The Syndicate

What replacement? She's only going to be replaced if she asks to. But what she did was vote for herself instead. I agree that aether surviving through day 5 (and possibly longer) is a travesty, though. I think what TH is saying that is unlikely anyone would want to sub in at this point. It's probab...

fingersplints wrote:Behind the scenes contact

Yeah, this.

I'm about as new with this jargon as you are, aether.

acrosstheaether wrote:Wouldn't that be BTST then?

Sorry it's chat, not talk.

acrosstheaether wrote:What does BTSC stand for?

Behind The Scenes Talk. In other words, the ability to talk with other members of your faction outside the thread.

What replacement? She's only going to be replaced if she asks to. But what she did was vote for herself instead.

I agree that aether surviving through day 5 (and possibly longer) is a travesty, though.

Where I come from we assume they always do unless stated otherwise.

Vompatti wrote:There's less mafia than civilians though and they don't even have BTSC in this game and no I have not read the thread.

Who doesn't have BTSC? Mafia?

I don't Roxy's giving up says much about whether she's a civ or not. What says that is the content of her posts, the way she interacted with other players, and her votes. And those scream "bad", and have doing that for a while. But Roxy's giving up tells us that we should lynch her now rat...

Vompatti wrote:Even if she won't be playing I'm not voting for a likely civ and I don't know why any other civ would either.

*votes G*

Why do you think she is a likely civ?

Well, vote Roxy then.

RL or not, she still had a lot of behaviors in the game that could be seen as mafia, and if she isn't gonna stay around to try to improve that, then she has to be removed.

I wish you good luck in your RL, though. I hope this isn't the last game I play with you.

Another thing, yes, this game has been a lot more intense than it should've been. This is probably the most intense game I've ever played, and I've played games with up to 50 players. I think I'm probably a little to blame for that. Thing is, it's easy to get excited when you're in new forum, speci...

Apparently she just voted for herself. Doesn't seem like someone who will ask to be replaced.

G-Man's story is amazing. I don't think he made it up, it's a pretty good explanation for why has has been posting pictures, and i certainly makes for a very memorable game. Also I think it gave me a very good idea for a game. Has anyone ever tried to host a game that only allowed pictures? Like oth...

So I finally had the courage to read all of JJJ's interaction analysis of Black Rock. I don't have much to say about them, other than the fact I noticed Golden said he was gonna do one of those between BR/JJJ, but it doesn't seem him or anyone else ever did it. Someone point it out to me in case I'm...

Go study MP.

MP's dog peeing made my morning! So funny!!! I can see a scenario where DDL is bad and trying to push the vote on to G-Man off Roxy (actually because I already viewed the DDL/G-Man thing as DDL being sus and GMan being civ, its not so surprising I see it that way), so I'm definitely preferring a ro...

Lastly, I got a bit of a chuckle at Rox painting my posts as "hostile" and isn't sure whether she deserves it. I don't sincerely believe she thinks that, and I'm all the more ready to vote for her, but I'll at least give her a chance to defend herself tonight. Idc if you do not think it r...

bwt was my number 2 suspect on Day 3. One of the reasons was because of his somewhat inconsistent activity. Then he got replaced, which gave him the perfect alibi for not being active. I still think his Day 2 vote, combined with his explanations of it and what I perceived as hipocrisy in his analys...

I've only played one game by a host that gave hints like that. It was an incredibly shitty and inbalanced game. It was the first mafia game I played in the internet, and it made me question my decision of playing mafia in the internet. So excuse me if I don't see host hints with good eyes. I still t...

Take your time, G-Man. Real life is sacred.

But you better have a really good explanation because right now you're somewhere between the "scummier than scum" and the "kill it before it lays eggs" tiers of my imaginary rainbow list.

Before I talk about some other ideas I've had regarding players, I have some questions for all of you guys. Everyone : - How are you reading G-Man, under the assumption that he is cursed somehow to post in only pictures? - How do you read G-Man, if instead you were to find out with certainty that h...

I am not angry or distressed and I am still getting suspicion. :shrug2: So not sure why you say I am only calm when I am not getting suspected. I don't think you know me well enough to keep generalizing my behavior like this. There is a shit ton of my posts that haven't been 'emotional' as well. I ...

If I wake up tomorrow and don't see a decent explanation, he's getting my vote.

G-Man wrote:

So... Do you want me to vote you right now, or after you try to explain why you have been trolling us for the entire game?

This was probably the last one. Other players I either think they're town, or have nothing much to add. I'm still trying to figure out what I think on G-Man, for example.

Thoughts on Bass: My opinion of him has dropped a lot lately. First, there's my Adam Smith tinfoily theory, whose weaknesses I recognize, but still think it's more likely than not. But other than that, Bass usefulness in the game has become nearly null in the last few phases. He disappears for the w...

JJJ - good overall, but I'm slightly uncomfortable that he's still alive (then again what if mafia wants us to feel this way :scared: ) I'm having this feeling since the game started. JJJ is my biggest "I honestly hope he isn't mafia or we're fucked" player. I wish Sloonei was here, he se...

