pull all those quotes so going back and re-reading Boogs would be beneficial for a lot of us.

Edit: Tons of linki

BWT of course you are gonna come after me because I figured out Ambray caught onto you and you are bad

I'm not going to keeps arguing bout myself, I said you should trust SVS and Russ saying how he felt about me but you guys can think what you want.

Flyin' High wrote:
Boogs wrote:
Flyin' High wrote:
thellama73 wrote:If we trust Russ that either indi or Boogs is bad, I would bet Boogs since he voted for a civvie four nights in a row.
Right, and indi was an Epignosis voter and was killed by Herobrine so it couldn't have been her. Whoever Russ targeted on Night 1 or 2 must have been targeted by both indi and Boogs on the same night and was also either killed or had a kill attempted on them that night which would have led Russ to say that.

After I'm done reading through Day 3 I want to go back through boogs' posts again and also see who may have been defending boogs (blindfaeth immediately comes to mind).
I had voted for Snow 2 times because I felt he was bad and have been consistent with voting on how I felt. It is my first game so maybe I don't pick up as some others. I felt confident Snow was bad but obviously was proven wrong. Honestly, I really feel the lynch needs to be BWT because Ambray was on to something but I'm not going to say more to give info to the baddies.

As for BF, we both have been busy and haven't been on and posting as much as MP and others. That doesn't make us being low posters "bad" because we have other thing going on. BF has been pretty good seeing who is bad and I think he is also Civ.

Others have been wrong lynching Civs including MP himself leading the Russ lynch.
It seems like your response completely ignored what I was pointing out by quoting Russ' posts though. He indicated that he felt either you or indi were bad and that we'd understand why he said that if he got lynched. He was the Minecart. Meaning he can track a player and see who targets them at night. What're your thoughts on that?

I have never targeted Russ with my power to help him in any way, so I'm not sure what he meant. I can't discuss my role, but I think SVS and Russ's last words saying he really felt i was Civ is as much as I can say.

thellama73 wrote:
Boogs wrote:
Flyin' High wrote:
thellama73 wrote:If we trust Russ that either indi or Boogs is bad, I would bet Boogs since he voted for a civvie four nights in a row.
Right, and indi was an Epignosis voter and was killed by Herobrine so it couldn't have been her. Whoever Russ targeted on Night 1 or 2 must have been targeted by both indi and Boogs on the same night and was also either killed or had a kill attempted on them that night which would have led Russ to say that.

After I'm done reading through Day 3 I want to go back through boogs' posts again and also see who may have been defending boogs (blindfaeth immediately comes to mind).
I had voted for Snow 2 times because I felt he was bad and have been consistent with voting on how I felt. It is my first game so maybe I don't pick up as some others. I felt confident Snow was bad but obviously was proven wrong. Honestly, I really feel the lynch needs to be BWT because Ambray was on to something but I'm not going to say more to give info to the baddies.

As for BF, we both have been busy and haven't been on and posting as much as MP and others. That doesn't make us being low posters "bad" because we have other thing going on. BF has been pretty good seeing who is bad and I think he is also Civ.

Others have been wrong lynching Civs including MP himself leading the Russ lynch.
If you think BF is good, Boogs. Who do you think the remaining baddies are, besides BWT?

I think Elochin was Baddie, and the remaining Baddies are BWT and DP. Something about that porcupine's posts and hiding back are poking me the wrong way. (Pun intended) I just haven't wanted to outright say anything about those 2 and draw more attention looking like I know something but I can't say much more. Just gonna have to trust me.

As for Herobrine, I really can't pinpoint them but still looking for clues. I know we really need to think Day 5's lynch carefully and get them out. (I think Andrew/Kate haven't updated and it should start Day 5 tonight)

Flyin' High wrote:
thellama73 wrote:If we trust Russ that either indi or Boogs is bad, I would bet Boogs since he voted for a civvie four nights in a row.
Right, and indi was an Epignosis voter and was killed by Herobrine so it couldn't have been her. Whoever Russ targeted on Night 1 or 2 must have been targeted by both indi and Boogs on the same night and was also either killed or had a kill attempted on them that night which would have led Russ to say that.

