The Syndicate

My biggest problem with it is that it doesn't stop people from voting randomly, there's no rule that says you need to have a reason to vote for someone and there's no reason why someone couldn't make one up if they had to.

When I vote randomly I use random.org to generate a random number, it seems more "fair" that way because if multiple people vote randomly, no one person is likely to suffer from it more than anyone else. This method would definitely cause some person to receive all random votes, which seems to defeat the purpose.

Edit: I realize there is a greater likelihood of a civ being randomly chosen, but I've never seen a baddie lynched with the first vote, so I'm not sure it would be any more harmful than if you didn't vote randomly.