The Syndicate

Scotty: Idk, I thought it was pretty self-explanatory why I thought Bubbles was bad. She was acting like she was cornered, all her posts sounded so so bad. What more do you want me to say? And as for my other suspicions, I've certainly explained a number of times why I suspect Bass, though again it...

Bass_the_Clever wrote:If I voted I would have voted Nutella or Cobalt.

Why?

And MM, welcome back! Did you learn anything or have any observations from your time off?

Sloonei, I'm reading through your ISO of ninja now. Her wishy-washy posts in Day 1 on SVS and LC are concerning, but it is also Day 1 and no one really knows anything. She does seem on the fence of both sig and GMan. Her suspicions throughout on both of them are weaksauce at best. Just looking at yo...

:sigh: You're gonna make me comb through your posts, are you? I'm gonna go ahead and vote for Bubbles. She is definitely my strongest baddie read at this point. Why? Bubbles is looking worse and worse, I think she is caught. I'm definitely planning to vote for her as of now. But it is also a good id...

Can someone check if these votes are changeable?

I'm gonna go ahead and vote for Bubbles. She is definitely my strongest baddie read at this point. You. Why? You've posted three times in this days phase, none of which were involved in talking about your suspicions. I'm also going to be looking at ninja, as per Sloonei's request, since she also ba...

Putting that mislynch aside for a sec...this poll is playing some serious mind games..

I'm not quite sure how to go about it yet.

Thanks for making it 48 hours, Dom! That's a big help as I will be in a boat all day tomorrow

Ugh. Damn, Tiny really was being genuine.

Now I'm pissed. Thought we could be infallible.

Golden wrote:
Sloonei wrote:Nobody's taking to my ninja case, i worked so hard on that thing
I just don't think its a case for today, but it's still an important one.

^This. I'm grilling and spending time with family right now, but I will look at it tomorrow. I promise!

Epignosis wrote:
Scotty wrote:The best part of this part of the day is waiting to see who bandwagons and why.
I already know why I plan to bandwagon.

I'm waiting with bated breath..

The best part of this part of the day is waiting to see who bandwagons and why.

That would be hilarious if he could insanify himself, though Cats doesn't seem like the type of role to do that. I would expect Lippa or even Jekyll and Hyde

I'm still watching MM, but I'm waiting on him to be unsilenced. I have done it yet, but I've also been looking at the gumshoe possibility. I really wanted to see what Mafia 2 does this next night however before I delve into people that haven't posted in a while. I'm slowly looking into BR, who I nev...

I honestly haven't looked into it. I'm trying to keep a strong focus on several people, with a soft soft focus on others. Ninja fits into that category. I'd equate her play to that of, like, fingersplints. From a glance, I see validity in your argument, but I feel like I still need to see more of ni...

Sloonei, for what it's worth, my reads at this moment in your shortlist from Mafia to Civ are: Tiny, BR, MM and ninja. Linki- ninja is the one to watch from the Les Mis Pm group. I don't think FZ was mafia. And I don't think you are. There is some validity in the theory that the mafia should have ha...

Also what happened to the insanifier? Not that I'm missing it.

Oh, I misunderstood. For some reason I had it in my mind you didn't change the vote, but had like a vigi ability to lynch. I'm currently sitting by the beachfront one so I apologize. I'll need to rethink my logic in a bit.

Ah ok that actually makes sense if you thought you could get 2 lynches in one day.

I know a guy with a striped shirt and claws that might be able to help you out

Sloonei wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:if y'all still need a replacement, lemme know.
I give it two real-time days before you're the thread's top poster.

Sloonei, do you ever sleep?

Put my vote in for long con, because there are far too many votes on cobalt right now, i dont trust that thre's not a scummy reason to get him lynched (even if he is mafia). Could be a willing sacrifice, to call attention away from the others. And long can has been slightly suspicious from the star...

My main concern about Sloonei is that if he is scum, every single one of his reads is strategic, and we have no IDEA what to actually trust. I'm not willing to take the risk of letting someone lead the general town consensus like that on every single other player. Way too risky. I do not think Sloo...

I go to sleep for 6 hours and I'm already behind a page. You vampires. Wow, so that was a very filling past few hours. Thanks for finally showing up Cobalt! After reading through your responses, I can safely say you've risen MUCH higher on my scale. You seem closer to -5 than my previous -15. Not co...

Golden wrote:I think DF's activity has increased slightly since you suggested he was bad.

With canuckle's logic, that's a bad thing, right?

OK, I wasn't asking about his lie. He even said he was lying. Do you think it's possible he could have pardoned himself?

Quick question- if Into the Woods is still alive, do you all think he/she pardons the one lynch during the day phase or night phase?

Because another thing that is giving me pause is that Cobalt could very much be Into the Woods. Am I wrong in thinking that is a possibility?