After I'm done reading through Day 3 I want to go back through boogs' posts again and also see who may have been defending boogs (blindfaeth immediately comes to mind).

I had voted for Snow 2 times because I felt he was bad and have been consistent with voting on how I felt. It is my first game so maybe I don't pick up as some others. I felt confident Snow was bad but obviously was proven wrong. Honestly, I really feel the lynch needs to be BWT because Ambray was on to something but I'm not going to say more to give info to the baddies.

As for BF, we both have been busy and haven't been on and posting as much as MP and others. That doesn't make us being low posters "bad" because we have other thing going on. BF has been pretty good seeing who is bad and I think he is also Civ.

Others have been wrong lynching Civs including MP himself leading the Russ lynch.

I don't think BF has really made me twitch, but we both have been pretty busy this weekend so I can vouch for him not posting much.

I have to vote now because I'm on my break. Ambray or Snow seem to be the 2 we are saying so I'm sticking with my gut since the beginning and voting Snow. Ambray hasn't given me much Baddie vibes.

(Votes Snow)

Flyin' High wrote:I went back through all of boogs posts and as I said, for the most part he reads civvie to me. Maybe the golem did happen to block Herobrine last night, but I don't think that's the reason I survived. And as was pointed out, the golem couldn't have blocked Herobrine 2 nights in a row because double targeting isn't allowed.

One thing that I noticed on reread of boogs' posts is that he was a bank voter. And if we're going with the theory that house was civvie and ship was mafia, then perhaps bank was indy?

I can't remember who else voted bank. I will read back through Day 0 posts to see who else may have mentioned it because that may be a way for us to potentially narrow down who Herobrine is. Though if bank was indy, we also risk targeting the wolves who I don't think mean the civvies any harm, so I figure we should tread carefully.

I did not know the rules that someone can not use their powers on the same person 2 nights in a row.

Flyin' High wrote:Thanks for helping me survive last night!

Now the question is, did I hit to close to home by wondering if Snow Dog is Herobrine, or is Herobrine trying to set Snow Dog up? Or did Herobrine try to kill me for another reason?

RIPIYWG LT! I think you had to be good.

Boogs wrote:RIP LT. I'm happy the Golem keeps blocking Herobrine
What makes you think the Golem blocked Herobrine?

Looking at the rolls it seems that is what happened, or that MP helped guard you. Either way glad you're safe and we didnt give Hero another kill!

It is possible Herobrine set him up since he's been away and his name has been thrown around. Has anyone seemed like they have been coming at you FH to try to kill you for another reason?

RIP LT. I'm happy the Golem keeps blocking Herobrine

RIP Russ sucks you turned out to be good :/

MP what seemed suspicious about BWT? I think I may have missed the discussion as I have been skimming the posts the last few days on breaks or when I get a minute between things with BF and I would like to hear about it again if you don't mind.

Guys what are your thoughts on Rogue?

That was a lot to catch up on between work and seeing BF the past 2 days lol

I'm going to cast my vote since I will be busy this evening as BF stated, and vote Russ.

*Votes Russ*

I'm working this weekend but I am just catching up on my break real quick.

I know it's Night 2 still and we don't cast our lynch until tomorrow but just wanted to just post my thoughts on everything being said.

I definitely still stand by thinking Elochin being Baddie and agree with MP that Stevie should use a night kill and us not waste a lynch, when we can try to lynch another of the 2 Baddies or the Rogue.

For the Rogue, idk who it is still :/ I know we need to find out soon because we can't afford more civ NKs and it doesn't help not knowing that person's role :/

Russ being suspicious? I do think it is a little odd, but more so on Snow now. I had my suspicions early on Day 1 about him and the poll knowledge, and him frantically switching for being for Epi then not being for him when voting Day 2 was really weird to me. I feel Epi wanted him to vote for him in an attempt to not make him look like a teammate defending him since the votes were starting to go to Epi.

I'm hoping Stevie does kill Elochin and we can lynch Snow

Search found 86 matches