The Syndicate

This was truly an awesome game, INH! Congrats to llama!

insertnamehere wrote:Still need that one freaking PM.

Lol.

I understand this feeling SO well as a host.

Also, I must say that both are awesome pictures, llama. Nice to put a face (faces including Nevinera) with the personality and text!

I died, huh? That sucks. Oh well. Thanks for the awesome game, INH!!

Also, sorry for the triple post, but for anyone who has said there is apparently no mafia role in the roles, look again. There is more than one role with *secrets* behind it. Just because there is no apparent NK doesn't mean that this is an LMS game. I do think it very unfair for it to be an LMS game if there is one of us killing at night as well.

Can anyone please explain to me how there is NOT a mafia in one of those three players' roles? It's absolutely absurd to think so, honestly. One player must be executing the kills, yes? How is it any coincidence that all three of you are still alive? Because the one of you that IS mafia and knows it isn't that stupid! They know their best chance to win is to keep your trio's voting block until the very end and then convince one of you that the other civvie one is bad, and then they win.

Nevinera wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:My vote doesn't seem to matter much at this point, so I went ahead and threw a vote at Nevinera just more of a message than anything.

I'm sorry, Snow and whoever else believes this, but anyone who thinks that there is NO mafia between Snowie, Nevinera, and llama is misguided because the mafia has consistently killed and you three have been in the game from the beginning. It's very evident to me that there is one mafia among those three.

I do, however, agree that it would make sense that there was a second player to join a mafia-aligned role when Kate, S~V~S, and I joined the game, and it's not me, so hopefully it is S~V~S. I'm not sure I believe this to be true as much as the former paragraph because we have evidence that mafia have been killing from the beginning and those three have been alive since the beginning. It's also very evident that whichever of you three IS mafia would LOVE to have that three-player voting block because then they have a very strong chance of winning the game. I disagree with you, Nev, that maintaining that block helps your chances. If anything, I would seriously consider voting one of your fellow voting block players out if you are not mafia, because one of them pretty much has to be.
There are no arguments here that are new or even really arguing in favor of anything. You make obvious statements, and then claim that they should imply specific behaviors.. But my reasons and logic are well documented, and yours are not even stated.

Why do you disagree? That's kind of the important part.

You think mine are not even stated? I stated them right there. Let me elaborate. Mafia have been killing at night. That requires that one of the roles that was given to one of these players to be a mafia role, one in which someone kills, yes?

I'm open to any possibility, sure, but how could a mafia be killing if they weren't here to kill for most of the black lodge's current existence?

Matahari wrote:
Nevinera wrote:Did you intend that vote to add you to the block?
I think we are all fine with that, but id like it to be clear :-)
Frankly, I consider this place to be purgatory. Its time to pay for my sins. I helped kill Llama, poor innocent llama, so I am ready to die for the ones who came before me.
* that means yes, I will help fight Bob and his minions for the trio.

Not sure that BoB and the gang truly have info on the mafia, because I know something else to be true. We are all mafia now. Last man standing, right?

Are you serious? Our white roles have nothing to do with alignment in this game. Why would they?

My vote doesn't seem to matter much at this point, so I went ahead and threw a vote at Nevinera just more of a message than anything.

I'm sorry, Snow and whoever else believes this, but anyone who thinks that there is NO mafia between Snowie, Nevinera, and llama is misguided because the mafia has consistently killed and you three have been in the game from the beginning. It's very evident to me that there is one mafia among those three.

I do, however, agree that it would make sense that there was a second player to join a mafia-aligned role when Kate, S~V~S, and I joined the game, and it's not me, so hopefully it is S~V~S. I'm not sure I believe this to be true as much as the former paragraph because we have evidence that mafia have been killing from the beginning and those three have been alive since the beginning. It's also very evident that whichever of you three IS mafia would LOVE to have that three-player voting block because then they have a very strong chance of winning the game. I disagree with you, Nev, that maintaining that block helps your chances. If anything, I would seriously consider voting one of your fellow voting block players out if you are not mafia, because one of them pretty much has to be.

Also, yes I am from PA! PA ftw.

Nevinera wrote: And one we have already drawn. But since civs don't win by killing all the mafia, the usual game plans are out.
The voting block is not related to that conclusion however, it is merely the best chance we each have at victory, mafia or not.

How do you figure this? I'm just curious. Because it seems to me a mafia is killing people every night. If this were an LMS game, would that not give the mafia member(s) an advantage?

I think, given that the mafia has killed from the BEGINNING of this Black Lodge game and given the "voting bloc" idea, that it's incredibly likely one of Snow Dog, llama, and Nevinera must be mafia. Is this not a sound conclusion?

ANNOUNCEMENT:

As an administrator and not a player, I am demanding that this conversation will be moved to private message so as to not be furthered in this game thread. This will NOT continue and the game will continue as planned from here.

Attempts to resolve this have been undertaken and it is not being moved privately in an attempt to 'hide' anything, so much as it is so that it can be properly discussed and resolved.

I want to clearly state that a primary goal at this site is to ensure that every member feel welcome and that the site feels like it is each member's own -- an aspiration I take incredibly seriously -- and this means bashing of a different sexual orientation, race, religion, etc. will NOT be tolerated, nor is it something that I believe is being fostered. If anyone ever believes it is, I would heavily appreciate being made aware immediately. With that being said, any accusation of such behavior is to be taken seriously and consequently should not be lightly made or handled.

Thank you.

The Syndicate

Search found 12 matches

Re: Twin Peaks Mafia BLACK LODGE: {GAME OVER}

Re: The Cake: Night 5

Re: TPBL: D4

Re: TPBL: D4

Re: Survivor: Black Lodge {EPISODE 1}

Re: Survivor: Black Lodge {EPISODE 1}

Re: Survivor: Black Lodge {EPISODE 1}

Re: Survivor: Black Lodge {EPISODE 1}

Re: Survivor: Black Lodge {EPISODE 1}

Re: Survivor: Black Lodge {EPISODE 1}

Re: Survivor: Black Lodge {EPISODE 1}

Re: TPM: Black Lodge {DAY 1}