I'm basing my read off of what Cobalt talks about and what his actions are. Not responding to criticism in any capacity is, to be honest, shady. The 2 reasons that I am not autovoting Cobalt now, who is hovering at the top of my scum list, are the facts that: - I have a sneaking suspicion he was sil...

I just got an idea- I don't know as much about obscure roles as you vets, but do we know all Wildhorn posse kill on even nights? What if that is just Wildhorn, and Bonnie and Clyde can kill on odd nights? But like, they only have 2 stocks (1 for Bonnie and 1 for Clyde). That would explain why only C...

I'm not deadset on Faraday right now to be honest. That's probably the biggest thing I don't agree with on your rainbow list, Sloonei. He did appear like he could have been blendy but at the same time I feel like some of his observations (to my memory) reminded me of timmer's play. And timmer actual...

Also MetalMarsh, id love to hear your thoughts on Cobalt, since you voted for him.
That fact and the fact that Cobalt may very well be silenced right now is giving me pause.

So am I on LC's team or Sig's? Sorry I had no suspicion on Sig until he was outed by himself. I don't think I defended LC ALL game. I did say I didn't think he killed Epig and I was right. Who are you trying to lead the lynch away from today Timmer? Oh BR, you aren't going to... NO U me.... are you...

I'm hoping to reply to Sloonei and other peoples concerns about me later. Finally have my internet working a bit better. However, I am suddenly faced with being in the situation where my relationship is breaking down and it's causing me a great deal of stress abd causing me to care a lot less about...

inb4 G-Man either bombs or somehow survives this phase What was the point of this post? Also, who do you guys think was silenced today, if anyone? Could be Cobalt. Could be DREAM. I have this theory that DREAM has continually been silenced every day since Day 0, and is just WAITING to explode with ...

Earlier in my catch-up I was feeling that Cobalt was deffo bad, but the fact that he hasn't yet lived up to his promise to be more engaged actually makes me less suspicious of him (contrary to Sloonei's opposite thought). I just think the impetus to clean up your image and contribute is much strong...

Only West Side Story and wildhorn, other than the one you and scotty got. what's the gist of the west side story role? It sounds like a massacre. If I were a Jet, I'd shark the hell outta dodge. linki- I've deciphered the thing, Sloonei, but go ahead and give a whack at it. I think it's a good thin...

Btw no dice on sending the deciphered PM to Dom. I literally have no idea why Into the Woods was revealed

linki- It was me, sloonei and ninja (and FZ), not nutella that got the other PM

@Golden - Sorry I probably sound like a righteous ass right about now. You are correct in that I'm probably suffering from groupthink. But I think that any stooge can solve the play in the PM. I'm all for what's in the best interest of the town- I just have to assume there's a good chance a mafia ca...

Scotty - never assume the mafia has a player who can solve those messages. Fewer people are good at it than you think, even with crowd think abilities. There are two different mafia teams out there as well. You didn't say whether you had the same message. Oh, I thought I answered that way back when...

Based on a tradition 'mafia two kills even nights' reading, Clyde trying to kill Bass is out of synch. That's why I want to know Bonnie and Clyde's role, because maybe they can kill off different nights. I would hope that we would get some sort of lead-up if teams were able to kill every night. @sc...

A couple things to be gleaned from this scene. 1) I have no idea what song these singers could be parodying. Too many unique words. Could be a whole bunch of anything. I'll keep researching. 2) Bass is not on team Wildhorn at least. 3) Bass probably had protection of some sort if Bonnie and Clyde di...

Hmm...interesting kill. I had a civ read on FZ, but we won't know.

And that disproves my theory that their roles show up when they're NK'd. Bummer. All around weird pick. Guess we go through FZ's posts for clues.

Heh. Yeah. Sorry about it MM. I'm pretty sporadic in my accusations, but also you were curious yesterday on when I would have more details on my thoughts. So it's not just you. I have more, but those stuck out to me right now

OK. Getting settled in at home. I'm gonna be driving to the beach tomorrow all day so I'll be attentive while I can. To sum up: The mafia is probably getting very frustrated right now, and rightly so. We're doing God's work, sonn. Backtracking to respond to MM: I'm not going back on what I previous...

I thought you had previously stated that you were suspicious of Cobalt because of his interactions with Long Con, who would be a member of Mafia 2. Which team do you think it's more likely Cobalt would belong to? I think the mafia 1 case is stronger than the mafia 2 case. But yes, I do recognise my...

So I'm currently packing and am traveling all tomorrow. I plan to do some drafting on my flight as well as hopefully get around to reading and responding to Golden/Sloonei's chronicles. Either way, looks like there's a lot to talk about this night phase!

Also I love that speech, Dom. It was my college audition monologue, that.

Lol Gman giant troll. Just like Cats. Wow we're doing terrific. Can we go perfect?
Welcome back, Sloonei!
Also, nights are by far the best time for discussion, what with this silencing thing on big talkers.

Thanks Dom! Hope this works.

I apparently don't know how to embed pictures.

Cheers, all!

Search found 16821 matches