Thoughts on splints: This one is hard to read. She has been all over the place lately in this game. First there was the whole stuff with the BR tunneling, the weird aether vote on D3 which could suggest bussing, the arguing with MP... None of those things really make her a big suspect. They are all ...

Thoughts on birdwithteeth/Golden 2.0 bwt was my number 2 suspect on Day 3. One of the reasons was because of his somewhat inconsistent activity. Then he got replaced, which gave him the perfect alibi for not being active. I still think his Day 2 vote, combined with his explanations of it and what I ...

acrosstheaether wrote:In fact I'm tempted to go ahead and vote for myself. My flip is gonna give the rest of my fellow libertarians a heckuva lotta information.

Go ahead, it will save us a lot of the energy that has been focused trying to argue with you and being ignored.

Seriously, everyone, G-Man is fucking faking this shit. Let's be honest here. - If he were cursed, it's highly dubious that it would have taken effect as early as Day 1, before any night actions could be submitted. It also cannot be due to the D0 poll because literally NO ONE else has had this prob...

fingersplints wrote:MP right now reminds me of a dog who is so excited he is just peeing all over everything.

Also MP, to answer your question, if I had to vote right now, I'd bet on my own theory and vote Bass.

I don't wanna vote right now, though.

Thoughts on MP: I refuse to do a full read on his posts because I want to preserve my own sanity. :pout: Day 1 I suspected him because of his somewhat artificial defense of him. I still think that was artificial, but again, that's me being naturally suspicious of people defending me when everyone el...

MovingPictures07 wrote: 666. BR, Jay, MP, Turnip

Add Sloonei to the mix, if that was still possible. You have an incredibly scary team.

Let's do some reads. Thoughts on Roxy: At first, I was suspicious of her because of her Golden "defends-then-disappears-as-he's-lynched" thing. Her explanation about real life was legit enough, but didn't change the fact the whole Golden thing could be easily exploited by scum. She was a l...

Turnip Head wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I have several mafia team scenarios going around in my head at the moment. What do players think of these?

7. BR, DDL, Turnip, Roxy

etc.
This is the best one.

I'd surrender right away if someone told me I had to face that team.

Do you think he is the one responsible for your posting restriction? I still am not sure what's causing it, but when rereading just him I noticed this post: Hey G-Man, are you even allowed to write full texts in images like that? :shifty: I agree other lynches may produce more information. But dunn...

DDL, what do you think of aether? Has your opinion changed at all? Still think she's scummy af. However, I thought about Jay's points that he made yesterday about her and they are valid, and I gotta admit I don't know her meta. I still believe a lynch of her has a good chance of producing a mafia f...

fingersplints wrote:I disagree that I "threw a tantrum"

When did I "stop posting"? I was literally only gone for 12 hours as I slept and then walked my dog

You should notice this is pretty much speculation at this point. You didn't stop posting.

But yes, you threw a tantrum.

Fair enough. I still think the possibility of you bussing BR is rather low. But ragequitting won't do yourself any favors. If you go "just lynch me", we'll have to lynch you. You should stay here and keep discussing. I did not quit. But I see the way this is going. If you think I am not g...

Did you even read the post I wrote that explained the theory. It was based on Adam Smith's kill of Epi, and TinyBubbles' votes in the phase. That has nothing to do with hosts revealing roles though. Hosts in this game reveal the name of the killer by default, and that is done in most of the games I'...

I still don't get why you think one thing has to do with the other one. I've said over and over the Invisible Hand thing isn't evidence for jack shit. You keep putting words in my mouth and pretending I think it is. But to answer your question, I'm on the fence now. Not because of the Invisible Hand...

For the third time: I said it was a COINCIDENCE. I didn't build my theory on some video a host posted. I built it on info that came before, and has been coming since Night 1. And now that I notice the write-up is called "Invisible Hands". I doubt hosts would give away roles like this, but ...

No, it's the opposite. I think the hosts would have no problem saying that hole performed the kill, but won't reveal the role of the player who died in the night.

i could dig a full reads list from DDL especially. tbh I don't do those often. I usually do it once in the beginning for the sake of estabilishing what I think of each player, but then as the game moves and things happen I focus on those instead. I'll try to organize my thoughts tomorrow and see if...

I'm gonna wait till tomorrow to answer that. I wanna read some isolated posts, but I'm sleepy.

G-Man, what I mean is, it's one thing for the host to give away the name of the role who used the ability that is appearing in the write-up. He did that on N1 for the Epi kill. But naming a role in the title of the write-up and posting a video about them is blatant role hinting, and good hosts don't...

https://i.imgflip.com/m5hg5.jpg Nope. I think the invisible hand thing is just a coincidence. Hosts usually don't give hints like that. https://i.imgflip.com/m5htt.jpg Don't see how. I just don't think the Invisible Hand thing is relevant at all, whatever it could possibly mean. My theory was built...

G-Man wrote:
Spoiler: show

Nope. I think the invisible hand thing is just a coincidence. Hosts usually don't give hints like that.

Search found 11623 matches